Are SAKs Multi Tools
-
@ratslash7 said:
I haven't voted yet because I haven't figured it out yet.According to Wikipedia:
A multi-tool is a portable, versatile hand tool that combines several individual tool functions in a single grip or in the shape of a credit card.
so the answer is YES and LMs are not

-
I haven't voted yet because I haven't figured it out yet.
According to Wikipedia:
A multi-tool is a portable, versatile hand tool that combines several individual tool functions in a single grip or in the shape of a credit card.
so the answer is YES and LMs are not

Wikipedia ::) ::)
-
I haven't voted yet because I haven't figured it out yet.
According to Wikipedia:
A multi-tool is a portable, versatile hand tool that combines several individual tool functions in a single grip or in the shape of a credit card.
so the answer is YES and LMs are not

Wikipedia ::) ::)
Yeah, I know. I was looking for a definitive answer and that's the closest I could find...on the internet anyway. Perhaps ans unabridged dictionary? I don't have one.
Maybe it's up to us to define multitool?
-
I think it's pretty black and white to me. A multitool has multiple tools, hence the name. Pliers are one of the many possible tools. I consider a SAK with more than just blades (such as the screwdriver/bottle-opener/can-opener) to have multiple uses besides just a knife and a SAK with only blades is just a folding knife.
-
the fact is "multitool" isn't a proper word and isn't in any official dictionary, the correct term is "multi-tool", a compound of multi, meaning many, and tool, defined as:
tool (plural tools)
-
A mechanical device intended to make a task easier.
Hand me that tool, would you? -
Equipment used in a profession, e.g., tools of the trade.
These are the tools of the trade. -
Something to perform an operation; an instrument; a means.
-
(computing) A piece of software used to develop software or hardware.
The software engineer had been developing lots of EDA tools. -
A person or group which is used or controlled, usually unwittingly, by another person or group.
He was a tool, no more than a pawn to her. -
(slang) smurf.
so, yes, it is anything with many tools.
-
-
@Whoey said:
I think it's pretty black and white to me. A multitool has multiple tools, hence the name. Pliers are one of the many possible tools. I consider a SAK with more than just blades (such as the screwdriver/bottle-opener/can-opener) to have multiple uses besides just a knife and a SAK with only blades is just a folding knife.Exactly my point :)
-
In my book it doesn't matter if a SAK has multiple tools, it is still a SAK... :)
Just a Swiss Army Knife with tools.. ;) -
@AHB said:
In my book it doesn't matter if a SAK has multiple tools, it is still a SAK... :)
Just a Swiss Army Knife with tools.. ;)A SAK is still a SAK even if it has 1000 functions in my book as well.
All this definition talk is all very well and good, but it gives a definition for the masses and for your average Joe. What I am talking about is for guys in the know like us and for us I'd say a SAK is a SAK and a MT is a MT and a couple of people that have voted yes have talked along similar lines as well.
-
A couple of other things to consider...
We have multitool.org AND sosakonline. If SAK's were simply MT's why have both?
We have a SAKwiki and a MTwiki and there are no SAK's on the MT one at all. Again if they were all MT's why have both?
Bottom line is, I do think quite a few of you that have voted yes are thinking to broadly and not in our little world as the bottom line is that if I flashed this;

...on the screen you all think SAK and not MT.
Oh and BTW, that pic was taken from heinnies from the "knife" section as they don't have SAK's in the tool section. ;)
That's where I stand anyway (not that it matters at all of course).

-
-
@Benner said:
Bottom line is, I do think quite a few of you that have voted yes are thinking to broadly and not in our little world as the bottom line is that if I flashed this;

...on the screen you all think SAK and not MT.
Flawed logic. If you flashed a kick or a blast many of us would think Leatherman first. If you flashed a box of tissues some of us would think kleenex. SAK is very much a label for a brand(s) or a type of product. Not only that, it could be considered a subgroup or secondary label for a multi-tool. Just because we think of it first doesn't mean it doesn't fall under other categories. =|
Any type of SAK (except for a solo or setinel... or that ranger... anything else I'm missing?) is a multi-tool BY DEFINITION.
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Any type of SAK (except for a solo or setinel) is a multi-tool BY DEFINITION.No it isn't...

:D :D
-
I love how you just happened to forget my other bits in that post Froggy. ;)
Oh and no I don't see it as flawed logic personally. Do you ever think, hmmm look at that SAK multitool? I bet you do with LM, Gerber, CRKT and all the others though ey

-
@Benner said:
I love how you just happened to forget my other bits in that post Froggy. ;)Oh and no I don't see it as flawed logic personally. Do you ever think, hmmm look at that SAK multitool? I bet you do with LM, Gerber, CRKT and all the others though ey

Uhh, yes, acutally. I find not a lot of people around me are used to the acronyms you folk are so I usually just say multitool. Or Swiss multitool.
And I left out the rest of your post because it was useless drivel. :P
As there is no standards body the creation of two sites were based on Def's opinion (not even, maybe for a technical reason or on a whim)... that being said I've often wanted sosak to just fall under mt.org... would make my life easier. I rarely associate with SOSAK because I'm lazy. And there's enough SAK people on here anyway. =PActually, by your reasoning since SAKs are mentioned on MT.org, the SAK is indeed a multi-tool. ::)
EDIT: WHY ARE YOU ARGUING AGAINST JEEVE'S LAW?!
-
@Benner said:
I love how you just happened to forget my other bits in that post Froggy. ;)Oh and no I don't see it as flawed logic personally. Do you ever think, hmmm look at that SAK multitool? I bet you do with LM, Gerber, CRKT and all the others though ey

But we are geeks; if you show us a picture of a Blast we instinctively call it a Blast, that's also a LM, that's also a MT. If you show a Farmer, we see a Farmer, that's also a Vic, that's also a SAK, that is also a MT.
-
It is separate as they are 2 different things (again IMO). The only MT's by Vic are the Spirit, Swisstool etc and like on the wiki, that is why you only see those on there and not a huge list of SAK's.
But this again is just my opinion.
-
I love how you just happened to forget my other bits in that post Froggy. ;)
Oh and no I don't see it as flawed logic personally. Do you ever think, hmmm look at that SAK multitool? I bet you do with LM, Gerber, CRKT and all the others though ey

But we are geeks; if you show us a picture of a Blast we instinctively call it a Blast, that's also a LM, that's also a MT. If you show a Farmer, we see a Farmer, that's also a Vic, that's also a SAK, that is also a MT.
My point is that I don't.
When I say saw a Kick, in my head I see a 'Leatherman Kick multitool', I never see a "Vic Farmer SAK Multitool' it is just a 'Vic Farmer SAK'.
-
@Freudian Frog said:
I love how you just happened to forget my other bits in that post Froggy. ;)
Oh and no I don't see it as flawed logic personally. Do you ever think, hmmm look at that SAK multitool? I bet you do with LM, Gerber, CRKT and all the others though ey

Uhh, yes, acutally. I find not a lot of people around me are used to the acronyms you folk are so I usually just say multitool. Or Swiss multitool.
And I left out the rest of your post because it was useless drivel. :P
As there is no standards body the creation of two sites were based on Def's opinion (not even, maybe for a technical reason or on a whim)... that being said I've often wanted sosak to just fall under mt.org... would make my life easier. I rarely associate with SOSAK because I'm lazy. And there's enough SAK people on here anyway. =PActually, by your reasoning since SAKs are mentioned on MT.org, the SAK is indeed a multi-tool. ::)
EDIT: WHY ARE YOU ARGUING AGAINST JEEVE'S LAW?!
So are bags, phones, hair cuts, dogs cats.... are they multitools as well then? No. Just because it's discussed here makes no odds.
And again you are looking at a definition aimed at the average Joe user. We aren't those here.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
(not that it matters at all of course) ;)
