Are SAKs Multi Tools
-
Plenty of people identify cars wrong... doesn't stop making them cars, nor whatever manfacturer they are. >=(
And sorry, if you're being serious about the "scientific" part of that test I'm going to have to let the handle fly, into your face! :D
-
This reminds me of the "Pop/Soda" debate. LOL!
-
-
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Plenty of people identify cars wrong... doesn't stop making them cars, nor whatever manfacturer they are. >=(And sorry, if you're being serious about the "scientific" part of that test I'm going to have to let the handle fly, into your face! :D
If MT's are cars, think of SAK's as aircraft. Sure they both transport goods/people from A-B (or in our case, cut, screw, whatever) but a Plane is not a car is it. It is something else designed to do a similar job just executed in a different way. That is how I see SAK's to MT's.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Why does Ben have to keep defending his position when he's clearly right :P
no amount of hair putty can achieve that.
Speaking of which, I think we can prove that there is no correlation between the points in Benner's hair and the amount of points he is considered right on... :D
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Plenty of people identify cars wrong... doesn't stop making them cars, nor whatever manfacturer they are. >=(
And sorry, if you're being serious about the "scientific" part of that test I'm going to have to let the handle fly, into your face! :D
If MT's are cars, think of SAK's as aircraft. Sure they both transport goods/people from A-B (or in our case, cut, screw, whatever) but a Plane is not a car is it. It is something else designed to do a similar job just executed in a different way. That is how I see SAK's to MT's.
If you do that, it'd be Butterfly MT's are cars, SAK's are aircraft, and MT's are vehicles, sir...
And CRKT would produce segways or something.
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Plenty of people identify cars wrong... doesn't stop making them cars, nor whatever manfacturer they are. >=(
And sorry, if you're being serious about the "scientific" part of that test I'm going to have to let the handle fly, into your face! :D
If MT's are cars, think of SAK's as aircraft. Sure they both transport goods/people from A-B (or in our case, cut, screw, whatever) but a Plane is not a car is it. It is something else designed to do a similar job just executed in a different way. That is how I see SAK's to MT's.
I quite like that analogy .... but in the spirit of keeping things well stirred
I'll chuck into the pot.... if SAKs are not MTs and this is MT.O then why do so many of the members spend so much time talking about SAKs? ;) -
Again, your "Vehicle" logic is one aimed at the masses. Going one higher, you could claim that anything we use are tools, be it a car, a screwdriver or anything really. I am talking about here at MTO.
-
@Benner said:
Again, your "Vehicle" logic is one aimed at the masses. Going one higher, you could claim that anything we use are tools, be it a car, a screwdriver or anything really. I am talking about here at MTO.So you're claiming that only in the realm of MT.O SAK's are not considered as MT's?
... what? Generalization exists for a purpose...
And yes, both a car and a screwdriver is a tool. :D
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Plenty of people identify cars wrong... doesn't stop making them cars, nor whatever manfacturer they are. >=(
And sorry, if you're being serious about the "scientific" part of that test I'm going to have to let the handle fly, into your face! :D
If MT's are cars, think of SAK's as aircraft. Sure they both transport goods/people from A-B (or in our case, cut, screw, whatever) but a Plane is not a car is it. It is something else designed to do a similar job just executed in a different way. That is how I see SAK's to MT's.
I quite like that analogy .... but in the spirit of keeping things well stirred
I'll chuck into the pot.... if SAKs are not MTs and this is MT.O then why do so many of the members spend so much time talking about SAKs? ;)But why do so many talk about my hair (lol :D) and Maxpedition gear? They are things we have a common interest in.
And since when Neil has there EVER been an on topic thread or post here at MTO?! :D

(and the word I wanted was analogy - thanks Neil ;))
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Plenty of people identify cars wrong... doesn't stop making them cars, nor whatever manfacturer they are. >=(
And sorry, if you're being serious about the "scientific" part of that test I'm going to have to let the handle fly, into your face! :D
If MT's are cars, think of SAK's as aircraft. Sure they both transport goods/people from A-B (or in our case, cut, screw, whatever) but a Plane is not a car is it. It is something else designed to do a similar job just executed in a different way. That is how I see SAK's to MT's.
I quite like that analogy .... but in the spirit of keeping things well stirred
I'll chuck into the pot.... if SAKs are not MTs and this is MT.O then why do so many of the members spend so much time talking about SAKs? ;)But why do so many talk about my hair (lol :D) and Maxpedition gear? They are things we have a common interest in.
And since when Neil has there EVER been an on topic thread or post here at MTO?! :D

(and the word I wanted was analogy - thanks Neil ;))
I believe your hair makes you a tool (just kidding! ... almost... but you're multi-talented!), and we all need something to put all our tools in. :D
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Again, your "Vehicle" logic is one aimed at the masses. Going one higher, you could claim that anything we use are tools, be it a car, a screwdriver or anything really. I am talking about here at MTO.
So you're claiming that only in the realm of MT.O SAK's are not considered as MT's?
... what? Generalization exists for a purpose...
And yes, both a car and a screwdriver is a tool. :D
You have missed the point.
And yes they are all tools, but they aren't all multitools ;)
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Again, your "Vehicle" logic is one aimed at the masses. Going one higher, you could claim that anything we use are tools, be it a car, a screwdriver or anything really. I am talking about here at MTO.
So you're claiming that only in the realm of MT.O SAK's are not considered as MT's?
... what? Generalization exists for a purpose...
And yes, both a car and a screwdriver is a tool. :D
You have missed the point.
And yes they are all tools, but they aren't all multitools ;)
Then you sir, need to further clarify your point. ;)
@Freudian Frog said:
This reminds me of the "Pop/Soda" debate. LOL!
Since some call it Soda Pop can we just call them Multitool SAKs? :(
Froggie, why are you arguing at all? I've been in chat with you and I've never heard you refer to SAK's as MT SAK's so there! :P ;)
You know I like to argue. XD
And I truly believe in proper definitions. =(
And you're not in chat anymore so you're just a big poopy head. :( -
A butter knife is intended to spread condiments on bread. Therefore it is not a tool, however, there have been times when I have used a butter knife as a flat head screwdriver as I had nothing else at hand (bad Whoey, learn to EDC more!).
I don't think there is a logic where a SAK is not a multitool, there is a logic however that a multitool is not a SAK
-
@Freudian Frog said:
Plenty of people identify cars wrong... doesn't stop making them cars, nor whatever manfacturer they are. >=(
And sorry, if you're being serious about the "scientific" part of that test I'm going to have to let the handle fly, into your face! :D
If MT's are cars, think of SAK's as aircraft. Sure they both transport goods/people from A-B (or in our case, cut, screw, whatever) but a Plane is not a car is it. It is something else designed to do a similar job just executed in a different way. That is how I see SAK's to MT's.
I quite like that analogy .... but in the spirit of keeping things well stirred
I'll chuck into the pot.... if SAKs are not MTs and this is MT.O then why do so many of the members spend so much time talking about SAKs? ;)But why do so many talk about my hair (lol :D) and Maxpedition gear? They are things we have a common interest in.
And since when Neil has there EVER been an on topic thread or post here at MTO?! :D

(and the word I wanted was analogy - thanks Neil ;))
There was that time in December '07... but I think you took it out back and shot it

Your hair isn't a MT ??? I think you forget the thread that discussed it as both edc armory and pigeon defences ;)
-
@Whoey said:
A butter knife is intended to spread condiments on bread. Therefore it is not a tool, however, there have been times when I have used a butter knife as a flat head screwdriver as I had nothing else at hand (bad Whoey, learn to EDC more!).I don't think there is a logic where a SAK is not a multitool, there is a logic however that a multitool is not a SAK
I too gave this some thought, and decided to classify based on the manufacturer's intentions.

-
@Freudian Frog said:
A butter knife is intended to spread condiments on bread. Therefore it is not a tool, however, there have been times when I have used a butter knife as a flat head screwdriver as I had nothing else at hand (bad Whoey, learn to EDC more!).
I don't think there is a logic where a SAK is not a multitool, there is a logic however that a multitool is not a SAK
I too gave this some thought, and decided to classify based on the manufacturer's intentions.

The manufactures intentions being multitools for Leatherman etc, and knives for the Swiss army from Vic yeah :P
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
