Are SAKs Multi Tools
-
Ok question what MT did you carry today? answer oh I carried a SAK escort
just doesn't have that MT feel about it IMO :D -
Actually that wasn't correct, they would fit into that Sub catergory of SAK's known as knock offs.
-
I want to know where CAK's stand in all this should we start calling them MT's as well

Yes they are also
MTsSAKs... just not very good ones!;) :D
Oi, bugger up your own ramblings not mine :D How can CAKs be SAKs when they are not Swiss?I was a bit late, so the answer is one above your last post. :D
-
How about this
What is this:

And this:

you likly said Shark (or great white) and Fish (or Crapie), but is the Shark not as much a fish as the Crapie? there
-
I'd say the Shark was the equivalent of a Surge, and the Fish a CRKT Guppie (see what I did there
:D).A SAK would be a squid. :D
-
@Benner said:
A couple of other things to consider...We have multitool.org AND sosakonline. If SAK's were simply MT's why have both?
to increase advertising revenue? ducks

-
Hehe! :D
-
@Benner said:
I'd say the Shark was the equivalent of a Surge, and the Fish a CRKT Guppie (see what I did there
:D).A SAK would be a squid. :D
I would say SAKs are Sharks (top of the cool list), SwissCards are Rays, and leathermen type MTs are normal Fish.
But squids are really cool :D I love cephalopods
-
I can't be arsed to read all the pages, but has anyone pointed out that SAK stands for Swiss Army Knife? Not Swiss Army Multitool.
Whilst a SAK clearly (sometimes at least) have "multiple tools", it would also be correct to define them as "multi purpose knives and tools fabricated from steel and fabric". The point is though, that noone does - they (including the manufacturers and most retailers) call them Swiss Army knives. Victorinox don't describe the Swisstool or the Spirit as Swiss Army Knives, they distinguish quite clearly between them.
It works the other way too. Leatherman describe their similarly formatted knives with drivers (e.g. e306) as knives, again, distinct from their multitools.
All this "well they have multiple tools" is pure semantics.
-
Tell' em Dave! :D That is why we use MT & SAK, not SAT or MK. :D
-
@DaveK said:
I can't be arsed to read all the pages, but has anyone pointed out that SAK stands for Swiss Army Knife? Not Swiss Army Multitool.Whilst a SAK clearly (sometimes at least) have "multiple tools", it would also be correct to define them as "multi purpose knives and tools fabricated from steel and fabric". The point is though, that noone does - they (including the manufacturers and most retailers) call them Swiss Army knives. Victorinox don't describe the Swisstool or the Spirit as Swiss Army Knives, they distinguish quite clearly between them.
It works the other way too. Leatherman describe their similarly formatted knives with drivers (e.g. e306) as knives, again, distinct from their multitools.
All this "well they have multiple tools" is pure semantics.
cant really argue with any of that.
-
I can't be arsed to read all the pages, but has anyone pointed out that SAK stands for Swiss Army Knife? Not Swiss Army Multitool.
Whilst a SAK clearly (sometimes at least) have "multiple tools", it would also be correct to define them as "multi purpose knives and tools fabricated from steel and fabric". The point is though, that noone does - they (including the manufacturers and most retailers) call them Swiss Army knives. Victorinox don't describe the Swisstool or the Spirit as Swiss Army Knives, they distinguish quite clearly between them.
It works the other way too. Leatherman describe their similarly formatted knives with drivers (e.g. e306) as knives, again, distinct from their multitools.
All this "well they have multiple tools" is pure semantics.
cant really argue with any of that.
Yes. It's semantics. That's exactly the point. What the heck? ::)
-
So can we say that it is the format that dictates the nomenclature? i.e. a tool that is in a folding knife format is referred to as a "knife" no matter what other tools are included...Or is it a "Swiss Army Knife? (If I have a knife that has two blades and a can opener, is that a SAK or just a knife? What if it's made in Taiwan?)... and a tool that is based on pliers, scissors or even folding pliers will be referred to as a multi-tool?
If this is right,where does this tool (mentioned earlier in this thread) fit in?
I'm not arguing with anyone. I have read this thread through a couple of times and I don't know which side to take. Both make excellent points. I like to use the right words for things and I thought it was easy 'till this thread. I'd love it if us experts could straighten this out and (mostly) agree. Then I could feel confident that I'm correctly describing what's in my pocket to folks that are not on this board.
-
I really don't see what's so fudging hard to get about this. Multi-tool is an umbrella term for any tool that provides more than one friggin' function. There's nothing to get. Most SAKs are both a swiss army knife (it's swiss made, it has a knife, sometimes their army uses it?) and a multi-tool (it's more than a knife! except for the single-blade models)! A leatherman is a multi-tool often in a butterfly plier type format!
WHAT IS THERE TO GET?! ArGH!11
I'm going to cry myself to sleep now. Some people need to learn about data structures or something...
-
Whilst Frog cries, I will answer your question ratslash.
Going by MY criteria, that is a multitool. Although it is a Wenger product, it fits in the MT bracket the same way a Vic Swisstool would.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
:D
