2010 Shot - Multitasker
-
@J-sews said:
I was browsing the Rock River Arms site just this afternoon :) but I need someone to explain to me the pros and cons of gas guns versus piston guns :-[For civilian use, you should be fine with a direct impingement setup as long as you follow some sensible maintenance routine. An AR is not an AK >:D
Some of these new piston designs are unproven too - never a good thing for a retrofit design IMO.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Got one in mind?
And why do I get the feeling your wife is going to want to test your new AR15 on me? :o
Def
Not to worry....she prefers strangulation to gunfire, and I am the sole beneficiary of her ill intent. :P :D
I was browsing the Rock River Arms site just this afternoon :) but I need someone to explain to me the pros and cons of gas guns versus piston guns :-[
I can't add much to what donvito said, but I would say that for most purposes I would go DI. BTW, If you can afford a little more than a Rock River, you might want to look at BCM(bravo company).
-
Bob, you should browse the Equipment Exchange forum on AR15.com
http://www.ar15.com/forums/forum.html?b=7&f=21
and EE on M4Carbine.net
-
any chance of you selling the bit carrier separately? It has to be one of the best bit carriers I have seen.

-
@Multitaskertools said:
OK, Series2 vs original 1st Gen pics as promised (sorry for the quality, shot with a point and shoot)Series2 (CNC billet toolsteel) pliers on the LEFT. 1st Gen pliers (cast 420ss) on the RIGHT; the prototype Series2 did not have time to get the QPQ Mellonite treatment - production units will. The place that does the treatment also handles a lot of engine component work for Toyota, so Im thinking they have more slots open to take my work now


Series2 vs. 1st Gen tool bit driver comparision pics:


The new bit driver uses a magnet to hold in the bits, much easier to insert, and it allows me to use the more elegant tool bit holder, which integrates nicely into the new improved carrying pouch. Overall, just much more refined.
In order to make room for the new accessory slot that accomodates the dental pick/optional PIN PUNCH/Otis cleaning kit cable, we had to cut away a portion of the grip panel and also scallop out part of the bit driver

more pics to follow...
Nice pics!

-
I was browsing the Rock River Arms site just this afternoon :) but I need someone to explain to me the pros and cons of gas guns versus piston guns :-[
For civilian use, you should be fine with a direct impingement setup as long as you follow some sensible maintenance routine. An AR is not an AK >:D
Some of these new piston designs are unproven too - never a good thing for a retrofit design IMO.
The piston uppers or complete systems are so different from each other that they are going to make the AR platform incompatible in a few years. Every manufacturer is making his own piston AR, unlike with DI the parts are more or less swappable, and like Shane said the piston rifles are very unproven.
Thanks for the comparison pics

-
Despite not having the gun, I am drooling over the MT

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Got one in mind?
And why do I get the feeling your wife is going to want to test your new AR15 on me? :o
Def
Not to worry....she prefers strangulation to gunfire, and I am the sole beneficiary of her ill intent. :P :D
I was browsing the Rock River Arms site just this afternoon :) but I need someone to explain to me the pros and cons of gas guns versus piston guns :-[
Direct gas impingement is the original operating system designed by Gene Stoner for the AR-10 and later adopted for the scaled down AR-15. The gas is bled off of the barrel down the gas port and directly (hence direct impingement) on to the bold carrier which in turn unlocks the bolt and cycles the rifle.
The controversy with this system is that A: if cheap/"dirty" ammo is used it will clog up the rifle and render it useless. B: if the gun is not properly maintained and cleaned even if you shoot "clean" ammo it will start acting up on you.
Gas piston ARs are a "new" phenomenon. Gas pistons were around a long time and still are the most common rifle operating system. In this system the gas is bled off the gas port and instead of acting directly on the bolt carrier it pushes on a piston which moves the bolt carrier unlocking the bolt and cycling the weapon.
The advantages of the piston is that it's cleaner, no carbon and other powder residue enter the receiver and the rifle is cleaner after a day of shooting and easier to maintain in the field.
Hope this explains the differences.Isn't that fundamentally what breaks people down into the Ar15/akm debate?
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Got one in mind?
And why do I get the feeling your wife is going to want to test your new AR15 on me? :o
Def
Not to worry....she prefers strangulation to gunfire, and I am the sole beneficiary of her ill intent. :P :D
I was browsing the Rock River Arms site just this afternoon :) but I need someone to explain to me the pros and cons of gas guns versus piston guns :-[
Direct gas impingement is the original operating system designed by Gene Stoner for the AR-10 and later adopted for the scaled down AR-15. The gas is bled off of the barrel down the gas port and directly (hence direct impingement) on to the bold carrier which in turn unlocks the bolt and cycles the rifle.
The controversy with this system is that A: if cheap/"dirty" ammo is used it will clog up the rifle and render it useless. B: if the gun is not properly maintained and cleaned even if you shoot "clean" ammo it will start acting up on you.
Gas piston ARs are a "new" phenomenon. Gas pistons were around a long time and still are the most common rifle operating system. In this system the gas is bled off the gas port and instead of acting directly on the bolt carrier it pushes on a piston which moves the bolt carrier unlocking the bolt and cycling the weapon.
The advantages of the piston is that it's cleaner, no carbon and other powder residue enter the receiver and the rifle is cleaner after a day of shooting and easier to maintain in the field.
Hope this explains the differences.Isn't that fundamentally what breaks people down into the Ar15/akm debate?
Only one part of the debate. Accuracy is another, AR rifles are a lot more accurate, and "stopping power" is often debated as well. AK rifles are not build to tight tolerances and thus are more reliable in sandy muddy environment at the price of accuracy, and AR sacrificing reliability and gaining in accuracy.
Check this link out, funny and it has some truth to it. http://www.mouseguns.com/compare.htm
-
stupid question from a guy that can't own guns: Why do people still buy/compare the AK-47 when it was made obsolete years ago by the AK74/AK100 series?
any chance of you selling the bit carrier separately? It has to be one of the best bit carriers I have seen.

sure thing, once i get some in, i will PM you

That would be great, thanks. If you ever make a general purpose MT, I will definitely be buying one.
-
@Magnus said:
stupid question from a guy that can't own guns: Why do people still buy/compare the AK-47 when it was made obsolete years ago by the AK74/AK100 series?That's just it, they aren't obsolete. I don't have an AK-47 anymore but now have an AK-74. The only difference is basically the caliber size. An AK-47 is 7.62 and the AK-74 was the Soviet Union's answer to NATO moving to a 5.56 round with a 5.45 round. You will still see millions of AK-47's still in use all around the world today. They are a lot cheaper than AR weapons and extremely dependable. AK's are easier to clean and maintain than AR's. It's not that AR's are hard to clean but are a bit more involved. I'm not talking about AR's or AK's with multiple accessories installed but just the basic versions of both.
-
-
stupid question from a guy that can't own guns: Why do people still buy/compare the AK-47 when it was made obsolete years ago by the AK74/AK100 series?
That's just it, they aren't obsolete. I don't have an AK-47 anymore but now have an AK-74. The only difference is basically the caliber size. An AK-47 is 7.62 and the AK-74 was the Soviet Union's answer to NATO moving to a 5.56 round with a 5.45 round. You will still see millions of AK-47's still in use all around the world today. They are a lot cheaper than AR weapons and extremely dependable. AK's are easier to clean and maintain than AR's. It's not that AR's are hard to clean but are a bit more involved. I'm not talking about AR's or AK's with multiple accessories installed but just the basic versions of both.
QFT. Also, the 7.62x39mm round is generally more useful to a civilian than the 5.45x39mm round. A 7.62 is an adequate deer and hog hunting caliber, comparable in end ballistics to the "all-American" deer round, the .30-30. So the 47 is still the most commonly seen version in the States, with the 7.62mm SKS-45 rifle being even more prolific.
The 74 is picking up in popularity almost entirely based on the cost of the ammo. There has been an abundance of 5.45mm ammo floating around at sane costs...which can't be said about a whole lot of other calibers at the moment.
-
@Magnus said:
stupid question from a guy that can't own guns: Why do people still buy/compare the AK-47 when it was made obsolete years ago by the AK74/AK100 series?any chance of you selling the bit carrier separately? It has to be one of the best bit carriers I have seen.

sure thing, once i get some in, i will PM you

That would be great, thanks. If you ever make a general purpose MT, I will definitely be buying one.
We can get a form of the AK100 series here, called the saiga. Problem is that they are sporterized so it takes some work to go from this http://www.centerfiresystems.com/sai-762.aspx to this http://www.k-var.com/shop/product.php?productid=17015&cat=353&page=1 . I have an SGL21 and I have to say it is quite a bit nicer than my romanian ak (wasr-10). The only thing that sucks about buying a 7.62 saiga is that nobody imports parts, so in the rare event you break an extractor, you're kinda in trouble.
-
@Magnus said:
stupid question from a guy that can't own guns: Why do people still buy/compare the AK-47 when it was made obsolete years ago by the AK74/AK100 series?Highly debatable that the AK74 is superior; the 5.45 cartridge wasnt adopted by the Chinese PLA because they felt it lacked punch - they are now using a 5.8 caliber round.
Also the AK100 series is just a freshened up version of the original, nothing revolutionary going on ;) The new AK107 is the first significant design evolution I've seen to the original Kalashnikov action.
The KEY to the success of the Kalashnikov design is it's manufacturing (and operational) simplicity. Cheap to produce (at least the stamped receiver version) and with minimal operator maintenance reqd. For example, the gas piston/bolt carrier system is elegantly simplistic and utterly reliable, but the sheer mass of the reciprocating assy means it generates quite a significant recoil impulse.
In other words, if you are shooting an AK in full-auto mode, anything more than a short burst results in "spray and pray" :ahhh The direct impingement system of the M16/M4 generates far less felt recoil, so the gun is far easier to control in full-auto mode, and the lockup method of its bolt insures greater inherent accuracy.
There are other advantages/disadvantages to each platform:
Magazines - the aluminum GI mags for the M16/M4 are notoriously flimsy; bend on of the magazine feed lips and your chances of a misfeed increase dramatically; the magazine follower design is not the best either. The newer aftermarket magazines, such as the Magpul PMAG, address these issues and improve magazine reliability quite a bit. However, the Kalashnikov has never had a magazine issue to my knowledge. The feed lips are exceptionally robust, and the magazine spring is rated about 25% over the intended 30rd capacity.
Platform modularity - this is a REAL advantage of the AR platform. By standardizing on the Picatinny/MIL-STD-1913 rail specification, the parts interchangeability of sights/bipods/lasers/etc. is unrivaled. Moreover, from an ergonomic standpoint, having the flat rail platform as the mounting base for items such as scope mounts means that these items are better integrated into the platform, rather than being an afterthought (as on the AK)

The AK on the otherhand, was designed in an age when optical sights for infantry weapons wasnt in vogue, and its cookie cutter design doesnt lend itself well to aftermarket accessories.
-
@Multitaskertools said:
The AK on the otherhand, was designed in an age when optical sights for infantry weapons wasnt in vogue, and its cookie cutter design doesnt lend itself well to aftermarket accessories.That's been my biggest hangup with the ak. I ended up putting an aimpoint on a MI quad rail handguard and while the setup works, it is incredibly heavy(at least in ak terms). It seems like most ak accessories end up either being poor quality, heavy, or expensive. I think the biggest challenge with the ak market is making good/useful accessories at a reasonable cost. I'm starting to see more ak goodies out there, but it's still nowhere near the AR market.
-
well i don't know what happened but i had another paragraph under the
'isn't that the ar15/ak47'i said, i hope not to derail this thread... (i believe its for the multitakser... you making a AK multitasker :P?)
What i put in the foot note is that either 'system'
often has variants that address the other.. like the current korean military m16 clone has the gas piston set up (i guess they decided the accuracy was not worth the reliabily) and their are variants of the ak that have heavier longer barrells for accuracy (like the Tabuk which is a RPK sniper rile)As a non-shooter the AK appeals to me, if i want super accuracy i would get a bolt action rifle
(if i ever get a cnc machine i want to build a super-AK)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login