A knife/tool legallity thread
-
I am sure that in some parts of the UK (Scotland??) ANY knife that can be considered offensive is illegal to carry without a good reason. ??? I'm sure this was mentioned before. I'll see if I can find the thread.
:D It was one of your posts actually Mike..........
@micky d said:
Don't forget though (boy I hate being the voice of reason) I certain part's of the UK and specifically in scotland, you still need a good reason to carry any kind of knife, regardless if it technically legal edc.I know your all sensible lad's out there, so please don't think I'm being patronising :)
cheers
on this thread /topic/2271
Thought I was imagining it at one point.
I remember it now, but after a while all the post's kinda merge in to one, or it could just be my age :D
-
So is that still the case do you think?
-
@micky d said:
So is that still the case do you think?
Sorry is what still the case mate?
That "in certain part's of the UK and specifically in scotland, you still need a good reason to carry any kind of knife, regardless if it technically legal edc."
Yes it does but only in the context, of where you are and what your doing, if your in a pub, it would be a no - no, if you were on your way to or from work it fine, it more of a common sence thing.
Likewise if you were in an train station and you had something like a UKPK on you, a copper could confiscate it and take you down the station, on the suspition of the fact that it's a weapon, it is completly legal but your average copper has just seen an aggresive looking knife and an easy arrest, you would probably have the knife returned to you but, you'd still lose half your day argueing the point >:(
So in short as long as your not somewhere inapropriate, doing something stupid, your fine :)

-
I have a friend that was a Ohio Highway Patrolman. He was telling me that in Ohio is is acceptable to carry any non switchblade knife as long as the blade was shorter than the length across the palm of the hand. Don ask why this is an accepted measurement to determine legality because the length would vary from person to person.
-
That is a typical measurement used by folks who don't really know the law, but saw someone else do it.
Ask him whose hand they use in court?
Def
-
Last time I read through my local laws here in Rhode Island, this was the main jist of the law:
**No fixed blade over 3" (Although I belive if you have a "reason" to have a larger knife like you're on your way hunting or to work, you can carry something bigger)
No switchblades, gravity knives, butterfly knives, etc
No double sided blades (daggers)**
I've forgotten what the legal length of a FOLDER can be, although I don't feel the need to carry anything with a 3"+ blade.
It's a good thing there aren't any illegal aliens raping, murdering, drunk driving, drug dealing, tax-dodging, and driving un insured, because then there might be something for America to do instead of harass regular citizens about something on their belt or in their pocket.

-
@CQC-7 said:
I have a friend that was a Ohio Highway Patrolman. He was telling me that in Ohio is is acceptable to carry any non switchblade knife as long as the blade was shorter than the length across the palm of the hand. Don ask why this is an accepted measurement to determine legality because the length would vary from person to person.Many law enforcement agencies in Ohio's rural counties tend to follow the OHP as a standard for policy and procedure,which is not unusual as many county sheriffs are former or retired Troopers. -
Guess I never checked before, but Michigan law seems a bit archaic in its stance on knives:
Any person who, with intent to use the same unlawfully against
the person of another, goes armed with a pistol or other firearm
or dagger, dirk, razor, stiletto, or knife having a blade over 3 inches
in length, or any other dangerous or deadly weapon or instrument,
shall be guilty of a felony, punishable by imprisonment in the state
prison for not more than 5 years or by a fine of not more than 2,500 dollars.Near as I can fathom, this means that there's no rule against <u>carrying</u> a knife shorter than 3 inches with unlawful intent, only 3" and <u>longer</u>. Seems kinda silly to me.
Bob
-
I believe that in Nebraska knives with over a 5" blade are acceptable for open but not concelaed carry but the way that the law is worded in archaic legaleese anything witha blade under 5" is not even considered a knife. How true that law enforcment sticks to that law is anyones guess. However in such an agriculture driven state it would be hard to find a farmer that does not carry a large leatherman or folder on their belt or in their pocket.
Kind of of topic but somewhat related to edc laws. Alaska did not have a CCW permit and I am not sure that they have one now you can just carry when you become of age. My friend lived in Alaska for a while and he carried all the time.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



