Throw or Spill?
-
Throw is for impressing lackies , a hotspot with side spill is a good compromise for EDC .
No need to blind the crews of low flying aircraft .Chris
-
For my EDC light, I prefer a floody beam with a wide spill, but if I'm out on my property at night looking for something, I prefer more throw. I will go further and say that I prefer floody beams when working with a light at close to medium ranges, and a throwy one when working with light at long ranges. All of my lights have some combination of throw and spill though.
flood<>spill. I think a better way to phrase the question is, "Do you prefer a throwy light, or a floody light", and also for what purpose. I define a floody light as one that has a low ratio of output difference between the center of the beam (spot) and the spill of the beam. The spot of a floody light will usually "blend" into the spill, whereas a throwy one will have a more abrupt transition from spot to spill.
-
Im a lackie :D I like throw....I do live by some woods so spotting deer is a hobbie, thus a throw for distance. I must admit that I also like throw for the wow factor.
-
@cgk said:
Im a lackie :D I like throw....I do live by some woods so spotting deer is a hobbie, thus a throw for distance. I must admit that I also like throw for the wow factor.another lackie here. :D I actually like to have both but if it had to be only one then a throwy light would have to be it.
What would you prefer:
can't see everything beside you? Have to move your torch around a bit. :-\
can't see the thing that's 100m away? Have to walk a 100m to go and have a look. :(
I'm just no that into pointless walking. ;) :D
-
If I had to select just one, I suppose I would select a light that has a good combination of spot and spill, such as a Quark or a Fenix L2D.
However... I would never limit myself to one beam profile, so I'll stick with carrying a floody light and keeping the throwers accessible in my bag and in the house and vehicles.
-
The Arc AAA & the Gerber Infinity Ultra come in mind. Both have good spots or throw & realy good spill beams. Kind of best of both worlds IMO.
-
@space cowboy said:
The Arc AAA & the Gerber Infinity Ultra come in mind. Both have good spots or throw & realy good spill beams. Kind of best of both worlds IMO.I would add the Novatac to that list also. I find the Novatac's beam to be similar to the GIU, except the spill is narrower on the Novatac, due to the deep reflector.
I consider the three to be fairly "floody".
-
Hmm.... throw or spill sounds like a choice you have to make about a drink

Throw - great big showy throwy sun cannon please :D
-
If a light doesn't have good throw, there's not a lot you can do about improving it.
Poor spill? well that can be remedied...
-
I need both, throw for finding house numbers when I'm stuck doing a call at night, climbing through attics etc, and flood for working on stupid hvac units, no vote for me
-
I prefer more throw than spill but still like a balanced beam. If I need more spill I can pop a piece of tap over the lens and be in business, conversely there's no good way to make a light with a lot of spill throw further. (Disregarding aspherics because they require a lot of work to function correctly and aren't a easy to implement solution.)
-
i throw 5-6 lights, 2 multis, 2 SAKs, and a folder in my backpack and I'm good to go. More is better than less
-
@Blackbeard said:
i throw 5-6 lights, 2 multis, 2 SAKs, and a folder in my backpack and I'm good to go. More is better than lessThat's great, as long as they don't spill out.

::)

-
i throw 5-6 lights, 2 multis, 2 SAKs, and a folder in my backpack and I'm good to go. More is better than less
That's great, as long as they don't spill out.

::)

Very punny :D
-
i throw 5-6 lights, 2 multis, 2 SAKs, and a folder in my backpack and I'm good to go. More is better than less
That's great, as long as they don't spill out.

::)

Oh dear ::) :D :D
-
Gave my vote to **spill **but generally agree with the idea that they both have applications.
However; floody lights can throw very well...they just need a LOT of power...Like a SSC P7 with 3 Amps going through it. or a SST-50/90.
For EDC & close up work(under 15 ft.)for me normally it's flood.
-
@Spoonrobot said:
I prefer more throw than spill but still like a balanced beam. If I need more spill I can pop a piece of tap over the lens and be in business, conversely there's no good way to make a light with a lot of spill throw further. (Disregarding aspherics because they require a lot of work to function correctly and aren't a easy to implement solution.)Big +1 on this Spoonrobot. You can always make a throwy light floody with a diffuser of some type.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
