Compact or Golfer ?
-
There was only a very brief period where there was a 91mm Golfer with combo tool and that was about 20 years ago. The difference is that it doesn't have a parcel hook on the back, whereas the Compact does, so I'd call that a Compact.
I know why you are questioning it though, it doesn't have the plus scales. I'd put that down to the fact it has the advertising on it and guess that "Holderbank" wanted a cheaper SAK, so didn't want to pay for the pen etc.
Come to think of it right now I can't think I've ever seen plus scales with advertising on them.
That said I'm no expert perhaps someone like Stressmaster will know better. -
Seconded on the Compact, and for the same reasoning as Gareth. To me, Hook = Compact, No Hook = Golfer.
Plus scales with advertisements are unusual, but out there. They do it in a couple ways - the Marlboro Trail Guide has plus scales with the Marlboro logo screen printed on the back. The "Techline" Mechanic Jr that was sold at Radio Shack has plus scales that are inlaid on the front, so the Vic logo is screen printed on the back. My guess is an inlaid logo would interfere with the pen slot.
Pics: (http://dorkiphus.net/imghost/TrailGuide_r.jpg), Techline Mechanic Jr
-
Thanks for the help,the lack of plus scales was the reason I started to question this one,at least my labeling was correct the first time. :D
-
I have come across several of these advertising Compacts and they always seem to be missing the "Plus" components.
-
Only plus scales I have with advertising.

-
So it is done, but not common.

-
While were on this topic, how about a 'Compact' without the file on the hook? Is it a Compact, or a Golfer, or either depending on the year-of-production?
I'm leaning towards Compact at this time, since once the hook appeared, the Golfer seemed to have aquired the divot tool, meaning they needed another name for the knife with the small blade.
-
I would think of it as being a Compact myself.
-
Compact. I've had boxed and labelled Compacts through with no file on the hook.
-
According to Ninjaz site the file appeared in 1998 giving a good 6-7 year window where I'd expect to see a Compact without a file on the hook.
-
Thanks! Clarified the the variation note on the wiki.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

