Gerber Crucial.
-
What don't you like about it then mate? :)
-
I like Gerber tools. I especially love their MP400 and 600 series sliding head pliers. I find their other lines a crapshoot in quality and function.
This one is a mixed bag. I like some heft to an MT, but this one seems a bit heavy for its size class. I understand this comes from the solid slabs of metal used for its handles. To me this is a plus. However, this is let down by construction. I can physically push the middle of the handles inwards. I can hazard that over time, this could cause the slabs to bend resulting in rubbing tools, and possibly jamming down the road. Of course, this may also result in nothing happening. Only time will tell. I just don’t like that I can physically bend the Crucial somewhat with a bit of pressure.
Another issue that puzzles me to this day; Gerber’s love of small secondary tools. I can understand it in their sliding plier models. Let’s face it; there is only so much room in the handles to accommodate the sliding pliers. However, someone figured that short drivers were the way to go with their whole line up. This one does not escape that trait. The small Phillips and flathead drivers are short.
I like that this comes with both a clip and a carabineer. The carabineer folds out of the way and also acts as a bottle opener. What I do not like is the flimsy gate used on the carabineer. The spring assembly is flimsy. Worse yet, it can’t survive any lateral push, as the small metal paperclip like gate moves side to side. Eventually, I see it getting looser and slipping past the metal hook negating the carabineer to dedicated cap lifting duties only.
Now onto style. I like the looks of this tool. However, this tool is clearly dictated by style and not function. This is probably my biggest issue. I just can’t use the pliers comfortably. The curves in the handles just don’t work for me. The ergonomics are all wrong for me. It could be due to my big paws. What I find annoying, is that I can’t one hand open the pliers due to the handle shape. The Skeletool also has that annoying curve in the handles. Nothing near as bad as the Crucial. I can comfortably use the Skeletool, I can’t say the same for the Crucial.
I do like the blade. I like the shape, size, and sharpness of it out of the box. I noted that they used a plastic thumb stud that is only pressure fitted via two holes in the blade. The plastic pins do not traverse the width of the blade. The blade is thick enough that this probably isn’t an issue.
These are my first impressions. This might be one of those tools that you need to EDC for a while to have it grow on you. I was prepared to like the Crucial. It is a smart looking MT with some class. Has a fair amount of capabilities for a tool of its size, and seems to be well made in some regards, and lacking in others. I just don’t know about the ergonomics, and am unsure if I can even get over it to be honest. It is rare that I find a tool that simply doesn’t fit me like this one, and I am sure this has soured my first impressions somewhat.
-
Thank's for your thought's mate :)
I had hoped it would fall on the MP series side of the quality fence, but I guess it's in the Suspension camp then :(
-
I just wasn't prepared to dislike it so much after initiating the fondling sequence.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I just wasn't prepared to dislike it so much after initiating the fondling sequence.
That such a shame as they clearly can make decent cheap and cheerful stuff like there folder's, torches and one piece tool's :)
But they seem incapable of making a cheap MT :)
Its not that their multis are that bad ... I'd still find a Crucial for instance to be damn handy in a pinch ... but quality-wise there are just better made tools available.
(IMO of course)
-
I agree Bob. The biggest let down is that I can't use it comfortably due to the lovely and oh so enticing curves. What makes it look good makes it bad for me to use.
-
So I finally saw this guy in REI today. I didn't realize how SMALL it is.
-
It might fit small hands better at that.
-
I was flopping between that and a skeletool for a while(skeletool won). I was looking for something that was "just the essentials" so I was in the department form over function tool. I loved the curves, color, blade, and the cool clip. But the pliers looked weak, I didn't like the way the carabiner opened(though I see why they did that).
Good to see another review with some honest feedback though

-
You know, I just figured out something else that bothered me at a subconscious level when I first got it. I just tried it a few times, which nailed the idea in my head so to speak. When I go to open this tool, because of the way it is made, I have no idea which side to flip unless I am looking right at it. Quite often, I am trying to open it, and it won't budge because I have the wrong end.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
, i do kind of like the look though ,