Gerber MP 600 D.E.T Fake.
-
Gareth's note:- This might be a little late but given that there still seems to be these MTs readily available on Ebay I thought I'd make this thread a sticky so folks know what to watch out for.

Gerber MP 600 D.E.T Fake.
I just got my āOEM Gerber MP 600 D.E.Tā in the door. I took a close look at it and knew immediately that it was what I suspectedā¦a fake. I am happy regardless because I didnāt spend much, and it is rather astonishingly well made for a fake. Regardless, I am sure Gerber isnāt happy about this even though I am quite happy to get such a good copy for the collection. Now all I need to do is get a real one down the road and I am set.
I am going to list all the things that tipped me off about this tool being off sort of speak.
The first thing that you will notice is the sheath. The sheath has the Gerber symbol, however, it is made of rather thin and cheap material.

If you take a look on the back, you will see how loose the belt loops are. No Gerber sheath is this bad.

It does look good. They got the likeness very close. So close that it is difficult to tell its pedigree from this photo.

With the tools opened however, you do notice a few things off, such as very slight tool shapes, wrong configuration, odd looking pliers, etc.

Now lets compare it to a real Gerber. The closest I had was this BO MP 600 model. Comparing them, you can tell right off the bat that the BO on the Gerber is better. I may be wrong, but the BO is just black paint on the fake. They do look very similar donāt they?

From the sides, there are a few places to see the differences though.** In all Photographs, the fake is on the left and the real is on the right.**All the Gerber MP 600s that I own have stainless imprinted on the handles just above the tool lock tabs. The fake Plier lock tabs are of a shinier black plastic and arenāt as well formed as the real deal. They also bulge outwards a bit compared to the real ones.

Looking closer, you can see that the fake handles arenāt as angular as the real Gerber. It is more rounded as it goes towards the plier head. A few marking details are off as well. I must say, the ruler impressions are dead similar to the Gerber. I am a bit impressed with that.

Looking at the washer spaces, you will see that the washers are thicker. This of course means that the individual tools are also thinner then the real Gerber.

Although the handles are very close to the original, upon closer inspection, you can see that they used a slightly thinner sheet metal.

Looking at the inside of the handles at the locking mechanism, there are some subtle differences. The fakeās spring is smaller and the locking plate looks cheaper than the original.

The eBay seller is called hugewish, and although he states that he is from Hong Kong, the package came from Singapore with a return mail address:
30 Kaki Bukit Rd 3 #06-
03/04 Empire Techno Ctr
Singapore 418713So there you have it. A not that badly made knock off of a good Gerber tool. Oh did I forget to mention that the plier heads rattle like the dead.

-
-
-
-
I kind of love it when collecting extends to look-alikes and downright knockoffs.

Thanks for the picture comparisson, very enlightening.

-
-
-
Interesting. Think it's worthwhile to alert Gerber to this?
A few years ago the firearms accessory the Grip Pod became an item that was issued to certain US Military members, over the course of time poorly made Chinese clones managed to get into the supply system and cause problems for frontline troops. Being that the EOD tool is sometimes issued and used by US Military personnel it may be worth an email to let Gerber know so they can make sure their supply line doesn't get compromised.
-
A Gerber MUT...

Great comparison, Chako..
-
do u realize how much trouble it is to create ALL of those stamped parts?
someone went thru an awful lot of trouble to make a counterfeit.
nice job on the comparisions BTW
-
I agree with you Sean 100%. I thought it might be a fake. Once I got it in, some things told me it wasn't real. It doesnāt reach the Gerber quality level by far.
Quoted from Fisting_chilil
It is fake. Gerber confirmed and know about these guys and are currently looking into a law suit. I am in negotiations w/the seller to get my money back. They seem very concerned w/bad feedback, so I told them I'd give them good feedback as long as I could just get my money back. He agreed, but now we are haggling over him paying for the postage back and me giving feedback AFTER I get my refund, not before like he wants, lol. I plan on getting my money back, giving good feedback, then forwarding all my email threads to eBay as proof of how he coerced good feedback from me by with holding my refund. Hopefully they will then cancel his account all together.
smurfs.
It looks like Gerber already knew about these fakes, and are taking action against them. They must be making a profit by selling these at less than 30 dollars. I know a real Gerber MP 600 D.E.T runs around 90 on eBay. As a collector, I am happy with it. If I wasn't a collector, I would be royally ticked off.
-
-
Yes, this is a rather good copy.
Best bet for anyone out there who are viewing a possible purchase on eBay or elsewhere, that white USA is a dead giveaway. On a real Gerber, it is usually stamped and blends into the handles. This one is white paint and silk screened/printed on it. They really wanted to tell people that the tool was made in the US and thus made it prominent.
-
-
-
@andre0407 said:
If it comes from Singapore... I reckon I could go pay them a visit and see what it's all about...seller might be based in Singapore, but that tool comes from China
-
Here is an update from my purchases of these fakes (I bought 2..yeah...I know...).
They are now trying to coerce me into leaving them positive feedback with full marks to get my money refunded to me. I've been going back and forth with them all night and all day today. I've also found out that ebay will refund all my cost themselves, so I told the seller that I will not leave him good feedback and will get my refund through ebay.
This is the feedback I just left for the two I purchased: THESE ARE FAKE! SELLER OFFERING REFUND ONLY IF I LEAVE POSITIVE REVIEW FIRST!!!
Chako and anyone else that bought from this guy, I really hope you all do the same.
I've opened counterfeit claims on both my items with ebay.
The following is taken directly from the emails between the seller and myself:
Me:That is coersion. I will not be forced into anything on the threat of not getting my money back. I'll just get my refund from eBay when I file a fraudulent claim.
Seller:After you leave me two positive feedback with full marks. Ok ?
Me:That would be fine with me, up to you. When will the refund of $51.98 go into my paypal?
Seller:My friend. I mean you could keep the items and don't need to send back ,because the postage will cost a lot .
Me:"Ok, leave me two positive feedbacks and I refund all of the 50USD back to you."
That is coercion.If you want to solve the problem, just give me my full refund and I'll send the tools back. That is the only answer.
Seller:I just want to slove the problem. I don't mean to coerce you .
Me:Not acceptable. I could get my money back from ebay by filing a fraudulent claim without having to be coerced into leaving you positive feedback.
Seller: Ok, leave me two positive feedbacks and I refund all of the 50USD back to you .
-
-
@Sean said:
Thanks for the pictures and your write up. What really burns me to no end is a copy
is one thing but a copy using the name on it of the company your imitating is quite
another. It's awful.
I've notified Gerber of their ads (I say "their" because the seller is selling these items with two separate ebay accounts), as well as notified the website whose picture they stole and doctored to sell their fake items.
-
@andre0407 said:
If it comes from Singapore... I reckon I could go pay them a visit and see what it's all about...Here is the info if you're inclined.
Name:
Li Hui
Address:
Room 302,No.158, Xin LiangXi RenJia
WuXi,214000
China
telephone:
+86-510--85892518No idea if they are close to you or not. Ebay has contacted them and the seller agreed to issue a full refund if I send them back. Packing them up now.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better š
Register Login
looking at the diferences the gerber looks really nice(fit&finish) now i cant wait for my MP600 :ahhh