Gerber MP 600 D.E.T Fake.
-
@Fisting_Chili said:
Well one thing I noticed right off the bat looking at your link is that the Lansky in this photo has the words facing the opposite direction. Instead of them facing in toward each other, they face outward, away from each other. Probably just another well conceived fake made of inferior materials and inferior design.that's a pretty generic Chinese MT to start with, and nobody is going to "tool up" to make a "fake" so they can move a few units on Ebay; they'd never recoup their investment.
-
Well one thing I noticed right off the bat looking at your link is that the Lansky in this photo has the words facing the opposite direction. Instead of them facing in toward each other, they face outward, away from each other. Probably just another well conceived fake made of inferior materials and inferior design.
that's a pretty generic Chinese MT to start with, and nobody is going to "tool up" to make a "fake" so they can move a few units on Ebay; they'd never recoup their investment.
Not sure what you mean by "tool up"? It it is anything like the MP 600 DET that started this thread, then it is most likely that it is not made to the exact standards of the real Lanskys. Maybe they shaved a bit off the thickness of the steel gauge or maybe they have cheaper locking mechanisms, or maybe the steel quality is just not the same grade. Its bad enough selling their tools under another company's name (one with a long history of excellence and a known reputation), but to sell inferior products under that company's name is even worse. Like others, I wonder if anyone in the armed services bought any of these inferior tools.
-
THAT Lansky tool is a generic multitool; they either paid a sourcing agent to procure it or licensed their brand to someone like Alltrade. I seriously doubt anyone from Lansky has ever set foot inside that Chinese factory.
I LIVE in Yangjiang, China about 4 months out of the year to watch over production; rarely do I see any Americans, and if I do, they are there for 1-2 days max. Can't blame em, it's a sh*thole city, not even a McDonalds.
Like the other poster mentioned, this seems to be a Chinese supplier issue, selling unauthorized versions, maybe even ones that failed QC inspection. But the notion some factory would invest in all that tooling to make some replicas to sell on eBay (how else are they going to sell them?) is very naive.
Take a close look at the fasteners on the "fake" Gerber and see how they resemble these other tools the seller posted? someone is dipping in the same parts pin if u ask me.
I haven't compared closely against the Carolina stuff coming out of China nut it wouldn't shock me if these "Gerbers" were coming out the backdoor.
Just my $.02
-
@Multitaskertools said:
THAT Lansky tool is a generic multitool; they either paid a sourcing agent to procure it or licensed their brand to someone like Alltrade. I seriously doubt anyone from Lansky has ever set foot inside that Chinese factory.I LIVE in Yangjiang, China about 4 months out of the year to watch over production; rarely do I see any Americans, and if I do, they are there for 1-2 days max. Can't blame em, it's a sh*thole city, not even a McDonalds.
Like the other poster mentioned, this seems to be a Chinese supplier issue, selling unauthorized versions, maybe even ones that failed QC inspection. But the notion some factory would invest in all that tooling to make some replicas to sell on eBay (how else are they going to sell them?) is very naive.
Take a close look at the fasteners on the "fake" Gerber and see how they resemble these other tools the seller posted? someone is dipping in the same parts pin if u ask me.
I haven't compared closely against the Carolina stuff coming out of China nut it wouldn't shock me if these "Gerbers" were coming out the backdoor.
Just my $.02
Interesting....I honestly don't know enough(or anything really...) about Lanskys to say, so I'll just shut my maw on that one, lol. So you mean that Lansky licensed their name to a generic distributor like Alltrade (not sure if I understand that fully) and that alltrade paid for the right to use Lansky's name as they wish?
I can say, from speaking with Gerber here in Portland, that the DET's this seller is putting out are in no way authorized or connected to the Gerber company at all. No permissions were given and they are looking into legal action.
Thanks! -
That "fake" Gerber is def unauthorized

I'm just suggesting that the source of the problem probably has ties to Gerber's Chinese supplier network.
-
@Multitaskertools said:
That "fake" Gerber is def unauthorized
I'm just suggesting that the source of the problem probably has ties to Gerber's Chinese supplier network.
Ahhh! got it. Thanks for the clarification :D
-
Also, just to clarify, I'm a merely offering an informed opinion (hopefully); I don't have any hard evidence in this case. But then again, solving their headaches isn't part of MY job description.
-
@Multitaskertools said:
Also, just to clarify, I'm a merely offering an informed opinion (hopefully); I don't have any hard evidence in this case. But then again, solving their headaches isn't part of MY job description.Funny, when I worked with lawyers, I always used to tell them, "YOUR rush is not MY priority"

-
This is highly likely an example of why you have to really watch what is happening with overseas production. It can happen with any outsourced production, but overseas where you are not there watching, it can really show up. There have been companies ruined by the clones that rolled off of unsupervised lines. They transferred the technology and were transferred out of business.
It is just too easy when there is no one around to walk the product out of the back door. If nothing happens then it just gets worse until you see your product sitting at half price next to your official one. Then they say sorry and go on to the next sucker.
This is not a Xenophopic chant, I have seen good stuff done off shore or by contract, honestly, but usually to get it, you pay a premium to get it, have your people there and on a first name basis with the company, and/or own the plant. When outsourcing, it is very much buyer beware and requires more effort than most companies realize. It is not just the MBA attitude, lets get of that troublesome, dirty plant and rake in the dough, it is harder work wth the travel as running that dirty, troublesome plant or you end up in a process that starts with Chapter and ends with 11 or 7.
My vote goes for this one walked out the back door.
-
Mine showed up today. Couple pics beside the real one..




-
Alright, my ordeal is finally over. I proposed he give me a $10 refund on the second one and we'll call it even. Went back and forth, back and forth as I tried to weedle him that if he spent 15 on it and I bought for 25, giving me a 10 refund would make him brake even and would at least close the fraud case and the feedback extortion case I have open against him. Ebay would require me to send it back with delivery confirmation...which to China would cost me over 25.00 but I didn't tell the seller that. So he thinks I only lose the $15, but if I had to ship it back I would have lost even more.
Its done and I'm glad.
-
Now...do you think I can sell these on ebay if I list them as Gerber fakes???

-
@Fisting_Chili said:
Now...do you think I can sell these on ebay if I list them as Gerber fakes???
eBay really helps perpetuate this sort of unauthorized/counterfeit business by allowing these overseas sellers to maintain auctions - the companies affected have little recourse against the seller(s), other than maybe shutting down their eBay accounts.
If someone were stupid enough to import those things to the US and then sell them, then they could get hit with trademark/patent infringement suits like whoa

-
Its all about presentation :P
**Title: <u>Genuine INFAMOUS Gerber FAKES!!!</u>
Description: Yes these are the real deal! These are not just any old knock -off, NO! These are the truly infamous ones that you've heard all the woeful tales about. The clandestine oriental deals, the black mail, the retaliation, the horror of negative feedback :o
Become the end of this internet legend and own one of THESE <insert picture>
You know you'll regret it if you don't win this, there are no second chances. You've followed the drama, now's your chance to be part of it.**
-
@Neil said:
Its all about presentation :P**Title: <u>Genuine INFAMOUS Gerber FAKES!!!</u>
Description: Yes these are the real deal! These are not just any old knock -off, NO! These are the truly infamous ones that you've heard all the woeful tales about. The clandestine oriental deals, the black mail, the retaliation, the horror of negative feedback :o
Become the end of this internet legend and own one of THESE <insert picture>
You know you'll regret it if you don't win this, there are no second chances. You've followed the drama, now's your chance to be part of it.**

-
@Neil said:
Its all about presentation :P**Title: <u>Genuine INFAMOUS Gerber FAKES!!!</u>
Description: Yes these are the real deal! These are not just any old knock -off, NO! These are the truly infamous ones that you've heard all the woeful tales about. The clandestine oriental deals, the black mail, the retaliation, the horror of negative feedback :o
Become the end of this internet legend and own one of THESE <insert picture>
You know you'll regret it if you don't win this, there are no second chances. You've followed the drama, now's your chance to be part of it.**
Neil's on the sauce again ::) :D
-
Just a slight headache actually

-
Mine is a real Lansky. I checked Lansky’s official site when I bought it and it matched.
That tool is generic. All those examples are basically the same tool made by the same factory, with different cosmetics specific to the buyer.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login