Gerber MP 600 D.E.T Fake.
-
eBay shields the Chinese sellers from legal action via trademark/patent infringement; much easier to penalize someone selling this merchandise from the US.
How? How do they shield them? ???
how is Gerber going to sue them? In China?

Yeah I can see that. But can't they still take legal action to have their auctions brought down or accounts terminated? maybe some action against ebay if they will not shut down their auctions?
-
I'm sure they can shut down this specific account; but it's easy enough to establish a new account to replace the one that's been terminated. It's precisely why you see so many fakes being peddled on eBay - there's no REAL recourse against the sellers of fake merchandise.
-
Gerber can have these listings removed, simply by asking ebay to remove them.
Whitby and Co (UK importers of Leatherman, Maglite, Buck etc) actually have a person / team that trawl the internet looking for things like this so they can close them down. I'd have thought that Gerber would too.
Has anyone told Gerber about these fakes?
-
@DaveK said:
Gerber can have these listings removed, simply by asking ebay to remove them.Whitby and Co (UK importers of Leatherman, Maglite, Buck etc) actually have a person / team that trawl the internet looking for things like this so they can close them down. I'd have thought that Gerber would too.
Has anyone told Gerber about these fakes?
I took them over to Gerber in person and spoke with one of their people. They were already aware of these people and looking into legal action. For some reason, I don't think it is as easy as just asking ebay to shut them down because I'm sure they already did and the ads are still up...and still going up.
I also contacted Harley Davidson to have them look into those Harley Davidson multitools the same seller is peddling. Also contacted the owners of the real webpage, whose screenshot the fake sellers stole and doctored to show the counterfeits and they told me they were not pleased and would contact ebay.
Yet the ads still go up?
-
Gerber can have these listings removed, simply by asking ebay to remove them.
Whitby and Co (UK importers of Leatherman, Maglite, Buck etc) actually have a person / team that trawl the internet looking for things like this so they can close them down. I'd have thought that Gerber would too.
Has anyone told Gerber about these fakes?
I took them over to Gerber in person and spoke with one of their people. They were already aware of these people and looking into legal action. For some reason, I don't think it is as easy as just asking ebay to shut them down because I'm sure they already did and the ads are still up...and still going up.
I also contacted Harley Davidson to have them look into those Harley Davidson multitools the same seller is peddling. Also contacted the owners of the real webpage, whose screenshot the fake sellers stole and doctored to show the counterfeits and they told me they were not pleased and would contact ebay.
Yet the ads still go up?
Precisely the point Ive been trying to make. Ebay gives these rogue sellers a safe haven to do business.
You can shut down 1 seller account, then another 1 will pop up in its place.
IMO, the only to root out the problem is to address it from the supply chain side.
-
Gerber can have these listings removed, simply by asking ebay to remove them.
Whitby and Co (UK importers of Leatherman, Maglite, Buck etc) actually have a person / team that trawl the internet looking for things like this so they can close them down. I'd have thought that Gerber would too.
Has anyone told Gerber about these fakes?
I took them over to Gerber in person and spoke with one of their people. They were already aware of these people and looking into legal action. For some reason, I don't think it is as easy as just asking ebay to shut them down because I'm sure they already did and the ads are still up...and still going up.
I also contacted Harley Davidson to have them look into those Harley Davidson multitools the same seller is peddling. Also contacted the owners of the real webpage, whose screenshot the fake sellers stole and doctored to show the counterfeits and they told me they were not pleased and would contact ebay.
Yet the ads still go up?
Precisely the point Ive been trying to make. Ebay gives these rogue sellers a safe haven to do business.
You can shut down 1 seller account, then another 1 will pop up in its place.
IMO, the only to root out the problem is to address it from the supply chain side.
But its not even a different seller. Its the same Hugewish guy that still has his account active and still puts up more ads. Its almost like no action at all has been taken against him
-
Gerber can have these listings removed, simply by asking ebay to remove them.
Whitby and Co (UK importers of Leatherman, Maglite, Buck etc) actually have a person / team that trawl the internet looking for things like this so they can close them down. I'd have thought that Gerber would too.
Has anyone told Gerber about these fakes?
I took them over to Gerber in person and spoke with one of their people. They were already aware of these people and looking into legal action. For some reason, I don't think it is as easy as just asking ebay to shut them down because I'm sure they already did and the ads are still up...and still going up.
I also contacted Harley Davidson to have them look into those Harley Davidson multitools the same seller is peddling. Also contacted the owners of the real webpage, whose screenshot the fake sellers stole and doctored to show the counterfeits and they told me they were not pleased and would contact ebay.
Yet the ads still go up?
Precisely the point Ive been trying to make. Ebay gives these rogue sellers a safe haven to do business.
You can shut down 1 seller account, then another 1 will pop up in its place.
IMO, the only to root out the problem is to address it from the supply chain side.
But its not even a different seller. Its the same Hugewish guy that still has his account active and still puts up more ads. Its almost like no action at all has been taken against him
It's been THIS hard to shut this guy down, despite the complaints.
How hard is it going to be for him, or another seller in China, to offer up the same merchandise from a different account?
There is no accountability for selling fakes on eBay, that's why these sellers exploit it.
-
ebay shut me down quick enough, based on a very dodgy instruction from Whitby's ???
I was told by ebay that when they receive any complaint, they suspend the listings and worry about it later!
-
@DaveK said:
ebay shut me down quick enough, based on a very dodgy instruction from Whitby's ???I was told by ebay that when they receive any complaint, they suspend the listings and worry about it later!
perhaps the Ebay.uk fellas actually do their jobs

im a bit of a clotheshorse, and i can tell you there are sheer oceans of counterfeit designer goods floating on eBay auctions at anytime - so obvious too
it's why i prefer to buy stuff off Styleforum.net - the admin & membership there does a great job of flushing out fakes.
-
ebay shut me down quick enough, based on a very dodgy instruction from Whitby's ???
I was told by ebay that when they receive any complaint, they suspend the listings and worry about it later!
perhaps the Ebay.uk fellas actually do their jobs

im a bit of a clotheshorse, and i can tell you there are sheer oceans of counterfeit designer goods floating on eBay auctions at anytime - so obvious too
it's why i prefer to buy stuff off Styleforum.net - the admin & membership there does a great job of flushing out fakes.
Maybe you're right!
-
one just sold on ebay.ca for 30 bucks plus 12 shipping. IDENTICAL to Chako's and............Hugewish!
Hugewish is no longer a registered member on ebay.
Booooooya!!! (Yes...I said booya)
Very nice! I was hoping that if Gerber, Harley Davidson and the administrators of gerber-tools.com all complained something would be done.

-
WH867
as of like just now? or as of a long time?it was .ca not .com
sorry, I was a bit confused by your phrasing
-
both sellers are US-based, but the price (Buy It Now for less than $35) and qty (more than 10 available) make me wonder :think:
-
@Multitaskertools said:
http://cgi.ebay.com/Gerber-Multi-Plier-600-Yellow-Lumilite-AA-Flashlight_W0QQitemZ370214809132QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item563285ae2cboth sellers are US-based, but the price (Buy It Now for less than $35) and qty (more than 10 available) make me wonder

Those are real. I bought one of the yellow set (Damn you Chako!!!). One thing to, is I look at the seller rating and with both of theirs in the thousands, I'd trust it.
-
both sellers are US-based, but the price (Buy It Now for less than $35) and qty (more than 10 available) make me wonder

Those are real. I bought one of the yellow set (Damn you Chako!!!). One thing to, is I look at the seller rating and with both of theirs in the thousands, I'd trust it.
Something's amiss if they can sell at those prices, and everyone else is around 60...
or maybe im just paranoid :ahhh
-
Just got one of these DET's in via Australia (thanks MAT!) and sure enough its fake as a three dollar bill. :P Every single component - at least 20 different parts - has been copied and remade. Nothing is original Gerber. An amazingly thorough job of counterfeiting to be sure. But the clues are there and easy to spot once you know what to look for.
The plier head for instance looks good at arms length, but I wonder how well the crimper jaws would really work? The crimp profile is much better formed on the genuine article:

You guys have already pointed out the other major shortcomings in the handles and blades. One other thing worth mentioning though is the slider spring-clips. They are barely held on on the fake model! I was able to pop them off easily with just my fingernail. No way you could do this on a real Gerber! :o

Once apart, you can see other differences between a real Gerber plier head casting and the fake one.


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login