The most unbreakable multitool.
-
I always felt when I had a Sog power assist SOMETHING would give if I squeezed to tightly
It wasn't going to be my hand
:D -
@CumminsDiesel said:
Right,but its a lots of broken in the normal use.Yeah but pretty much everyone who breaks something will claim it's under "normal" use.
-
Gerber Suspension .
btw my name is Robert and I'm a compulsive liar .
Sidney
-
Right,but its a lots of broken in the normal use.
Yeah but pretty much everyone who breaks something will claim it's under "normal" use.
not me and not this guy I guess (for example): /topic/19396 - like he said: " I was bending a wire and did not use much force. I was being cautious with the tool as it was new and I did not want to break it. Nonetheless the pliers snapped!".Same with my SURGE (handles).So its a NORMAL use.
-
Multitool pliers are for turning stuff more than bending it seems imo.
I think the shcrade st5 slip joint and endeavor are the toughest pliers on a multi -
Don't get me wrong,I really like Leatherman products,they really looks like HD tool,and I think pliers on ST300 (MUT) is a very tough to beat.Its a big improvement.
-
I have yet to break a MT's pliers. I guess I'm not trying hard enough, but my blast has stood up to more punishment than I thought possible. And it still looks new!
-
The Achilles heel of 99.99% of multi's is investment cast pliers . Some companies do better castings than others . Many would not be too happy with drop forged carbon steel plier heads , as they would rust ; multi's are by deffinition compromises . If you are seeing lots of broken Surges , you need to graduate to 9" vice grips or 8" linesmans pliers .
Of existing/commonly available Multi's I would say the Leatherman Supertool 300 or the Vic. Swisstool .
Chris
-
@Gadget Guy said:
Have you ever bought anything and as soon as you received it said to yourself "boy I wish I could get my money back on this one"? Well... this is the thread to share your stories of your not so great purchases. Pictures would be great and a little info on the purchase would be good.Here is my latest stink bomb of a purchase:

It's called a "Silk Worm" and it's made by a custom knifemaker from Korea named Kim. His company is called Raidops. I usually love all of his stuff, but this purchase is a stink bomb! :D
Specs: 3" long
3/4" thick
Heat treated titanium
4.5oz :oWhat the heck am I going to do with this? ::) BTW, it only cost $100! :ahhh
-
As I recall all of Cummin's broken Surges weren't actually him breaking the pliers, he had one bad one he sent in for warranty, an LM kept sending him defective ones back. Took 5 tries before they managed to get him one that wasn't screwed up.
I would say take a look at the Surge, ST300, Powerlock 2.0, and Swisstool. They should all be around equal toughness for most things you will use them for. Then decide which one fits your needs the best, because at that point anything that will break one of those tools, will likely break all the others as well, barring a factory defect of some kind. If after that you are repeatedly breaking the one you choose, it's time to start using dedicated tools for those tasks.
-
I broke the pliers on one of my surges, broke very easy too. The replacement has been beat to hell and no problems. Musta been a defect on the first one.

-
@Styerman said:
The Achilles heel of 99.99% of multi's is investment cast pliers . Some companies do better castings than others . Many would not be too happy with drop forged carbon steel plier heads , as they would rust ; multi's are by deffinition compromises . If you are seeing lots of broken Surges , you need to graduate to 9" vice grips or 8" linesmans pliers .Of existing/commonly available Multi's I would say the Leatherman Supertool 300 or the Vic. Swisstool .
Chris
my CNC billet pliers are almost here... :ahhh
-
@DaveK said:
I suppose it depends on your definition of "normal use". I can't recall hearing about many broken Surges, so you either have been very unlucky or your definition of normal use differs from other people's.i agree dave, i dont abuse MT's as there a alternative useful tool when needed but no substitute for the proper tool, i mean i broke a flat driver on my old wave and i did it by using it as a mini crow bar, its not built for that and it broke, my fault,but yes some are stronger than others , but i find there all pretty good,

-
Now I know which one, :D :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
LM Super Tool. 10 years of abuse and going strong.

-
@CumminsDiesel said:
Now I know which one, :D :ahhh :ahhh :ahhhthis was the pre 04 wave, :D i like the beefier flat driver on the st300 and the swisstool,
-
My ST300 is shaping up to be quite sturdy. I just dropped it hard and there is not a single scratch on it.
-
My ST300 is shaping up to be quite sturdy. I just dropped it hard and there is not a single scratch on it.
i used mine while up a ladder the other week to knock in some rawplugs, i wouldnt knock nails in with it but i bet it could do it ::) :D
I bet it could, and it could do it well. I don't think LM would warranty that though, but you never know!
-
I can tell you which one is NOT the most unbreakable.
/topic/18005I feel that the powerlocks have the tightest grip of all multis and thats due to the compound leverage gears, but of the major multi tool makers i think its got the weakest frame. As you can see from the above link, i easily broke a powerassist while applying a lesser grip than i have on my small swisstool spirit. I also bent a regular powerlock to the point where the handles are completely parralled to one another when opened. In my opinion the swissgrip does have the strongest plier head but it not worth a damn for cutting anything thicker than a clothes hanger. I almost broke my wrist trying to cut a thin nail with a swissgrip, i think the design was poorly done.
My first choice for the strongest, usable plier based multi is the swisstool, even when twisting something you see very little twist on the plier head, where as with my surge, after minimal twisting of a metal plate, the tips of the pliers ended up not being even.
Gerbers are in the bottom, when it comes to plier strength, (of the major multi brands).
Just my opinion, but like others have mentioned, multis are not meant to be used as hard a an individually specialized tool is but it shouldn't brake with minimal use either.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login