I was wrong....
-
Man... your guys comments just make me sad. :'( I hate to see the future of our country or the world for that matter. ::)
I think you are letting your personal feeling toward atwood cloud your judgement. Let's say if you are in charge, how far off would the design be before you'd allowed it to be produced?
Let me ask you a question. If you designed the Atwood tool how would you feel?
-
Man... your guys comments just make me sad. :'( I hate to see the future of our country or the world for that matter. ::)
I think you are letting your personal feeling toward atwood cloud your judgement. Let's say if you are in charge, how far off would the design be before you'd allowed it to be produced?
That's the point. Unless you're going to boycott SwissTools and Spirits, I think it's a little disingenuous. I really like Atwood tools (and all the one piece makers), but without patent protection, the rules are set to allow others to copy. :-\
I don't see how you can selectively play this...
(btw, I don't own a PockeToolX tool, mostly because I like my Atwoods, and if I need more, I go to socket sets--but if they're playing by the rules, they're playing fair...)
-
Man... your guys comments just make me sad. :'( I hate to see the future of our country or the world for that matter. ::)
I think you are letting your personal feeling toward atwood cloud your judgement. Let's say if you are in charge, how far off would the design be before you'd allowed it to be produced?
Let me ask you a question. If you designed the Atwood tool how would you feel?
Well, I wouldn't like it, but I'd realize that I didn't protect my work. I'd change that pronto.
-
Contructive thoughts have been shared in this thread so far - well done all. Lets please see this continue.
-
Why is it every time I post in a thread like this I see a Moderator? :D
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Man... your guys comments just make me sad. :'( I hate to see the future of our country or the world for that matter. ::)
I think you are letting your personal feeling toward atwood cloud your judgement. Let's say if you are in charge, how far off would the design be before you'd allowed it to be produced?
Let me ask you a question. If you designed the Atwood tool how would you feel?
Well, I wouldn't like it, but I'd realize that I didn't protect my work. I'd change that pronto.
Peter did in fact patent the original Prybaby design but that didn't stop Gerber.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
[quote author=Gadget Guy link=topic=19943.msg376480#msg376480 date=1274293021]
Man... your guys comments just make me sad. :'( I hate to see the future of our country or the world for that matter. ::)I think you are letting your personal feeling toward atwood cloud your judgement. Let's say if you are in charge, how far off would the design be before you'd allowed it to be produced?
Let me ask you a question. If you designed the Atwood tool how would you feel?
Well, I wouldn't like it, but I'd realize that I didn't protect my work. I'd change that pronto.
Peter did in fact patent the original Prybaby design but that didn't stop Gerber.
[/quote]Wow. That does suck. (You're referring to the Shard yes?)
-
Well,
Let me modify that a bit...
It sucks for the creative innovator.
I know in the climbing world that one company/person comes up with a new, unique and awesome piece of gear, every company comes out with their version of the same shortly thereafter. Some are better, some are worse, but as a climber, it is a good thing for me.
Maybe not so clear in the one piece tool realm.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
[quote author=jzmtl link=topic=19943.msg376481#msg376481 date=1274293218]
[quote author=Gadget Guy link=topic=19943.msg376480#msg376480 date=1274293021]
Man... your guys comments just make me sad. :'( I hate to see the future of our country or the world for that matter. ::)I think you are letting your personal feeling toward atwood cloud your judgement. Let's say if you are in charge, how far off would the design be before you'd allowed it to be produced?
Let me ask you a question. If you designed the Atwood tool how would you feel?
Well, I wouldn't like it, but I'd realize that I didn't protect my work. I'd change that pronto.
Peter did in fact patent the original Prybaby design but that didn't stop Gerber.
[/quote]Wow. That does suck. (You're referring to the Shard yes?)
[/quote]I think the Artifact is more of a direct copy then the Shard. Gerber basically took a old skool xl Prybaby and added a X-Acto blade to it.
You be the judge:


-
:O that s literally the same if gerber wasn't a worldwide company peters patent might stand a chance for a lawsuit
-
@Gadget Guy said:
I think the Artifact is more of a direct copy then the Shard. Gerber basically took a old skool xl Prybaby and added a X-Acto blade to it.You be the judge:


Just to be totally precise, Gerber added an XActo blade, phillips screwdriver (instead of the flathead), and a bottle opener that doubles as a 1/4'' bit drive in a pinch, made it out of non-premium stainless steel, and retailed it for much less and much more readily than mr. Atwood... :-\
-
:O that s literally the same if gerber wasn't a worldwide company peters patent might stand a chance for a lawsuit
So does that make it right to rip-off Mr. Atwood? ;) See where I'm coming from.

i sort of in the middle i see your point, but i dont have an atwood. If i did then i might be a bit more for it. But i also like seeing a one piece tool in my price range ???
-
I'm not 100% sure on this but I think it would be very difficult to get a patent for a pry bar tool

-
he might have patented the idea of a mini pry bar with a bottle opener or something similar
-
Or what about this. Did Mr. Emerson steal an idea from Victorinox?
http://www.emersonknives.com/ekEmersonShow.php
Scroll down for Custom CQC6 with tweezers.
-
@Gadget Guy said:
Let me ask you a question. If you designed the Atwood tool how would you feel?I'm not a designer, so I can't really say
@Mr. Whippy said:
That's the point. Unless you're going to boycott SwissTools and Spirits, I think it's a little disingenuous. I really like Atwood tools (and all the one piece makers), but without patent protection, the rules are set to allow others to copy. :-\I don't see how you can selectively play this...
(btw, I don't own a PockeToolX tool, mostly because I like my Atwoods, and if I need more, I go to socket sets--but if they're playing by the rules, they're playing fair...)
While Peter can copyright his exact tool pattern, I don't think he can copyright/patent the individual element because he didn't invent any of them. The wrench/opener/prybar design are older than probably all of us on the forum, he just combined them into one tool.
-
I think before we go much further with this discussion, I'd like to review the patent for the Prybaby and see what exactly it covers. Otherwise, I can't really comment intelligently on what can or cannot be considered a copy. I'll admit, that even without any solid evidence, that there is definitely a similarity in concept but that really only means that Atwood was onto something with the basic design.
You also need to look at it from the other point of view- whether PocketToolX or Gerber did or did not infringe on Atwood's patents (and without seeing the patent I can't comment on that one way or the other), Gerber is making the tool for the mass market, which is something Peter never has. That doesn't excuse any potential infringements, but I see no reason why Peter couldn't have made his limited run for collectors, then contracted another agency like CRKT to crank out a production version. Many makers have done something like that, and history has proven that a production version of the "original" can stamp out the copies quite effectively.
If Peter really wanted to take a shot back at these guys, then he could do that- I'm sure any number of companies would love to have an Atwood collaboration.
Def
-
and i for one would be willing to see that happen!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login