Email from Pockettoolx
-
Ok, those are some simply AWESOME old tools.
I would love to work with some of those alligator wrenches with integrated dies in the center. What an awesome idea. Thanks for that link.

-
@BigFatTon said:
I think it's harsh to call him a liar. There are only so many things you can do with a tool like this, so it makes sense that the tools would be similar. The pockettoolx tools, by all accounts, are pretty fantastic tools, and the fact that I wouldn't have to get lucky in order to purchase one makes me not even care if it was copied or not. The Atwood tools are beautiful and mostly functional, but if he isn't going to step up to mass production, then i'm glad someone is.Just because you can't get an Atwood tool doesn't mean it's ok to copy his designs. BTW, I called him (Justin) a liar because he is a liar. I have no time to sit and call people names. He lied and he knows it. Doesn't seem to matter, people are going to buy what they're going to buy and there is nothing I can do about it except stand up for what I feel is right...
-
OK let's keep this civil please gentleman.
-
I think it's harsh to call him a liar. There are only so many things you can do with a tool like this, so it makes sense that the tools would be similar. The pockettoolx tools, by all accounts, are pretty fantastic tools, and the fact that I wouldn't have to get lucky in order to purchase one makes me not even care if it was copied or not. The Atwood tools are beautiful and mostly functional, but if he isn't going to step up to mass production, then i'm glad someone is.
Just because you can't get an Atwood tool doesn't mean it's ok to copy his designs. BTW, I called him (Justin) a liar because he is a liar. I have no time to sit and call people names. He lied and he knows it. Doesn't seem to matter, people are going to buy what they're going to buy and there is nothing I can do about it except stand up for what I feel is right...
You called him a liar because you think he is a liar, you have no proof he is one, so how about you act like an adult and stop with the baseless accusations
-
Could have sworn Mike said to keep this civil?
-
I think it's harsh to call him a liar. There are only so many things you can do with a tool like this, so it makes sense that the tools would be similar. The pockettoolx tools, by all accounts, are pretty fantastic tools, and the fact that I wouldn't have to get lucky in order to purchase one makes me not even care if it was copied or not. The Atwood tools are beautiful and mostly functional, but if he isn't going to step up to mass production, then i'm glad someone is.
Just because you can't get an Atwood tool doesn't mean it's ok to copy his designs. BTW, I called him (Justin) a liar because he is a liar. I have no time to sit and call people names. He lied and he knows it. Doesn't seem to matter, people are going to buy what they're going to buy and there is nothing I can do about it except stand up for what I feel is right...
You called him a liar because you think he is a liar, you have no proof he is one, so how about you act like an adult and stop with the baseless accusations
I have proof but I just keep it to myself. I think Mike has spoken here.

-
Sorry Ben, I was posting at the same time as you. :D
-
No worries. :D
-
Well I think it's perfectly civil to expect someone to provide proof if they're calling them a liar. So until you provide said proof, I think it fair to ask you to calm down with the name calling.
-
OK let's just leave it there please, or the next vaguely negative comment get's the thread locked.
-
@BigFatTon said:
Well I think it's perfectly civil to expect someone to provide proof if they're calling them a liar. So until you provide said proof, I think it fair to ask you to calm down with the name calling.Fair enough...

-
Why can't we just decide who from and what we purchase is a individual decision and leave the copy right laws to those qualified,just a thought ;)
-
Trying to get back to the topic, I have no comment on Justin or his product since I haven't held either his or Peter's. What I will say is that parallel evolution is indeed a possibility, and while I can't intelligently comment on it in this case one way or the other, I can say with absolute certainty that there is a limit to it. While there is the chance that these tools were developed the same way to fill a similar need, it's rare to see that kind of thing continue on for any length of time. I'd like to see what PocketToolX and Peter Atwood are likely to come up with after this- if there are continuing similarities (as close as these are) then we know someone is full of the brown smelly stuff. If they diverge, then someone could still be full of brown stuff, but had the sense to take the idea and run rather than continue to copy others. If that's the case, then future tools are likely to be flawed, since the copycat is unable to intelligently build on a concept that they didn't develop initially. Or, it could simply be that these similar tools were legitimately similar. Really, only time will tell.
In the meantime, regardless of originality, Multitool.org has a responsibility to provide unbiased reviews on the functionality of each tool. If it works, it works no matter how it came to be. If it doesn't work, well then it doesn't matter how inspired it was.
Def
-
I think i believe them, I remember my grandpa had a few alligator wrenches that cut out int the handles that fit like box ends, so i know the idea is defiantly not the most original, but i think we'll have to see what comes of this, honestly I had never heard of peter atwood until a few months ago, when I was looking for a small wrench, I actually found out about the pocket wrench II and piranha before any of peter atwoods designs, so i think that they really could have designed it beginning to end without even knowing that he existed.
-
@diabolicturtle said:
I think i believe them, I remember my grandpa had a few alligator wrenches that cut out int the handles that fit like box ends, so i know the idea is defiantly not the most original, but i think we'll have to see what comes of this, honestly I had never heard of peter atwood until a few months ago, when I was looking for a small wrench, I actually found out about the pocket wrench II and piranha before any of peter atwoods designs, so i think that they really could have designed it beginning to end without even knowing that he existed.I'm not going to post pictures because I don't want to beat a dead horse, but my real problem in the Piranha design is with the bottle opener. The Piranha uses the exact same bottle open as Peter Atwood (Atwrench) and if you look at the Atwrench you can clearly see that the Piranha tool's bottle opener was no accident, IMO...

Like I said before, buy what you like as I can't stop you anyway. :D
-
Got this from Justin at pockettoolx, they said they will have a forum screen name on here sometime soon.
"I've attached an image of the laser nozzle tool that I mentioned, this one is probably about 10 years old."

-
They really are going the extra mile to show us they are totally original and not derived from someone else's work. I applaud their efforts, I wish I could make a pocket tool and have the idea be original. :D
-
I also wanted to add this, when I first starting talking to them I wanted to know how their company got started.....
MK7 Designs is a Seattle-based firm that offers design, engineering, prototyping, and product development services. We also have our own machine shop for production and prototyping. Prior to starting MK7 Designs in 2009, all of us had worked together on various projects over the years and at several different companies. Our backgrounds are heavily rooted in manufacturing, engineering, industrial design and product development/prototyping.
Our first company project was our own "brand," PocketToolX (We now currently have several clients at various stages of product development, but we must keep those company's name confidential until their products have been launched). PocketToolX was created out of the necessity of our team always working on things mechanical, building/constructing things or just general tinkering -- we always carried a good knife (As a side note, we almost exclusively all carry SOGs) but didn't always have a tool box nearby or were we willing to carry a heavy multi-tool such as a Leatherman. Thus, we began the process of developing a slim and lightweight pocket tool that we could carry with us everywhere. Two weeks later the Piranha was born.
We have nearly a dozen products in development right now, with the release of a few scheduled for later this month along with a new updated website. The rest, if released (we don't plan on releasing them all) will come in the Spring of 2010.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




