Design Talk : About flashlights
-
I have carried 3 & 4 D cell maglights with a belt carrier supplied by my local police supply store without discomfort. I tend to stick with inexpensive AA & AAA cells that are easily obtainable.
-
Hiya neoseikan,
You can never have one torch (read flashlight) to cover all needs can you???. Everyone has their own needs from a tool, it depends what thay going to do with it.

I have a few (my wife would say too many!) , I run a 1AAA on my keys, then a fenix CR123 in my pocket, those are my EDC's.
If I need something more powerful I'd grab one of my modded maglites. If I need something with a long run time I'd grab a std maglite LED. If I want to confuse people I'd grab one of my LED modded Welsh miners torches from the early 1900's !
-
I am turning in to more of a flashaholic these days it seems, and would really like to invest in one or two high end lights too. An Ra Clicky would probably be top of my EDC wish list at the moment
I would also like something made of Ti as well, especially for EDC pocket carry.I have a couple of cheaper AA lights - Romisen and Hugsby, which serve their purpose fine. I also like AAA for the keyring, mostly the ITP EOS A3. If I want more oomph, for walking at night or something, I will throw a Fenix LD20 in my pocket.
At home in the bedroom is a lightly modded Maglite 3D which serves nicely as something to
with should the need arise ;)I haven't strayed in to the path of CR123 lights yet but I think it's only a matter of time before I give in! They would have to be rechargables anyway, so that would limit some of the lights I cold use.
-
@nuphoria said:
I am turning in to more of a flashaholic these days it seems, and would really like to invest in one or two high end lights too. An Ra Clicky would probably be top of my EDC wish list at the moment
I would also like something made of Ti as well, especially for EDC pocket carry.I have a couple of cheaper AA lights - Romisen and Hugsby, which serve their purpose fine. I also like AAA for the keyring, mostly the ITP EOS A3. If I want more oomph, for walking at night or something, I will throw a Fenix LD20 in my pocket.
At home in the bedroom is a lightly modded Maglite 3D which serves nicely as something to
with should the need arise ;)I haven't strayed in to the path of CR123 lights yet but I think it's only a matter of time before I give in! They would have to be rechargables anyway, so that would limit some of the lights I cold use.
CR123's are very short , and have high energy densities . This gives you small lights , that are barn burners , with short overall length . They are great EDC's , I would find it hard to settle for AAA or AA lights . With multilevel lights , you quickly learn to use low or intermediate levels ; but it's nice to have a bit of punch in reserve . I find a cell lasts me about 1.5-2.0 months . When bought in quantity , this isn't too expensive to operate .
Chris
-
My Fenix PD10 (1XCR123 with twistie cap) is my goto EDC light at home on the farm. Really bright and decent low beam, it has a very long run time and it's extremely compact and rugged.
That said, as a dedicated, grab and go into the night, light, I LOVE the Olight M21. Extremely floody, it's good as a headlight on the bike, will light up a room when the lights go out and things need to be found, or searching for horses that have gotten out. I like that it has a memory for light setting. The intermittent on is handy, but not essential. It's a clickie, and has been reliable, but I still don't totally trust clickie switches.
Maratec AAA (X1) for keychain. Good compromise size and convenience. Not any where near as bright as the 1XCR123 though.
-
The AAA NiMH cell and the XP-G LED have really transformed my appreciation of the EDC light. Prior to this past December I was using two or three lights to get through the average week of EDC carry. I had a Fenix L2D, Fenix P2D and Fenix E01 and a Princeton Tec EOS headlamp. I was using Alkaline AAA, CR123 and AA cells in three different lights depending on attire and what I was doing that day.
With the release of the 4sevens Preon and the recent iTP H01 headlamp I've become standardized on the AAA NiMH cell and have never been happier. The AAA lights are so much smaller than comparable AA/123 lights that I am blown away. Max output varies from 60-160 lumens and runtime is within an acceptable range as well. I like to see @45min-1hour on high and at least 2hours on medium, low can be whatever since I rarely use it.
My use is general EDC tasks, everything from peaking under the sink to working on my car to exploring abandoned structures. I prefer a balanced flood/throw in my beam and like the neutral tints to my LEDs. Preferred UI would me M/H/L but I've yet to find a AAA light that has this set-up so I make due with the current market offers. Reverse clicky is the only way to fly and I require a lock-out tailcap to even consider a light for purchase.
I only really buy maybe 1-2 lights a year since I'm generally dissatisfied with what the market offers. Seems most users have very different preferences than I do and are more catered to by the boutique flashlight companies so not a lot of the new lights interest me.
-
As the original poster will find , as 10 flashaholics , get 25 opinions !
Chris
-
Hi guys. After a sleep, I was astonished, so many replies.
Thank you all.
It seems that most of you prefer mini lights as a tool, right? AA/ AAA/ CR123. I can understand that, because it's for EDC.
Then, I got an idea.
You know, the recent LEDs are good enough to give good output with good runtime, if we use "High CRI" LED to build an EDC tool light, for example, using single CR123. The only advantage is, the colors can be shown better.
For example, with a regular LED, you can only tell 60% of the color difference, and with the high CRI one, you can tell 85~90% one. In fact that's more compleax than this. -
I like CR123's, so my EDC light is a Fenix P2D, and my looking around outside light is my P3D.
-
I would like to see a Delrin light , machines beautifully , tuff as a pig's nose , threads etc are basically self lubricating . I would love to see a manufacturer think outside the box .
Chris
-
What I'd like to see is a good multi level (med-low-high or med-high), 1xAAA, forward clicky (with momentary on), HA-III, warm tint, robust, waterproof, cheap, optional pocket clip/keyring.........
I don't think that light exists yet, if it does though could someone tell me it's name? ;)
-
@Gareth said:
What I'd like to see is a good multi level (med-low-high or med-high), 1xAAA, forward clicky (with momentary on), HA-III, warm tint, robust, waterproof, cheap, optional pocket clip/keyring.........I don't think that light exists yet, if it does though could someone tell me it's name? ;)
Yeah me too.
-
Good simple user interface , if a clicky - a well engineered one . Ruggedness , HAIII , and a pocket as good as the McGizmo clips .
Chris
-
Thank you!
Then, what's the MAX length / diameter you can accept? -
For EDC carry the ARC AAA & the Fenix E01 are very popular here in the USA. The Preon 1 also is popular. Some people want to see the ARC AA be produced again. For EDC smaller is better.
-
@neoseikan said:
Thank you!
Then, what's the MAX length / diameter you can accept?100mm would be a good length for most people :)
And as narrow as possible

-
There is a plan for mini EDC lights:
800mA output into a CREE XP-G LED.
Single 16340 / 18650 battery.
1~3 brightness levels.Will that be a good config?
-
Readily available batteries, small outer dimensions, and a loooooong-lasting low output are the make-or-break factors for me, and I'm really picky with those two. That said, I'm not sure about that 16340/18650 requirement... :-\
-
@neoseikan said:
There is a plan for mini EDC lights:800mA output into a CREE XP-G LED.
Single 16340 / 18650 battery.
1~3 brightness levels.Will that be a good config?
IMO, 16340 isn't really a worthwhile option. Even the best ones I have owned (AW brand) couldn't store more than ~550mAH of energy. 18650 is a much better option, storing 2200mAH (or more) in a package just a bit more than twice the size of a 16340. 16340 will only give you ~40 minutes of runtime at 800mA. 18650 will give you ~2.5 hours runtime at 800mA. Actual runtimes would vary with the efficiency of the driver, but 18650 will always give you roughly 4 times the runtime of a 16340.
If you want to have the ability to run Li-Ion w/CR123 Lithium primary as backup, I would suggest an 18650 format light that is also compatible with the higher voltage of 2xCR123. For a small EDC light to run Li-Ion, my preference is to run a 14500 in an AA format light, since 14500 has better energy storage capacity than 16340. LSD NiMH can be used for backup in that case, or you can use AA lithium primary such as Energizer L91 if you can afford them, and you could even use alkaline in a pinch.
Of course, there are other options such as the 4Sevens Quark that will allow you to swap bodies, and therefore run many cell options in one light. For instance, a 2xAA quark will allow these options:
2xAA (NiMH, NiCd secondary, or Lithium, Alkaline primary)
1XAA (NiMH, NiCd secondary, or Lithium, Alkaline primary)
1XCR123 (Lithium primary)
1x16340 (Li-Ion secondary)
1x17670 (Li-Ion secondary)
1x18650 (Li-Ion secondary) -
@space cowboy said:
For EDC smaller is better.Well, to a degree, yes. The problem for me is that I can't justify carrying AAA as a primary EDC when AA gives me almost three times the runtime at the same brightness level. AAA lights are indeed small, but the QMiNi AA in my pocket is only 78mm long. I do carry an ARC AAA-P Snow or Fenix E01 around my neck for backup though, and I can run the QMiNi on AAA if I need to.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login