Is a knife a multitool?
-
I feel like I need to explain my question or pad it with my own bias/opinion before just asking: is a knife a multitool? So, let me pad:
-
By knife, I mean a folder, something like the Leatherman c301 or such. Just a blade, without anything else, not like a Buck X-Tract.
-
By multitool, I mean something like a Leatherman, SOG, or SAK. My definition isn't "something with pliers" since a lot of SAK's lack pliers, and I consider them multitools.
-
I realize no single blade will be as versatile as as a full-fledged multitool, but I also think that the best tool is the one you have with you.
-
This question originates from my experience on the weekends that most of the time having my LM c301 is just as good as having anything else, since it can be used to: cut, pry, gently hammer, etc.
So, yeah, this may be one of those questions that as definitive an answer as "which is better: LM or SAK?" in which case...feel free to delete the post. However, if it's not, then let me re-ask: is a knife a multitool? Is it proper to think of yourself as having an MT on you if all you have is a knife?
-
-
I still think this edited quote from Benner covers it pretty well..: ;)
@Benner said:
SAK's - Anything made by Vic or Wenger in either the "traditional" SAK set up, or any of their OH lines.
Folders - Any folding knives that contain blades and blades only (Wenger or Vic knives with blades only are still SAK's).
Fixed blades - Any fixed bladed knife.
MT's - Any tool with more than one function that doesn't fit into any of the above. -
Here is my take. A knife is a tool, so if it has any other tools besides a blade then it's Multi-Tool. :D
-
-
my take is yes you can use some knives to do quite a bit
-
I'd say no, a knife is not a multitool. It's a single tool with multiple uses. At it's very base level a knife is something that cuts and pokes and that's about it anything else is just improvisation, I'd not call a stick a multitool just because I can think of more than one use for it. To me a multitool really has to have more than one tool, each one doing a distinct and different task.
Now a multi bladed knife, with each blade having a distinct task, now that might be a different story. :)
-
@Gareth said:
I'd say no, a knife is not a multitool. It's a single tool with multiple uses. At it's very base level a knife is something that cuts and pokes and that's about it anything else is just improvisation, I**'d not call a stick a multitool just because I can think of more than one use for it**. To me a multitool really has to have more than one tool, each one doing a distinct and different task.Now a multi bladed knife, with each blade having a distinct task, now that might be a different story. :)
If you had a stick that was sharp on one end and big and heavy on the other, it would have a poking tool and a hammering tool, therefor it would be a multitool. :D ::)
-
Ninjas have better swords, more training, more discipline and aren't drunk all the time so they would definitely triumph over pirates. Besides, black is more stealthy. Pirates wear a lot of bling - making them both loud and shiny when they move around.
wrong debate :D -
I'd say no, a knife is not a multitool. It's a single tool with multiple uses. At it's very base level a knife is something that cuts and pokes and that's about it anything else is just improvisation, I**'d not call a stick a multitool just because I can think of more than one use for it**. To me a multitool really has to have more than one tool, each one doing a distinct and different task.
Now a multi bladed knife, with each blade having a distinct task, now that might be a different story. :)
If you had a stick that was sharp on one end and big and heavy on the other, it would have a poking tool and a hammering tool, therefor it would be a multitool. :D ::)
That's no stick! That's a spear! I'm gonna call the cops on you for carrying a deadly weapon! :D
-
@cerbera147 said:
Ninjas have better swords, more training, more discipline and aren't drunk all the time so they would definitely triumph over pirates. Besides, black is more stealthy. Pirates wear a lot of bling - making them both loud and shiny when they move around.
wrong debate :DMac or PC?
No, wait, I was trying to avoid that! AUGH! :ahhh
-
I say if it is a knife only with no other tools, then it is not a multi tool.
-
Oh look.. Pandora's Box... :P :D
-
It can't be. The people who keep bringing up these classification questions are being silly. It only contains one tool so it can't possibly be a multitool. =(
-
@Freudian Frog said:
It can't be. The people who keep bringing up these classification questions are being silly. It only contains one tool so it can't possibly be a multitool. =(I'll gladly accept that answer. I didn't mean to bring up a silly question, but for some reason I couldn't shake it today. There was this image of a soldier stuck in my head, using this big, durable knife to cut stuff, manipulate screws, pry at things, etc., and I kept wondering: if that a multitool or a knife? I really appreciate AHB posting Benner's quote, though, because that clears up my question perfectly.
-
People-who-thinks-the-people-who-keep-bringing-up-these-classification-questions-are-being-silly-are-really-the-silly-ones... :D Or something.. :ahhh
-
@Freudian Frog said:
People-who-thinks-the-people-who-keep-bringing-up-these-classification-questions-are-being-silly-are-really-the-silly-ones... :D Or something.. :ahhh
Oh hush, you! You don't even have a proper name - you are just an acronym!
But I haven't changed it 8 or 9 times...
:D -
@cerbera147 said:
Ninjas have better swords, more training, more discipline and aren't drunk all the time so they would definitely triumph over pirates. Besides, black is more stealthy. Pirates wear a lot of bling - making them both loud and shiny when they move around.
wrong debate :DDude, Ninjas would totally kick a$$ in a fight with pirates! No contest.
PC.
And since we are bringing up big matters of contention:
The Dallas cowboys are the best football team in the NFL, UT is the best in the Big 12, I prefer the backspring phillips, and Gerber sucks! (except for the Octane)
-
@Gareth said:
I'd say no, a knife is not a multitool. It's a single tool with multiple uses. At it's very base level a knife is something that cuts and pokes and that's about it anything else is just improvisation, I'd not call a stick a multitool just because I can think of more than one use for it. To me a multitool really has to have more than one tool, each one doing a distinct and different task.Ditto.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login