Schradetools and Bear Jaws
-
I had a BuckTool 360 that I was quite fond of. It was eventually sold to another forum member who is a bigger fan of Buck than I am, and so I thought he could appreciate it more. I did like it- it was a very interesting take on the whole plier tool design. It also had the nicest black anodizing I've ever seen on a tool- it didn't seem so much like a black coating on the tool as the tool had been fashioned form some black metal. Very nice.
I'm not as big on the Schrade tools as I was on the buck. I have an ST1 and ST2 and I am somewhat unimpressed with the ST2. The ST1 is also an interesting take on the problems facing early multitools as I discussed in my original review of it:
Unfortunately, it's a bulky tool with stubby implements. Great ideas on paper, but just not so good in practice. Now that they are made in China by my arch enemies, Taylor Cutlery, I really have little else to say about them.
I like Bear tools. I only have one so far, but I think if Bear was to start a more aggressive marketing campaign, or promote their tools to enthusiasts like on this forum (DO YOU HEAR ME MR BEAR? MR BEAR JUNIOR? I'M TALKING TO YOU GUYS!) I think they could go far. bear tools, from what I have seen could be contenders for a top spot in the "Tool Hierarchy" but they don't seem to be making the effort.
Personally I think every tool and every manufacturer has something to bring to the table, and I am fascinated by the different, the old and the oddball. I'd like to see more companies start producing well thought out tools rather then just jump on the bandwagon with any old thing like they did 15 years ago.
Def
-
I agree heartily. One of the things that interested me so much about multitools was how each manufacturer put their own little spin on each design. I couldn't understand why Bear, with so obvious an advantage in the outside tools/better handle design, is such a minor player. I wish they'd rethink the locking mechanism as the exposed lever de-locker is awkward and somewhat in the way when using the screwdrivers. I read the excellent review of the Schrade (I'm fascinated by Defender's Taylor Cutlery remark). It's one of those tools with so many eccentricities that you'd really have to love it to carry it. Oddly, I've an acquaintance who carried a Scradetool all through his Army service and into his current position as an IT tech for a local fiber optic concern. He absolutely prefers the Schrade to any of my other tools. I guess you can get used to anything!
-
Is the Bear tool made by Bear Archery, or a separate company? If it's the archery firm I may have to find one ;)
-
@yellowhammer said:
Is the Bear tool made by Bear Archery, or a separate company? If it's the archery firm I may have to find one ;)I think there different companies, but I could be wrong (often am) :)
-
The Bears are 2 seperate companies.The Bear multi-tools were ahead of Leatherman for innovation,with a multi for gradening,and one for electrical work before LM put theirs on the market.
Schrade will be one of the great might have beens.When the doors closed a lot of new and well thought out designs were coming out the doors,it's sad that Schrade is no longer among us,and that nobody will ever know how the multi-tool line would have evolved. -
(I'm fascinated by Defender's Taylor Cutlery remark)
Oddly, I've an acquaintance who carried a Scradetool all through his Army service and into his current position as an IT tech for a local fiber optic concern. He absolutely prefers the Schrade to any of my other tools. I guess you can get used to anything!
First off, Taylor Cutlery is the epitome of evil in the knife world. They take excellent, well established names and turn them into monkey poo. For example, for a hundred years or so, Smith & Wesson has been a well respected name in the firearms industry. They make good quality products, and still do to this day. Enter Taylor Cutlery, who finds the person at S&W responsible for the trademark and name and backs a dump truck full of money up to their house and says "I'd like to use your name for a line of knives." The S&W guy, dazzled by an honest to God dump truck full of money in his driveway, nods, thinking that knives might be a good way to compliment the gun line.
Armed with the rights to the name, Taylor then goes to China to locate the cheapest, most decrepit factories it can find to crank out the cheapest tactical looking junk they can find, buy a few hundred thousand of them, import them to the US and sell them with "Smith & Wesson" stamped on them. These knives, that they bought for less than $1 each would ordinarily sell at Wal Mart for $15 are now sold at $50 because of the S&W logo. People buy them because of the name association with high quality firearms, and are either disappointed with them and never admit to owning them, have no idea how bad the junk is and show off to their friends that they have a S&W knife (friends of course rush down to Wal Mart and throw money at random employees until they get one too), or are the victims of a horrible accident resulting from the knife folding over the liner lock or failing at some other critical juncture.
This is bad right? Well, it gets worse. When a good old fashioned US knife company like Schrade is forced to close it's doors because people have stopped buying real quality tools in favor of these warped imported pieces of junk, the jackals at Taylor are waiting in the wings, wringing their hands and salivating, hoping to snap up a piece of the corpse before it's cold. In this case, they bought the Schrade name and many (if not all) of the patents and designs, danced for a few moments in the misery of many skilled craftsmen now unemployed, and headed off to China where they could crank out the designs at a fraction of the price by using child labor and materials that resemble steel, all with the eye of making even more money by continuing to sell Schrade tools at the same prices as when they were US made, because people know for a fact that the ST1 was a good quality tool. People like your friend, who owned an original Tough Tool and like it (and why not? It was a well made tool with decent quality components and materials) think it's great and buy more of them for tool loving friends for Christmas, birthdays etc and can't understand why you think it's a hunk of crap. Your friend starts to think you are an idiot because he's carried and used the exact same tool for years without a problem, and yours broke in half and caught fire while cutting a particularly thick piece of cheese.
That's why I hate Taylor and all they do. I expect to hear from their lawyers any time now, and I'll bet they can afford good ones with all of your hard earned money lining their pockets and stuffed into closets in the mansions folks have bought them. As far as I am concerned, if they tried sueing me for saying that, it just proves my point about them being spineless vultures.
A hearty one finger salute to all my friends at Taylor! May you one day be trapped in a sinking submarine, and your only hope of salvation is to cut your way free with your own shoddy products!

Def
-
I get the impression you're not keen then mate.
:D -
Not really no...
It's awful products like Taylor that give the whole industry a bad name. I have actually met people who say things like "I had one of those multitools before and it was such a piece of crap. I'll never buy another one."
Of course that isn't just Taylor, it's any cheapo company, and that kind of thing snowballs. Soon you have someone else looking at multitools but deciding that $80 is too much to spend on a Leatherman because a "friend of mine had one and it fell apart in his hands when he tried to use it and he ended up with six stitches across his palm."
Plus, getting back to the topic at hand, some folks simply get to know the major brands like Leatherman and Gerber, and completely gloss over lesser known brands like Bear simply because they figure Leatherman is good and anything else must be a knockoff, making it almost impossible for these brands to get ahead, which would be a good reason for a certain company to contact me in regards to running some promotions that might be very inexpensive and amazingly effective at helping to build their brand....

Def
-
OT I know, but you find that happens a lot in electronics as well. :( I just think it's a real shame as people end up finding out the hard way. Still, it makes forums like these even more important I suppose.
-
Any time someone puts effort, energy and money into trying to develop something good, there's always someone waiting in the wings to swoop in, steal the idea, and cheapen it to ruin it for everyone.
Of course I would like to say that Taylor isn't the only company that does that- like any other parasitic vermin, they reproduce at an astounding rate, and you are right, they are in every industry.
The good news about this is that when a truly good quality new product comes along, it is tested and tested and tested again to make sure it's not swallowed up by all the crap out there. Of course there are many good designs and products that could have gone the distance had there not been so much crap slowing them down. The BuckTool I think is a great example of that.
Def
-
Defender:
I'm heterosexual, but would you marry me?? :o :D ;)
Seriously:
Actually, I noticed this phenomenon when the US Schradetools disappeared from my local Kmart after clearance, then reappeared. Since I'm not really a fan of the ST, I didn't beg the salesperson to get one out of the case, but I wondered whether these were foreign-made. Taylor may make the Winchester multitool as well. A family member gave me one of these last year. There's also a Gerber multiplier knockoff as well, branded Renegade.And on the subject of Bear, one great thing about them was that they'd sell you individual tools so you could customize your multitool-and at very fair prices. I don't know if they still do that after Victorinox's purchase, sale and their subsequent reorganization. The electrician's tool is very cool. It's beefier than the Leatherman model. I used to carry it at sound shows since we always needed to rework cables (mine is the Toolzall-branded unit). The Bear Jaws Sportsman is, I think, the real sleeper. No locking tools, but man that thing will spoil you.
-
Hate-Rant
While not quite as worried about it as that guy over there with the multiple tics and twitches, I do my best to discontinue lines when the manufacture takes their labour to China (or Italy), but it's a hard thing to do business-wise, and this puts my prices up, and people are used to paying sheap chit rates for their stuff.
I tend to haunt Second-hand stores for quality stuff made in their original countries to original standards, not just multitools, but anything.
-
Let me clarify one thing...
Just because something is made in China doesn't necessarily mean it is a cheap knockoff and crappy quality. Some manufacturers are getting some very good products made in China where the labor cost is much lower, which allows them to put decent quality tools into customer's hands for less money. The Chinese factories, like any factory worldwide will make whatever you want, to the specs you want. Some Chinese stuff is pretty darned good.
However, when the company that is commissioning the work to be done specifies that they don't care how something is slapped together and they want it as cheaply as possible, corners tend to get cut and the product suffers, which is the case with Taylor. I have nothing against Chinese made products, I have something against cheap pieces of monkey poo.
As for Winchester, I believe that is Gerber's discount line, and I am not terribly fond of those as well. In fact, many of the "old" gun manufacturer names should be avoided- Colt and Remington are pretty well the same thing from a couple of different vulture companies.
Some of the newer or foreign gun companies commission knives and tools made by companies like Benchmade, and these are pretty darned good, and in no way should be confused with the chunks of crap offered by Taylor and their silly mirror image company, United Cutlery.
Def
-
I have nothing against Chinese made products,
Neither do I, specifically, but there's an odd relationship between stuff that breaks and is faulty and "Made in China" stickers.
(So far most (one or two unlucky pairs may have suffered extra abuse) of my pants have remained intact and functional, so stitching we know is something they have a good workforce for.)
-
I have nothing against Chinese made products,
Neither do I, specifically, but there's an odd relationship between stuff that breaks and is faulty and "Made in China" stickers....
Theoretically the Chinese can make good tools, but examples of such are quite rare. The Byrd Wrench doesn't really do it for me. Best Chinese tool I can think of is the Buck X-tract.
-
I don't really care WHERE anything is made as long as the person who makes it WANTS to be doing it (i.e. his shift leader doesn't urge him on with an AK-47) and gets paid a decent wage. I worked for a US defense contractor and a US aircraft parts manufacturer while I was in college, and not everything they made was a jewel just as not everything made in China is junk. What I hate is when a product has a good lineage due to the innovation and quality of build by its originators-then the company sells out to some schmuck who wants the name but not the effort to keep up the quality-and that's happened when the followup manufacturer has been in the same country as the originator. Besides, once the Chinese get organized in the area of labor, their wages will rise and some other country will undercut THEM. Then we can gripe about how good the Chinese Leatherman tools were compared to the new ones made by Antarctic slave labor.
I have three Chinese Bear Jaws clones that I like much and carried at work to spare my beloved Wave. My major complaint with Chinese multitools is that the ones I've owned had Phillips screwdrivers that rounded off with little effort and one had a plier jaw break (I was not over-stressing it) which nearly caused me a very serious wound. All three are more consistent in setup than the five Bear Jaws I have, but let's be truthful-the actual heft and build quality of the real Bears make them the only ones I'd bet my life on.
-
Then we can gripe about how good the Chinese Leatherman tools were compared to the new ones made by Antarctic slave labor.
Japan used to get a bad name, now they make some fine things.
I have three Chinese Bear Jaws clones that I like much and carried at work to spare my beloved Wave. My major complaint with Chinese multitools is that the ones I've owned had Phillips screwdrivers that rounded off with little effort and one had a plier jaw break (I was not over-stressing it) which nearly caused me a very serious wound.
Leaving the Labour debate for a minute - most chinese Steel I've seen is poor (Taiwanese steel on the other hand is quite satisfactory)
In case I'll declare that any and all Penguin-made products I own are of excellent design and finish!
-
Amen.
I was thinking of the Japanese example when I made my previous post. As a musical instrument tech, Japanese guitars used to get a bashing, but it was just that they were on a learning curve. Now, their guitars get consistently high marks for quality and are quite expensive.
I've never tried Penguin-brand tools, I may have to look them up. Like I say, I've had good luck from my Sino Bear Jaws. The brand that broke on me was a Sheffield. I had a couple of them before I stopped buying lower quality stuff. I don't really trust any of my Chinese-made tools for heavy use. No slight to any country or brand, it's just the way it is.
-
Sheffield? Is that near Usa? South of Beijing?
-
A lot of Japanese stuff used to get bashed. Many of the younger guys here may not believe this, but there was a time when all Japanese manufactured electronics were considered to be garbage. :o
The same thing is happening to China. The current head of the Elsener family (which owns Victorinox) never considered Wenger to be their biggest threat. That wasn't a shot at Wenger, that was recognizing the increasing quality and low cost of the Chinese made knockoffs.
While many of the steels manufactured and used in Chinese plants right now isn't great, I guarantee that will change as well. More and more companies are dismantling US based operations and moving all of their equipment to China. The Chinese plants are using the same machinery, the same materials, and their workers cost nothing, and work long hours, seven days a week. They'll amass the experience of US workers in a fraction of the time as a result, and then, watch out.
Like I said, the crappy Chinese products aren't their fault, it's ours because that is what can be mass marketed here, and we (not us per se, but us "Developed Nations" people) buy them up by the bajillions, especially when it has Smith & Wesson stamped on it...
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



