Sherlock Holmes
-
I've read most of the Conan Doyle too and came to a different conclusion,
True there was a lot of stuff that was given little time in the novels but it was the characterisation that bothered me sherlock was subject to an intersring interpritation as was Watson, I did like Lestrad though
As a matter of taste I feel the BBC Sherlock is closer in spirit than the resent Hollywood offering.
-
PS the wife just read this and disagrees, she thinks Watson was rather good, oh well
-
@InspectorWinter said:
I guess that could be open to interpretation, I am quite an avid reader of Holmes and I thought the film was very Sherlock, it focused on a lot of the things that only took a small part in the cannon novels.I agree here! Though it was not very explicitly stated in writing Sherlock did all of these things - and more! :D
-
Well, at least it's not the Robert Downy Jr. Sherlock ::)
I loved the Downey, Jr. Sherlock!
Well, at least it's not the Robert Downy Jr. Sherlock ::)
I loved the Downey, Jr. Sherlock!
It was a fun film but it was not Sherlock Holmes
THe Downy Sherlock, nothing against Robert Downy Jr. , But the SHerlock character was a bit too "action heroie" for that character

-
Well, at least it's not the Robert Downy Jr. Sherlock ::)
I loved the Downey, Jr. Sherlock!
Well, at least it's not the Robert Downy Jr. Sherlock ::)
I loved the Downey, Jr. Sherlock!
It was a fun film but it was not Sherlock Holmes
THe Downy Sherlock, nothing against Robert Downy Jr. , But the SHerlock character was a bit too "action heroie" for that character

Conan-Doyle does have Sherlock box and practice bartitsu so it is part of the character, but not quite as front and centre as it was in the film. In theory much of the fighting in the film is based on the Bartitsu system.
bartitsu BTW: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bartitsu
-
Just watched that scene in HD, definitely a LM Charge, either an AL or ALX (black scales)

-
@AddictedToTools said:
Just watched that scene in HD, definitely a LM Charge, either an AL or ALX (black scales)
Is no-one going to confirm my findings? Sorry for the double post, but I was expecting some sort of reply ???
-
Just watched that scene in HD, definitely a LM Charge, either an AL or ALX (black scales)

Is no-one going to confirm my findings? Sorry for the double post, but I was expecting some sort of reply ???
If you wanted confirmation why did you say it was definitive? ??? :D ::) :P
-
Yeh, i was wiling to take your word for it :)
-
crimpers or no crimpers? that should settle Al or ALX from a plier point of view
-
Unfortunately you don't see the plier head in the scene
-
@Screwtape said:
Yeh, i was wiling to take your word for it :)Thanks :D
-
i was about to post it and then i found the threat :D
is definitively a charge al/alx
-
We just watched the first two episodes on catchup (if you are in the UK with Virgin it's on there), and I have to say I rather liked it.
There hasn't been much on the BBC I have been interested in for a while drama wise, but this has got my attention :)
-
Sadly only one more episode to go :-\
-
Isn't british TV different form US TV? I.E., british TV show runs for a fixed set of time, then DONE! A year or 2 later, if that shows was a success, then a second series is commissioned.
I think Japan and CHina have a similar TV system.

Certainly beats the US system that drones on FOREVER!! :ahhh
That system is so bad, if I saw Jerry Sienfeld walking down the street>

-
I downloaded ep 3, I'm going to enjoy next 90 min watching it!
-
Sadly only one more episode to go :-\
Tonight 9pm!
But I have heard rumours that they are having talks about second series :ahhh
i wish, it was really good!
-
This morning, producer Sue Vurtue confirmed that there will be a second series of Sherlock, starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman. With overnight ratings just shy of 8 million for the final 90 minute episode with plenty more time-shifted viewers to come, it was almost inevitable.
Created by Sue’s husband Steven Moffat and comedian Mark Gatiss, this Sherlock is a modern-day London-set drama that updates the original, using modern-day technologies for stylistic storytelling devices.
The pair appeared on BBC Breakfast this morning with Sue confirming that “there will be more, it’s just a matter of how many and when really”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0i02yc7y3Y
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login