Imported Slip joints
-
Now that is a striking set of scales

-
Looks good sappy!
What else did ya get? -
a very sexy sawcut whitler. :o
this is the best of the lot by far. the build is outrageous and F&F is as good as i have seen among whitlers. i think the whitler is one of the hardest slipjoints to get right.

have a look at the spring joint here. i've never seen better on a whitler.

i'm totally taken by the sawcut scales but not so much by the scalloped bolsters. plus, they seem to be slightly yellow of all things. the weight is right around that of the kissing crane whitler i posted elsewhere but it stomps the crane in build and finish. this one has put in some time doing what it was designed to do and i have no complaints. the blades are stiffer than the congress and TU quickly. i can see this one getting a lot of use.
-
lastly; a trapper. i got this one to see what all the buzz is about. i've never had a trapper and they seem so popular. well, the price was right.



the RR only confirmed for me that the trapper pattern (at least for me) is only a passing fansy... fasionable and nothing more but, oh what a tart i am for RRs sawcut bone scales. it has the same kind of yellowie tint to the superbly done scalloped bolsters (though not my taste). the blades are very well centered and this kind of western build/ labor could easily add 8-10 times the price paid for this RR.
my issue here is not with the manufactured product as much as it is with this very trendy pattern. it's way too big and heavey at 4 1/4" and not nearly as useful as say a kershaw skyline. the long pull does magnify the poor nail nick on the clip blade which could easily do w/o the matchstrike for a better purchase. the blades (especially the clip) tend to be too light and springy much like the congress. when closing you feel a 'sproing' that's not entirely from the springs. i do not care for the trapper pattern. RR allowed me to confirm this for a fraction of the cost from a high profile maker. -
I'm looking at the backspring of that whittler (3rd) photo and it looks to me like it's cracked? What
am I not seeing quite right here? ??? -
That design uses a split backspring. Its meant to look like that :)
-
Interesting, I never knew or heard of that, thanks.
-
sappyg,
Nice grabs bud. The RR's are great for what they are, ain't they? And as you mentioned they gave you an opportunity to try out a classic pattern (in this case the fullsize Trapper which happens to be the most collected slipjoint pattern out there) to see if you like it for very little money.
And I am with you on the Sawcut Bone, I too like it alot but could do without the fancy bolsters. The only one of that series I have is their large Stockman........

......I am partial to the larger patterns.
Sean,
As Neil mentioned it is a Splitback Whittler. The design has been around a long time, a very oldschool way of doing things. And much more expensive to do as well.
2xTap
-
Thanks again for the clarification. Can anyone take a pic of the split backspring up close? Why do
they do that? I find it all a bit interesting. :) -
Are we talking about the same thing? I thought Sean was talking about the right side spring have a black line in the middle?
-
@2xTap said:
(in this case the fullsize Trapper which happens to be the most collected slipjoint pattern out there) to see if you like it for very little money.
2xTaphey tap,
why is it that the trapper is so popular with collectors? i really don't get the pattern personally. i think it's pretty but not near EDC standards IMO. functionally it's great if you're a trapper but most collectors aren't trappers. you'll get a lot less gunk on you during use on smaller critters but i don't see the intrigue for a collector. i do think the pattern can show off what the maker is capable of to certain degree. i'm not a collector but an accumilator i spose.
on an aside: i have seen 'whitlers' by respected companies that are as far removed from what a whitler is that they can't even be called stockman. -
@jzmtl said:
Are we talking about the same thing? I thought Sean was talking about the right side spring have a black line in the middle?i've gotta learn to clean and clean again before i take a pic.... that was some dirt of some kind from my pocket. i swear it was not there when i snapped. the black thing is not a part of the whitler from RR. in fact, the build and finish is comendable.
sorry sean,
my camera can only do so much. that's as close as i can get.
a true whitler has a split spring that a lot of makers can't get or cheat by making two bigger springs that can handle the load but will develope side to side blade play under the lightest use in my experience. -
(in this case the fullsize Trapper which happens to be the most collected slipjoint pattern out there) to see if you like it for very little money.
2xTaphey tap,
why is it that the trapper is so popular with collectors? i really don't get the pattern personally. i think it's pretty but not near EDC standards IMO. functionally it's great if you're a trapper but most collectors aren't trappers. you'll get a lot less gunk on you during use on smaller critters but i don't see the intrigue for a collector. i do think the pattern can show off what the maker is capable of to certain degree. i'm not a collector but an accumilator i spose.
on an aside: i have seen 'whitlers' by respected companies that are as far removed from what a whitler is that they can't even be called stockman.sappyg,
First thing to take into account is depite what a particular pattern was meant to do or who it was originally designed for, just throw that out of the equation. Slipjoints have been around for a few Centuries now, and your most popular styles now are designs based off of oldschool English designs or Classic American patterns. Many of which have been found to work quite well in all manner of work.
That said, and this applies quite well to the Trapper pattern, simple is best. In it's many forms it is a workhorse of pattern and one that nearly every maker of slipjoints has produced or still is producing. You look at every big name slipjoint maker out there now, every brand.....Case, Hen & Rooster, Boker, Henckels, Bulldog, Weidmannsheil, Eye Brand, Queen, Schatt & Morgan, Robeson, Great Eastern, Northfield, Tidioute, Colonel Coon, Steel Warrior, Schrade, Camillus, Bear & Son, Buck, Remington, Winchester, Canal Street, Rough Rider, Kissing Crane, Ulster, Colt, MooreMaker, Fightin' Rooster, Indian Head, Owl Head, etc., etc. Not all of these brands have Clasp Knives, or Sodbusters, or Swayback Jacks, or Canittlers, or Grandaddy Barlows, or Tear Drop Jacks, or Toothpicks.......but they all have Trappers in one form or another.
Add to that most companies when they produce Anniversary models, Commemoratives, and Special Editions they are often done in the Trapper pattern. On top of that it generally is, in the standard 4 1/8" size version, one of the least expensive patterns. All of this adds up to a top selling pattern for many companies. And it's been doing so for many years.
2xTap
-
@jzmtl said:
Are we talking about the same thing? I thought Sean was talking about the right side spring have a black line in the middle?Thanks Jz, I was looking at that trying to figure out why it looked like a broken backspring trying to make
sense of it. :DSappy, no problem, thanks for the clarification, it happens.

-
point taken...
just wondering why as i am looking for the best (all around) slipjoint for my personal use. collections (accumilations) are loosely based on this among other things.
i grew up around farmers and mill workers and to the man jacks and stockmen were king. goofing around with knives as i do i realize now that these choices were based on use and need though they had several prized folders amongst them yet non were trappers. i've seen many things done with a well made slipjoint but never with such a BIG thing as the trapper.
i think trappers have a trendy look that is easy to make and make look good. at 4 1/4" nobody will seriously carry or use one on a daily basis.... it's just too big but, it offers plenty on room to show off scales and sheild treatment while giving the illusion of utility. ultimately i think there is a trend among makers to make their slips larger than needed. try to find a good 3 1/2" stockman anywhere. oh they are around... case's 63032CV and eye brand's 350 series but that's about it (i left out boker) but the marque names are running to 3 7/8" and 4 1/4". not from working need but for the sake of showcase IMO.
that said... if you know of someone making a good 3 1/2" jack please let me know.
-
sappyg,
It's all in who you know and works for who. Lots of Trapper users out there. And take into account the fact that the Trapper comes in many sizes. The one you have is a standard Trapper at 4 1/8". Trappers come much smaller in the Mini-Trapper, Tiny Trapper, and Baby Trapper sizes. And then their is the King of Trappers, the Jumbo Trapper. A staple of the Remington lines as well as original Camillus. And now made in quantity through Bear & Son and the signature pattern for Great Eastern Cutlery which has brought the pattern back with a vengence. These are 4 1/2" closed and much broader in the frame than the standard Trapper. Add to that the Mountain Man from Queen Cutlery.......a hugely popular pattern for them which is essentially a single blade Jumbo Trapper in both slipjoint and lockback styles.
And as far as serious carry, I know of many who carry large framed slippies. Large Stockman, Jumbo Trappers, Mountain Mans, Folding Hunters, and in my case I EDC regularly a Case Gunboat Canoe..........

..........these are 4 1/4" closed and noticably heavier, thicker, and broader than a standard Trapper. It is one of the few slipjoints that fits my hand extremely well in use regardless of which blade I have open.
As to trends in the slipjoint market, funny thing is happening and has for the past few years......smaller patterns are the rage now. Tiny Toothpicks, Peanuts, Muskrats, and Canoes are the favorites now. And while they haven't surpassed the standard Trapper as the all time collectable they are gaining serious ground.
Now I'd like to add something that is going to confuse you. Jack Knives! A Trapper is a Jack Knife. A Peanut is a Jack Knife. A Barlow is a Jack Knife. A Folding Hunter is a Jack Knife. Pretty much any slipjoint with either a single blade or two blades on one end is essentially a Jack Knife. The term Jack Knife at one time was used to describe pretty much every slipjoint out there. The term is derived from the man believed to have created the first slipjoint knife, Jacque de Liege. Anyway, the term eventually generalized down to any slippie with one or two blades on one end of the knife. This terminology has carried over to pattern names such as Teardrop Jack, Texas Jack, Swayback Jack, Barehead Jack, and the like.
That said, for Jack Knives there are many high quality pieces out there. The question is what exactly are you looking for......a Jack more along the lines of a Barlow style, or something different? Is 3 1/2" you specific size range or will you go 3 5/8" or 3 3/4", or how about 3" even? Do you want one or two blades?
2xTap
-
an exceptional and informative response 2xTap.
the jack that just came in yesterday. i like it a lot but at 3 1/8" it's a wee bit small for my liking but still very usefull i must say. if thing thing came in at 3 1/2- 3 3/4" it would be just right.

to me there seems to be a void of sorts when it comes to slipjoint sizes. i look at so many knives and think 'boy... if that came in around 3 1/2" i'd be all over it'. queen has a real nice looking jack in burnt amber stag bone that is the bomb but 3 1/4" only. no other sizes in that pattern. i've seen the mini trapper and the size is right but could do w/o the spey in lieu of a nice pen blade. in most cases the jump is from 3 1/4" straight to 3 7/8".
ATM i'm leaning toward the case 62032 CV jack (not sure if you call it a texas jack b/c there is a bigger one still).
i have noticed an equal trend towards warncliff blades as well as the peanut size gaining popularity. the little swayback is a good example. actually the warncliff at all that bad. everything has it's place.
sorry for the rant earlier. i'm sure lots of people are using these full size trappers. it's never been common in my area and the size is rather overwhelming to me. i really wanted to like it. do people carry theirs in a belt holster or some kind of pocket slip like your gunboat? when i put the trapper in my pocket i look.... well.... a little happy.
-
sappyg,
Nice Swayback Jack, they are a neat pattern.
As to recommendations, might I suggest the Queen version of the Gunstock. It is a Jack Knife.....

........they are 3 5/8" closed and a pattern I have grown to like. I own quite a few of these. If you want to get an idea of what the pattern is like without jumping into Queen right away, Rough Rider makes a version with a Spearpoint blade. Their frame design is virtually identical to the Queens but at 3 1/2" closed. Here's a few I have........
<a href="http://img502.imageshack.us/i/rrambergunstock01.jpg/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://a.imageshack.us/img502/6199/rrambergunstock01.th.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a> <a href="http://img8.imageshack.us/i/rryellowgunstock01.jpg/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://a.imageshack.us/img8/2628/rryellowgunstock01.th.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a> <a href="http://img502.imageshack.us/i/rrmalachitegunstock01.jpg/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://a.imageshack.us/img502/6357/rrmalachitegunstock01.th.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
Another nice one is the Swayback Jack from Kissing Crane (more of a Humpback really), these are really nice........

.......they are 3 3/4" closed and are of real nice build, if mine is any example. They come in Red Bone, Autumn Bone, Stag, and Yellow delrin. And can be had for a sub-$20 price. The #032 pattern from Case that you mentioned is another good one.
Also take a look at the #69 pattern from Queen Cutlery.........

...........in ACSB and at 3 1/2" closed these might work for you as well.
And also take a look at Schatt & Morgan, their smaller Coke Bottle Jack at 3 1/2" as well......

It's also offered in with a Spearpoint in smooth Harvest Bone..........
There is more but here's a few for you to look at that might help.
Now, as to carrying the bigger patterns there are many options. There are leather belt sheaths available for the bigger patterns, Case makes one specifically for the Trapper. Seems common for those who carry bigger patterns like Trappers and Folding Hunters to carry in the back pocket. Funny I should mention that now that I think about it as Case has two new patterns coming out in November which are Tony Bose designed single blade Jumbo Trappers that are actually called "Back Pocket Knives"! Anyway, some do carry in the front pocket but like you mentioned even I had the occassional incident of my Gunboat Canoe sliding sideways in my front pocket, which did look odd. The Pocket-Slip I carry it in now solved that problem........and they have become quite popular. I know lots of guys toting their big'uns, and others, in this fashion.
2xTap
-
sean changed his avatar again.... 8)....
@tap.... you have one hell of a collection... clearly arrived at through experience. i'm likin' the queen gunstocks in burnt amber stag bone a lot. i've had this gunstock for years and at one time i thought.... 'this is my pattern'

still, it's a bit verically challenged at 3 1/8" but very light and handy. i guess i never really liked the steel more than anything. a nice medium case stockman in CV came in with the swayback jack that i just can't keep out of my pocket.

now i've found my size slipjoint but maybe not my pattern... i don't know. that's a very sexy looking clipblade S&M cokebottle. i think i might try to track one down in carbon.
also, i have a chino/ remington 4" stockman i need to post here. i think it's even better than the RRs i've handled so far.
-
4" remington stockman. bought at a B&M for $9.00.... amazing...



this is a very stout and well built knife. you can see that the F&F is of the highest quality in the spine shot. over the years the bolsters have yellowed. the remington shield is of some type of plastic button and the pins are of brass. the steel is probably 440a and takes a wicked edge. believe it or not the walk and talk are excellent with equally strong springs and 1/2 stop.
IMO this chinese remington smokes the RR's i've handled. buildwise they are similar but of the RR's to date the blades seem to be on the thin side. you can consider that a US made remington will likely run you 10x's the price i paid for this chino and that was about ten years ago. yep.... chinese qualty was that good even then. my 73' case stockman is the only slipjoint that outshines this.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login