Juice Xe6 or Cs4?
-
I just want to hear some different opinions, especially from those who have both, but anyone can chime in.
I am looking to get a juice, and my usual "greedy" self says get the Xe6 because it has more, and more is good. Or is it? I doubt I will use the file or NEED the serrated blade, and those two items practically double the weight of the tool. On one hand, I would hate to need something and not have it, as opposed to have it and not need it. But on the other hand, I am looking to pocket carry(might do sheath but probably not), and I don't want to be weighed down.
Basically, from those who have both, when you hold them both in hand, is it a huge difference or only slight. From those who only have the Xe6, do you find the extra thickness too bulky or chunky? Or is it still comfortable in your pocket without a giant bulge. For those with just a CS4, have you ever been "Man, I wish I had a file right now"?
-
To answer your question, yes there is a fairly significant difference in the size and the weight of the tools.
I have owned both, though I no longer have either, and I found that in my situation I found that the Xe6 is just a little large for pocket carry, while the corkscrew on the CS4 is of very limited use. (unless you like to picnic with wine)@TheRodfather said:
have you ever been "Man, I wish I had a file right now"?YES.
That being said I would highly recommend the diamond file on the XE6. I never personally used the file on the XE6, I didn't keep the tool long enough, but it is the same file as the KF4, which is one of the greatest Multi-tools ever made.
Since you have expressed that you are not adamant against a sheath carry, I would suggest that you look into the Charge AL. It gives you a good deal more functionality than the Juice series, and in comparision to the XE6, can be had for about 10 dollars more. Considering the large size of the XE6 upgrading to the ChAL might be worthwhile. While the Charge is slightly larger it is not much more than the XE6.
Finally you might want to consider going to a store that sells a number of multi-tools to physically handle the tools in question before you buy.
-
I only owned an XE6 for a short period of time, same with a CS4. There is a weight and size difference between the two, noticeable, but I wouldn't call it significant.
As to the file... well, it's the best MT file there is. The Leatherman diamond file is truly fantastic - I used to use the file on my old Kf4 to sharpen chisels and scrapers for painting, and it was fantastic.
-
@asupernothing said:
Since you have expressed that you are not adamant against a sheath carry, I would suggest that you look into the Charge AL.I already have 3 Charges. A TTi on my gunbelt for work, and an XTi in each of my cars. I don't really have a weight issue, it's more of a size thing. I've got a bunch of full size MTs, and a bunch of keychain MTs(I always have a Squirt P4 on my keys, but I have a PS4 coming in the mail to replace it). I'm pretty much just looking for something in between. I might just go with the Cs4 because it is thinner and lighter but still a decent size to fit in the hand when using.
Thanks for that advice though
Still looking to see if someone can talk me into getting the Xe6. It's really just a size/weight thing. That's why I'm leaning towards the smaller.
-
Been trying to figure out which one I'd get, if and when I get the IT Help Desk job or not. Having to dress up more formerly and carry a Surge might be a tad difficult, so was opting for a Juice with the leather pouch.
Seems that leather sheath is more business/casual like that the sheaths for any of the other multi-tools.But then I recently got my Surge and paid $72 for it. Now if I was to buy an Xe6 that would mean about $80 with shipping and engraving. That's a bit out of my league for the moment.
In searching the internet, seems the Kf4 is more of what I would rather have. For some reason the Solar Yellow costs more than the Thunder Gray, grr.
Then found the Juice Pro which is a relic to even get a glimpse of let alone find one. And just so happens there's a used one on eBay I seen the other day.
Although am a stickler with mutli-tools, like them new if at all possible.
If I had my way, Kf4 in Orange scales.

-
I own almost every model of Leatheramn. The Juice models are tricky. I have just never had a use for a corkscrew.
-
I don't have the CS4 so can't comment but the XE6 is a great multitool
Mine mostly lives in my bag :DIf I'm after slimline pocket carry I grab the S2, it has the bare minimum for most ocassions. After that it would be my ever trusty KF4; yeah it's got no scissors but it's got two very capable blades

I've got a Solar Yellow KF4, waaay better than gray :D I always thought gray was harder to get a hold of than yellow

I hope to add a blue CS4 at some point. I do recommend the XE6 as it is the Daddy of the Juice range. [The Pro does have a foil cutter and tweezers but only comes in gray and will be harder to get new] If you find the XE6 too much on the weight side you have an excuse to get an S2

If you need pushing in the right direction take a look at these threads

/topic/16428
/topic/8145
/topic/22005
Some great pics like these from Chako and DaveK :D


Someday I'll take pictures like that

-
For those with just a CS4, have you ever been "Man, I wish I had a file right now"?
You can't sharpen a file. Think about it. File gets dull, and they turn into dead weight. Personally, I don't like files on MTs.
I have a CS4 (My review: /topic/22249) and it fits in the pocket nicely. I don't have the XE6, but I'd guess it'd be a tad bulky in the pocket. Exponentially increasing the weight for just a file and a serrated blade? Nah.
-
What a difference a photo makes. :o
The bottom photo: the Kf4 are just about as far as I'd want to go thickness wise.
Xe6 seem even more bulkier than the Surge. Looks like the pliers would be hard to use with the amount of handle bulk going on there.
They look like one of them rather fat SAKs. Glad you posted the photos, gives a person a bit more insight.The 3 in the middle; Silver, Red, & Blue - what are those?
Didn't mean to jump in there OP: Just amazed at the sheer thickness of tools there, and the pliers on the Xe6/Pro seem more like pimples than pliers.
-
Found the other part of Dave's pic



I am pretty sure the three between the C2 and the CS4 are SC2's
A limited edtion run between 2003 and 2005 :D The only model done with the clear scales. Basically an S2 with a corkscrew.Some other 'juicy' pics here; some of them are mine
I'll get my coat 
/topic/18422 -
@cerbera147 said:
Some great pics like these from Chako and DaveK :D

S2, C2, ?, KF4, CS4, XE6, Pro?
That pic is worth a million words. Looking at the thicknesses, I think the KF4 might even have been a little too thick for my purpose. I think the first three are my limit as far as pocket carry. I don't want people asking "Is that a multitool in your pocket or are you happy to see me?".
@Xelkos said:
What a difference a photo makes. :o
Didn't mean to jump in there OP: Just amazed at the sheer thickness of tools there, and the pliers on the Xe6/Pro seem more like pimples than pliersNo problem. I agree on what the pics add to the thread. Pretty much made up my mind against the Xe6. Way too thick for my taste as far as pocket MTs should be. Wow.
I think I'm going to get the S2 and file/grind the small screwdriver into an awl. That would cover my bases and be small/thin enough to keep in my pocket with my cell phone. Keep the thread going though, I'd like more feedback.
-
@Xelkos said:
Xe6 seem even more bulkier than the Surge. Looks like the pliers would be hard to use with the amount of handle bulk going on there.
Not really; I don't have a problem and my hands aren't particularly big.
Bear in mind that the pliers on the Juice range are pretty slim so that probably makes the handles look thicker than they really are. Like asupernothing says it'd really useful to handle them before making a judgement.
I've got a CS4 and an XE6 and pocket carry them using a belt hanger:
-
Don't forget the Juice pouch; I like it some don't.
/topic/17923

-
psst dan post a pic of it open in the sheath ;)
-
SO WANT A KF4!

-
I had both the CS4 and the XE6. Gave the CS4 to a girlfriend. Having the extra serrated blade for the heavier duty cutting chores is GREAT! Plus, I love Leatherman diamond files. Just the other day, I used the file on my XE6 to do a quickie sharpening job on my friends EXTREMELY DULL pocketknife.
If weight and bulk are an issue, I have a great tip: I hang my XE6 in my back pocket (next to my wallet) from a small caribiner and chain attached to my belt loop. You hardly even notice it's there. Great little tool. Granted, it's no super-steel and doesn't have locking blades, but people have gone decades without those and were fine.
-
good call on the s2. since you already seem to have a fairly complete multitool set, the s2 is probably the best choice for the filler.
i use mine on a key chain and find that it works quite well for that. and it easily fits in my pockets.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

