MUT vs. Charge TTi
-
So, I'm enlisting the (Israeli) army next year (or possibly within two years, still don't know). And I was thinking to buy myself a nice multitool for my 17 birthday, so far I carried a SAK (forester) usually when I was outdoor (I don't carry a multitool when in urban environment). So far my SAK was used only while outdoors (usually camping and hiking), but things are gonna be different.
I talked with my father (who was a paratrooper) about the possibilities and he was very impressed with the MUT pliers (especially the cutter). But he said the hammer looks poor, and that the weapon handling tools (the pin and the scraper) are unnecessary, because you rarely need to disassemble and clean your gun in action, and when not in action, you can use the cleaning kit. He was much more impressed with the Charge (lightweight, separated knives), especially with the CAN OPENER (yes, that's a huge plus).
Now, my father is not a multitool expert, but he knows the needs of soldiers (specifically Israeli soldiers, who apparently have different needs from other soldiers). so that's what I questioned him about, he said you usually use stones and other tools for hammering. Scissors, can opener, knife, pliers and wire cutters are being used very often. File & saw are rarely being used. And for cleaning and disassembling your gun you usually use the kit. Besides for military needs, I use my knife, saw & awl on my SAK (which I carry when outdoors) very often.
With those in mind, I come to you - fellow multitools lovers. Which tool do you think suits the best for my needs?
P.S - I don't know which unit I will enlist to, but I know it will be a field unit (combatant unit) which is anything from artillery & tanks, air force & navi to infantry and commando - all carry and train with guns (even if only for part of their service).
Thank you.
-
I think the Charge is a better choice for an all around tool. I have both and use the MUT mostly when on the range. I do think the hammer is well made and has stood up to pounding in nails. You father has a good point about the rocks though. Of these two, I would get the Charge. I think it's a better all around tool, especially if you need a can opener and intend to use a separate rifle cleaning kit.
One other suggestion, take a look at the Leatherman Surge. It's a beefier version of the Wave with a T shank connector for the saw and file so you can just replace them. Also, the scissors are on the outside. One note about the Surge knives, there is no premium steel option and the blades are over three inches. I don't know if either of those are issues for you.
Stay safe in your military service.
-
@gadgetman7 said:
I think the Charge is a better choice for an all around tool. I have both and use the MUT mostly when on the range. I do think the hammer is well made and has stood up to pounding in nails. You father has a good point about the rocks though. Of these two, I would get the Charge. I think it's a better all around tool, especially if you need a can opener and intend to use a separate rifle cleaning kit.One other suggestion, take a look at the Leatherman Surge. It's a beefier version of the Wave with a T shank connector for the saw and file so you can just replace them. Also, the scissors are on the outside. One note about the Surge knives, there is no premium steel option and the blades are over three inches. I don't know if either of those are issues for you.
Stay safe in your military service.
Thank you, I never considered the Surge as an option, the T shank and the scissors looks great. and the knife size isn't an issue. knife laws in israel are very forgiving when it comes to multitools or knives designated for a specific job.
Any other suggestions/ opinions?
-
@Kidi said:
He was much more impressed with the Charge (lightweight, separated knives), especially with the CAN OPENER (yes, that's a huge plus).Now, my father is not a multitool expert, but **he knows the needs of soldiers **(specifically Israeli soldiers, who apparently have different needs from other soldiers). so that's what I questioned him about, he said you usually use stones and other tools for hammering. Scissors, can opener, knife, pliers and wire cutters are being used very often. File & saw are rarely being used. And for cleaning and disassembling your gun you usually use the kit. Besides for military needs, I use my knife, saw & awl on my SAK (which I carry when outdoors) very often.
I'll second the suggestion of a Surge. I think it is the perfect tool for you based on what you've said. It hits every one of the parts in your post that I emboldened.
Scissors are outside accessible. That means that all the tools your Dad described as being used often are easy to get to (except for the can opener) in one move.
The blades are OHO.
You don't use the saw or file much in the service, but you personally use the saw in your personal life. The Surge will allow you to leave the file at home and just keep the saw on board.
And you mentioned you use an awl. The Surge has one, the Charge does not.
In addition, due to it's weight, the Surge can be used as a makeshift boat anchor, a bludgeoning weapon, a tire chock, ship ballast, a dive weight, and a door breaching tool (you just stand back ten feet and throw the Surge at the door).
:D
Just kidding. It is a large multi, and a bit hefty, but I do like it a lot. I think you would too.
-
+1 for the Surge

-
Kidi, I just finished my service in the IDF 3 months ago. So feel free to ask me anything.
I wasn't in a field combat unit, but I know a thing or two about their needs and uses of multitools, plus I carried a Supertool 200 on my belt the whole time. And let me tell you, I used it a lot!
I agree about the can opener, There's always a shortage. And about the rifle cleaning and maintenance.
I think your best bet would be one of the bigger tools like the Core (discontinued), Supertool 300, Surge ,Wave and Charge models.
I would recommend the Supertool 300, because of it's relative simplicity. Even though it doesn't have outside opening blades, or scissors it has longer dedicated screw drivers, and no bits to warp or lose. It has the beefiest pliers, and In my opinion, the most comfortable handles when using the pliers and the inside tools.
And it has less nooks and crannies for dirt to accumulate in.Good luck!!!

-
+1 for the Surge or SuperTool 300,both are great tools!

-
Thank you all, I just ordered a black surge with a nylon sheath from ebay (75$ not including shipping).
threeme2189 - מזל טוב על השחרור -
Black Oxide Surge or Black Oxide Charge would be my options for military use. Won't go wrong with either of them. I have both, and I would pick a BO Charge, because it's lighter.
The MUT doesn't impress me too much. I shoot my rifle frequently and as you say there is always my kit nearby to run maintenance on it. It's also very big and heavy, prohibitively so for me.
Good luck on your decision.
-
I today I could touch the MUT (standard, not black and EOD). It 's really a great multitool, very particular in relation to charge TTI, too bad for the price really high here in Europe.
-
Kidi, how do you like the Surge?
-
Just received the tool yesterday, it's awesome. Not as big as I expect but it was really heavy. Still leaves black stains on my hands, and the tools are kinda stiff (especially the bit driver, almost broke my nail trying to pull it out). The saw and file were smaller than I expected.
I don't like the MOLLE sheath, it's just way too big, and makes a big tool huge. Luckily the Surge (and the extra file) fit nicely in one of my SAK sheaths.
I got to hold the MUT ,myself, and it's a great tool, but for my current and near future needs, I think the surge is the right choice.
Thank you all for your help!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login