Paladin PT-540
-
Yep, all is not wonderful with the PT-540.

One thing that I found disappointing is the blades and tools. Despite having LOTS more room in those oversized handles, the blades are all standard SOG length. The knife blade, the file, the saw blade: each one of them should be about 1/2" longer than they are.
What's the sense of having longer handles if the blades inside them are all standard length?

-
The ability to use off the shelf parts?
Def
-
@Defender said:
The ability to use off the shelf parts?Def
The PT-540 will accept any of the off-the-shelf SOG implements.
But its so BIIIIGGG!! It just seems like they should have put some bigger-than-standard tools in it. Y'know, like screwdrivers with extra long reach. Or a saw blade with an extra half-inch of stroke. Important things all.
-
Good reports on the PT 540, thanks!
I too wish they would do away with the flappers completely, why not just go Swisstool like and put all of the tools on the outside of the handles where they should be so you don't have to open the plier to access them. It looks like from the picture of the Powerassist that half the tool is going to be like this anyway, so come on SOG just make both handles the same and ditch the flappers once and for all. AND, if I'm going to wish for things why not take the whole powerassist idea one step further by putting not just one blade, but two blades (one straight and one serrated) on the outside position of the handles with thumbstuds and powerassist, and on the other handle rig up a very long bladed saw and some big usable scissors with the same setup?? Sound good? Does to me...I would love to be able to just flick open my most used tools

-
-
not just one blade, but two blades (one straight and one serrated) on the outside position of the handles with thumbstuds and powerassist, and on the other handle rig up a very long bladed saw and some big usable scissors with the same setup??
Like a Surge you mean? ::)
Does SOG make special run designs for any other companies?
I don't have a lot of use for electrical tools.Except maybe crimpers and wire strippers, for 12v stuff, and I suppose I could use a drywall cutter once in a while, and maybe I'd use those Punchdown blades more often if I knew what they were

REGARDLESS, the question stands.
In other issues - I've never had flappers. They seem somewhat inconvenient for the hasty gentleman, (as do inside opening blades) - still, all that "used by the military, Yay!" advertising is getting to me...maybe I need one?
(I've yet to see anyone on a .mil site mention them though, they seem to spend more time talking about the most comfortable boots, and whether or not moustaches should be allowed)
-
@edap617 said:
I don't like multitools with flappers. Can the flappers of SOG MTs be easily remove?The covers are easy to remove and replace without any tools. They just snap into place. But without the covers, the pliers will have the same ergonomic flaw as the old Leatherman tools. The predecessors to the PowerLock, the Power Plier (e.g. T52 and T65), lacked the covers. The Power Plier is in the middle of the photo.

It was also available in stainless if gold isn't your style.

-
@Nomad said:
...I've yet to see anyone on a .mil site mention them though, they seem to spend more time talking about the most comfortable boots, and whether or not moustaches should be allowed...Are you going to keep us in suspense? What are the most comfortable boots?

-
@Nomad said:
not just one blade, but two blades (one straight and one serrated) on the outside position of the handles with thumbstuds and powerassist, and on the other handle rig up a very long bladed saw and some big usable scissors with the same setup??
Like a Surge you mean? ::)
Well yes and no. All the tools accessible without opening the pliers, with the blades, scissors and saw all being powerassisted.
-
@Mike D said:
Well yes and no. All the tools accessible without opening the pliers, with the blades, scissors and saw all being powerassisted.Seems like one flaw in the PowerAssist is that there are only two blades in the one entire handle.

Must be the powerassist mechanism takes up a lot of space?
-
I always thought AO blades were best when the knife could be in hand and situated the way you want it within 2 seconds or so...the Powerassist needs to be unsheathed, then you have to feel around for the side with the blades, then you have to know which blade you're going to deploy...
It's a good idea, but not good enough to forfeit a handle full of drivers/an awl/bit driver/etc...
-
I just joined this forum and, wow, what a great resource! All the questions I asked Supratentorial about regarding the PT-540 is answered in this thread. Greta pics too! I was glad to be informed that the blades are not any longer than on the Powerlock - that's unfortunate. Its still a very impressive MT! I also noticed only one square tool cover stop on Supratentorial's PT-540 handles and two on J-sews PT-540 so it shows that they're slowly improving it as they go. If only they would design a tool lock good enough to make all the tools accessible with the handles closed. The current SOG/PT locking mechanism apparently doesn't provide enough locking power so safety is an issue (don't want the tools, especially a blade closing on some fingers!) However, Victorinox made a good enough lock so their tools open without opening the handles. Gerber even did it with their Freehand. Now its SOG's turn.
-
Good eye for small details there Carl. Must say I agree with you on where SOG should focus their efforts. Everyone agrees that they make fine quality tools, better in many respects than their competitors. Yet most folks seriously dislike the number of steps required to access a PowerLock knife blade.
If only SOG could work on improving that a bit.......

-
Yeah, I totally agree. SOG makes a very fine Extraordinary ( no pun intended!) multi-tool. But the design is old old old technology. Seriously, look at the locks-how simple are they, or the 'doors' just to cover up the old technology! I personally think SOG can make some of the best tools! But, they have to stop with the dated designs!!!
-
-
@carl said:
Just out of curiosity, has anyone here spoken with SOG about their dated locks? What was their response? Does SOG know that their design priority needs to be placed on their locks rather than on nice but non-essential features such as power-assist, etc. ?For better or for worse, SOG placed their design priority on locks last year. The result was "piano locks" like the ones shown below.
(picture from SOG website)

-
Agreed that they needed to upgrade the locks, but I hope they come up with a better steel for the cutting edge on the now powerplay. Unfortunatly I feel that the steel used now is really substandard.(not that tools are known for really having great steel.) Vic, and leatherman really did themselves a favor by sticking with good steel on hte Vic, and great steel on the leatherman in 154C
-
For better or for worse, SOG placed their design priority on locks last year. The result was "piano locks" like the ones shown below.
(picture from SOG website)
[/quote]Oh well (sigh).........I guess we're in for inside opening tools rather than outside openers for a good while to come.
-
I'm wondering if there are some design patents on it that prevent everyone doing it?
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login