Sharpening stones
-
I just ordered a couple of sharpening stones from www.dmtsharp.com. I got a 600 grit diamond bench stone and a double sided 1200 grit diamond and 2200 grit ceramic stone. 2200 grit can put a pretty good polished edge on a blade. DMT actually has an 8000 grit diamond stone. I might get that some time but 2200 grit can put a decent polished edge even on carving tools. 1200 grit is about as high as you would want to go for any practical utility edges. I'll let you know how they work when I get them.
-
They are great stones aren't they :)
-
Diamond stones cut fast and restore an edge in only a few strokes. 1200 grit puts a nice fine edge on. I am going to start whittling and carving with my son so wanted the 2200 grit. I will see how well the ceramic performs. I don't know how the real fine 8000 grit diamond compares with a Japanese waterstone. You want that polished edge for carving not just because of the fine edge but it reduces friction on the bevel.
-
I need to get some good stones (probably Japanese wet stones) and practice my "hidden" skills!
-
DMT has a new 8000 grit diamond stone that has an advantage over a Japanese waterstone in that it always stays flat. I don't know how well it works. I might get it for my carving stuff. I am just going to do some whittling now and that 2200 grit ceramic I got should be enough. It will put a decent polish on. The 1200 grit will put a good razor edge on my utility multi-tool blades.
-
I found this excellent site on knife sharpening today. Check it out. It also covers the different types of alloys used in knives.
-
DMT is a fantastic product. i actually only use their stones and have put the others away. just be carefull when using them. a little presure goes a long way to sharpen them. Best thing is I work right next door from them in Hudson ma and I do the snow removal for HP. We used to be able to go Dumpster diving there, and I had recieved by this most every product that they had made but unfortunatly this year they locked up the dumpsters. :ahhh
-
Too bad, you can't party with the bag ladies anymore. Yes diamond stones are very aggressive. I've had a small DMT and some Smith's. You don't need much to get the job done. And if the stone glazes for some reason with the metal shavings you can clean it under water with something like an old toothbrush. It has a 2200 ceramic as well. They are real easy to clean, just rub with some Comet to remove the metal and stop the glazing. Now I want that 8000 grit DMT just came out with. Japanese waterstones are real expensive and need a lot of maintainence.
-
I'm torn between getting some of these stones to freehand sharpen knives, or a "kit" type thing like the Sharpmaker...
-
@Corrugated said:
I'm torn between getting some of these stones to freehand sharpen knives, or a "kit" type thing like the Sharpmaker...Both ways have their advantages and disadvantages. Kits have jigs and allow you to get a good consistant flat bevel. Their disadvantage is that you are limited to the angles on the jig. Free hand allows you to set bevel angles for the task and do things like a double bevel. Of course it takes practice to get a good even flat bevel. If doing it freehand it's much better to use a large benchstone even for small blades. It's easier to get that consistancy. Modern diamond and ceramic is so superior to old Arkansas stones. They tend to glaze and are hard to clean out and then don't sharpen anymore. Diamond cuts fast. On a typical utility blade on a multitool just a few strokes will restore an edge.
-
Not to get too much off topic, but has anyone tried the block sharpener or the hunters honer. I have seen their websites and have had the blade of one of my multitools sharpened by the block sharpener. it worked great but with only one knife hard to tell how versitile it is. If anyone out there has one please say a few words as to how good they are. Thanks
-
Hmmm... I just looked at the hunter's honer. It's 2000 grit ceramic. Should be similiar to the 2200 grit ceramic I got from DMT sharp. That is around 7 microns. It should give you a very polished razor edge. To compare 600 grit which is usual for most utility sharpeners, DMT has one at 750 grit is around 25 microns. I presume you are refering to the Eze-Lap block sharpener. That is probably more a utility grit in the 600 to 750 range. I'd get both. You might want a grit in the 1000 to 1200 range for intermediate sharpening. Ceramic stones are real easy to clean the glazing on if it builds up. Just lightly scrub with a little Comet. The only thing I might consider is that the hunter's honer is about $30. The DMT Diafold I got was $40. It gives you both a 1200 grit diamond on one side and a 2200 ceramic on the other. Check it out at www.dmtsharp.com.
At the point of a polished edge it's going to be more a matter of how fine an edge a typical multi-tool blade will hold. My new stones come tomorrow and I will find out.
I also have a Smith's sharpening jig. It sets at a 20 or 25 degree angle and has a 325 grit for shaping the bevel and a 750 grit for fine sharpening. Also included is a triangle Arkansas stone for serrated edges. It works real good but the clamp can scratch the knife a bit. It costs about $25.
-
The Diafold's are a really good bit of kit, I've used mine for what must be at least ten years and it's held up really well :)
-
"kit" boy you Brits.
If you really want to get anal I was looking on Amazon and they carry the Shapton brand of ceramic waterstones. They go all the way to 12000 grit. From the reviewers comments it will produce an edge far sharper than a razor. One of those will set you back for just under $100.
-
@FredKJ said:
"kit" boy you Brits.If you really want to get anal I was looking on Amazon and they carry the Shapton brand of ceramic waterstones. They go all the way to 12000 grit. From the reviewers comments it will produce an edge far sharper than a razor. One of those will set you back for just under $100.
I think 12k really is for the anally retentive amoungst us :D
-
Yeah but now that I see it I want. I guess it's that Benner magpie syndrome. I do have some carving knives. 2200 grit is probably at the upper limit of an edge that you can put on the steel of a typical multi. It also gives a decent polish. It's really hard to put an edge on that refined and it takes a very good steel to hold an edge like that. You also have to be very skilled to produce an edge at that level.
-
A mate of mine (unka colin for those who know)uses up to that grade when he restores swords and knives :)
But year your right, it takes a fearsome amount of skill to use a stone like that properly :o
-
Yeah but now that I see it I want. I guess it's that Benner magpie syndrome.
I've been really good recently. :)
Is that along the lines of what Mae West would say, "When I'm good I'm good, when I'm bad I'm better"?
I was looking at a reviewer telling how to test an edge on that stone. Run it on the back of your head and if it catches on the hair and stops it's ready. Of course it seems like you could cut your neck in the process. An edge like that will cut by just being near something. I might get the DMT 8000 grit diamond though. It might cut a little more aggressively and should still give a good polished edge.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login