Show your slip joint's thread!
-
I decided to buy a few reasonably priced but interesting looking slipjoints about a month ago, which arrived during the past week or so.
Some canoes (the buck, last one, is the most attractive of the lot, the rough rider stag does not look "right" to me).
Also some more rough riders (the large toothpick looks and feels quite good), a few wengers (were on sale in a normal shop...) including an eloxy which I was not aware of before but which is impressive in its simplicity and a couple of mini buck toothpicks.
I was surprised by the fact that I had problems with the knives of two different companies, first time I had any real problem with any of their products.
The Rough Rider 6 blade stockman came with pathetically weak springs on the two larger blades (they work slightly better now after extensive cleaning) and a crack on the bone scales.
I noticed only the weak springs when I first got it and decided to keep it, even though the seller offered to take it back and then I saw the crack, but did not bother contacting the seller again. Based on what I read about this model on the internet I must have got the only problematic one.
???
The yellow buck mini toothpick came with both scales practically unstuck and discoloured and with oxidation inside. It seems like it was kept near some oxidising chemicals, maybe in a very hot and humid environment. I got a refund so I can’t really complain, I was just surprised that this was actually sold as new and theoretically checked before shipping..jpg)
-
dks,
Nice grabs bud. Sorry to hear you got a few lemons in that bunch though. That Stag Buck Canoe is sweet. The Stag looks that way because it's torched. Bear and Sons has done quite a few runs in torched India Stag and I've seen some of theirs look just like the Stag on that Buck.
2xTap
-
The Buck Canoe looks great. Does it have a spring for each blade or do they share a single spring? I like the kind that share one spring as they tend to be slightly slimmer.

-
Each blade has its own spring. They are about 12mm thick
These were bought unseen, so the stag "look" varies from one to the other, as shown in the pictures.
Quality is similar for all, that is, quite good, though the spring tension differs slightly between them, but it’s still OK.
The bone ones are thinner by about 4mm.
I have not really used any of them for anything but they feel solid. -
dks,
Nice pics bud. The Stag on all of those looks great, as does the F&F. I only have one of the imported Bucks, a 301. It's ok but I was disappointed in it as I have seen many others just perfect in F&F.
Might have to get me one of these Stag Canoes though.
2xTap
-
Many thanks, the quality of them is, generally, very good. There are no rough edges, the gaps are quite small and they come sharp and with no mystery oil/dirt in their joints.
From my (note: MY ;) ) experience (owning and handling, not so much from actually using hard), comparing slipjoints of this category (inexpensive, usually not made in the west) they seem/feel to be a “click” better than Rough Rider, similar to Boker Plus, better than Steel Warrior (though I only have 1-2 of the last two brands…) and a lot better, especially in QC, than the new schrades. Though not a statistically significant observation they appear to be at least as good as a, similarly priced, German Bull I have and have smoother action than my SRM slipjoint.
(The first rough rider is not a slipjoint, I just thought those two looked nice together) -
dks,
Funny you should mention Rough Rider as I am told that the factory over in China that produces the Rough Rider line of slipjoints (as well as many others) are the same people building the imported Buck slipjoint line.
2xTap
-
And speaking of Stag, just had a new one myself come in a couple days ago...........


2008 production GEC Stag Muskrat. I have to honestly say I am not a fan of the Muskrat pattern. Of the hundreds of slipjoints I own, out of those I think I have but one or two Muskrat patterns. It's not that I dislike the pattern it's just that they never really appealed to me most often. And I have to admit this one from GEC surprised me a bit because I like it alot more than I thought I would. After getting it in hand and getting the blades open and toying with it, at least this variation, I can appreciate the appeal the Muskrat pattern has on some people.
It is a nice pattern. But for me initially, getting this one had more to do with it being in Stag and bladed in 440-C, and at a great price! And the Stag is quite nice..........

The knife is 4 1/8" closed with nickle/silver bolsters and shield, brass liners and pins, and polished 440-C stainless blades. This knife came from a pre-owned but unused collection. Fit and finish is near perfect, although this one came with a small cosmetic flaw on one of the bolsters but nothing major. F&F is typical GEC with nary a gap anywhere, stout backsprings, zero blade play throughout, etc. But also typical for GEC's of this time is the fact that the edges need a little work as they didn't come real sharp. But I ain't complaining as it's overall F&F is still excellent.........

This one has me actually looking at other iterations of this pattern that are still available.

2xTap
-
That is some nice stag;
I especially like the one on the side with the shield, really good, deep pattern.
I doubt you could get anything close to that for Buck canoe money, at least not from ebay.
Mind you I have enough problems deciding to use the Buck stag ones, in case they break or get lost, that’s why I got a few for backups...... :DAs for RR and Buck being made in the same factory, it is a possibility, first time I saw one of each together I thought of that since they are similar in shape and size, especially when closed (they have to, they are both canoes), but the grinds and blade thickness are different, stag used also differs (though, stag canoes seem to cost about the same from both), and the decoration on the bolsters is different… These of course can easily be made to the specific order.
Fit and finish is, however close… I have no idea which factory makes them, but it must be a good one… Someone said that most, decent quality, Chinese knives are made in the same region. It would be funny if SRM made those too… -
dks,
Yeah, GEC uses some nice Stag. And they bookend it pretty well. And nope, you won't find any of this even close for Buck Canoe money. Even on factory "seconds" they go for alot more than any of the imported stuff.
As to the makers of Rough Rider and the imported Bucks, I should of clarified........they actually are the makers of the Imported Buck line. The Rough Rider line is owned by SMKW's (jointly with Blue Ridge Knives). SMKW's has also had a longstanding relationship with the Buck family. According to Steve Koontz over at SMKW's Buck had a hand in setting up the factory that is churning out their imported line and with the quality they are producing there, and their connections, SMKW's went with them to produce their Rough Rider line. This factory also produces the new line of Colt slipjoints as well as the new imported offerings for Remington, and the newer Marble's line of slipjoints.
2xTap
-
I've posted same thing on another thread, so I'll repost it here...
I do like Sunfish / Elephant Toe type of knives, but due to their price I didn't thaught of getting one (I'm a user not collector)... Then I've discovered few manufacturers like Rough Rider, Marble, Hammer Brand which are afordable for me. Seems that they have overall thumbs up for EDC quality.
Any thaughts and experiences?
-
For a imported Sunfish/Elephant Toe I would recommend Rough Rider. I own many a RR and the overall quality of them is way above their price. That said I don't own any of these particular patterns from Rough Rider so I can't comment on them specifically.
As far as the new Hammer Brand line, these are being made by Taylor Cutlery and I've heard both good and bad and not alot in either direction so I can't say if they would be a good choice currently.
As for the imported Marble's line, I have a few in various patterns. While pretty good quality for the money they ain't quite as good as the Rough Riders in their overall fit. They don't seem to be as consistant in F&F as the Rough Riders, but still a good buy when had in the RR price range.
2xTap
-
@2xTap said:
For a imported Sunfish/Elephant Toe I would recommend Rough Rider. I own many a RR and the overall quality of them is way above their price. That said I don't own any of these particular patterns from Rough Rider so I can't comment on them specifically.As far as the new Hammer Brand line, these are being made by Taylor Cutlery and I've heard both good and bad and not alot in either direction so I can't say if they would be a good choice currently.
As for the imported Marble's line, I have a few in various patterns. While pretty good quality for the money they ain't quite as good as the Rough Riders in their overall fit. They don't seem to be as consistant in F&F as the Rough Riders, but still a good buy when had in the RR price range.
2xTap

-
You learn new things every day!
I have been thinking about colt and marbles slipjoints (some of the colt stag looks good), but I have not yet seen something that I felt I had :D to have from their range. They also appear to be more expensive than RR, at least on ebay. Maybe one of these days...... -
dks,
The newer Colt slippies are more expensive than the Rough Rider line, but if the few I have are any example they are well worth it. I got these a while back from the Colt Brown Stag Bone line and they are flawless in build............


The fit and finish on these two is every bit as good as the best American made slipjoints in my collection.
Now this one below is another Colt, this one from the Samuel Colt Signature Series in Black Stag Bone........

Fit and finish on this is good, on par with your average Rough Rider. It has some blemishes but decent none the less. But not on par with the previous two.
2xTap
-
They seem like they are worth a try. I may have to get one of each stag models to see for myself. if they are as good as you say they are then their price is quite reasonable.

-
dks,
Definitely worth a look, especially if you can find them at more Rough Rider type pricing.
2xTap
-
I have three Chinese-made Buck slip joints: a Stockman, a Muskrat, and a Trapper. The fit and finish on all of them is great! All three of them have seen pretty hard use, especially the Stockman, and have held up VERY well, mch better than I thought they would.
-

G10 Peanut.
Case Sodbusters.



Peanuts. -
Very nice indeed - some of my faves there :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login