First tool, need recommendations
-
PyroJames, I am considering the SOG. The Paladin PT-540(i think SOG-made) looks good, but no crimpers and a few extras I don't need.
Duncan and zed, the quality of the blade isn't a very important detail for me. I like the Wave, but there's no wire crimper and the pocket clip is extra. Seems like I might as well go for the charge because I'll probably carry with the pocket clip.
Also looking at Surge and ST300, though they're kinda big.
I'm also looking at the Bear and Son electrician MT, which has a wire stripper head.
Am I overanalyzing for my first tool? Maybe I should just get a Gerber Suspension for $27 shipped and then upgrade when I better understand my real needs/wants.
-
Well first off welcome on board and second off you can over analyze but theres no pain in just thinking about what you want. I went with an ST300 for my first tool and really enjoy it (its still my workhorse at home tbh) but found I had a need for different tools. You can't really go wrong with a Charge TTi because it covers pretty much every base and is lightweight and handy. If weight wasn't an issue though I would say go for the surge because it will never let you down and although its a brick that has advantages as well as disadvantages.
-
Welcome!
We have a small farm and we've been doing major renovations to the basement (new walls, new bathroom, new circuits, replacing the old wiring in large areas, new lights etc). I use my Charge ALX for the vast majority of the work. If I'm stripping a small number of wires, I find the hard wire cutter works pretty well for stripping (rounded cutting area), just don't clamp down too hard.
If I'm doing a lot of stripping, I actually find using a Victorinox knife with bottle opener works best: Partially open the main blade, place the wire in there, hold the blade against the wire,rotate around a couple times and then pull the insulation with the groove in the bottle opener.
I still use linesman pliers for cutting cable and twisting wires together, just faster that way.
-
sorry welcome
so does the charge come with a clip
i thought it was a extra like on the wave . ive got a st300 and love it but big for edc, its drivers are very long so can squeeze into tight spaces, but for size and weight and versatility i think the wave is a great choice and if you have the extra cash the tti is next, -
@Zed said:
sorry welcome
so does the charge come with a clip
i thought it was a extra like on the wave . ive got a st300 and love it but big for edc, its drivers are very long so can squeeze into tight spaces, but for size and weight and versatility i think the wave is a great choice and if you have the extra cash the tti is next,You get a clip on lanyard and clip for the charge (although it has Leathermans hidden lanyard anyway...)
-
sorry welcome
so does the charge come with a clip
i thought it was a extra like on the wave . ive got a st300 and love it but big for edc, its drivers are very long so can squeeze into tight spaces, but for size and weight and versatility i think the wave is a great choice and if you have the extra cash the tti is next,You get a clip on lanyard and clip for the charge (although it has Leathermans hidden lanyard anyway...)
yeah the wave has the hidden lanyard hoop i use mine, plus i have the extra loop and i have a clip on my wave, i didnt know these came with the charge or was a aftermarket extra ,
-
FWIW, Bear makes an electrician's tool:
SOG is also a good choice as they are virtually indestructable and can be outfitted however you like, including with a set of fold out wire strippers.

http://sogknives.com/store/100-442.htmlFailing that, I would suggest if you do a lot of electrical work and the wire strippers are an absolute necessity, get a full sized tool that suits your needs, then get a Leatherman Squirt E4 for a few extra options and wire strippers.

http://www.multitool.org/Leatherman-Tool-Group/Keychain-Tools/2006/12/06/squirt-e4.htmlGoing with something like a SwissTool Spirit and the Squirt E4 would leave you better equipped for around the same money as an aluminum Charge would cost, and a lot less than a titanium Charge.
If you wanted to stick to one tool though, I would probably go with a SOG Powerlock or any of the Paladin models as you can remove the tools you don't need and install tools you do want. You can often trade the various tools here on the forum with other members, or just buy them outright from SOG, which runs usually about $6-10 per piece, so not a huge investment.
The only real drawback to SOG components is that things like saws and files are a bit stubby compared to other tools in the PowerLock class. This is because the tools are designed to be interchangeable with all other tools in the lineup, including the standard sized models like the Pocket Power Plier and ParaTool. Still, as an actual tradesman, you probably don't have dedicated tools too far away, so things like saws and files would be "functional enough" for your needs, and if you need something bigger, well you probably have access to that.
That's my $.02, but the great thing about tools is that there are a billion and two of them out there, so if shouldn't be too hard to find what you need! BTW, all of the tools I mentioned, except of course the Spirit, are made in the USA, in case that is an important factor to you, which I assume it is since you are in manufacturing!
Def
-
sorry welcome
so does the charge come with a clip
i thought it was a extra like on the wave . ive got a st300 and love it but big for edc, its drivers are very long so can squeeze into tight spaces, but for size and weight and versatility i think the wave is a great choice and if you have the extra cash the tti is next,You get a clip on lanyard and clip for the charge (although it has Leathermans hidden lanyard anyway...)
yeah the wave has the hidden lanyard hoop i use mine, plus i have the extra loop and i have a clip on my wave, i didnt know these came with the charge or was a aftermarket extra ,
Well according the bible (Leatherman's website) it has a pocket clip as standard but it may not be set in stone.
-
sorry welcome
so does the charge come with a clip
i thought it was a extra like on the wave . ive got a st300 and love it but big for edc, its drivers are very long so can squeeze into tight spaces, but for size and weight and versatility i think the wave is a great choice and if you have the extra cash the tti is next,You get a clip on lanyard and clip for the charge (although it has Leathermans hidden lanyard anyway...)
yeah the wave has the hidden lanyard hoop i use mine, plus i have the extra loop and i have a clip on my wave, i didnt know these came with the charge or was a aftermarket extra ,
Well according the bible (Leatherman's website) it has a pocket clip as standard but it may not be set in stone.
can imagine it comes with the charge as it does cost more so nice to have a few extras -
[quote author=Zed link=topic=26116.msg467826#msg467826 date=1298229142]
sorry welcome
so does the charge come with a clip
i thought it was a extra like on the wave . ive got a st300 and love it but big for edc, its drivers are very long so can squeeze into tight spaces, but for size and weight and versatility i think the wave is a great choice and if you have the extra cash the tti is next,You get a clip on lanyard and clip for the charge (although it has Leathermans hidden lanyard anyway...)
yeah the wave has the hidden lanyard hoop i use mine, plus i have the extra loop and i have a clip on my wave, i didnt know these came with the charge or was a aftermarket extra ,
Well according the bible (Leatherman's website) it has a pocket clip as standard but it may not be set in stone.
can imagine it comes with the charge as it does cost more so nice to have a few extras
[/quote]
£109 for mine but i'll take a fiver off for the bit kit and clip... -
Lots of great responses! Thank you.
Grant, I was hoping to simply purchase a tool that was already outfitted. I guess I should spend some time in the SOG forum and look into the possibility of customizing my own Power Assist. How do you feel about the compound lever action?
As far as cost, I will only spend as much as I need to be satisfied. Just like a car, house and any other purchase, I am always looking at price-point. $52 shipped for the ST300... Though I really like the Surge, no clip and it may be too big for EDC.
It's kind of addictive shopping for these and looking at all the options...
-
It is that. A good option may be to get an ST300 which is kinda of a good all rounder heavy duty tool, give it a bit of punishment then come back to the choice when you know what you really want. SOGs and LMs are sweet but the good stuff is always going to cost that bit extra. At $52 though I don't think its a big gamble. Most people end up liking the ST300.
-
Here's a secret that no one will tell you- Any of the above tools is going to do everything you need to do. Really. I mean that. If you are a mechanic or electrician you know full well that there are millions of fancy dedicated tools for everything you do, but the vast majority of the work you do is done by a half dozen regular tools that you reach for- maybe a set of pliers, a knife, a couple of flat heads and some kind of cutter. Basically, any decent brand name, and many non-brand name Home Depot/Wal Mart specials will do what you want and more. I always recommend the brand names though, even though they tend to cost more, since you can always be assured that a SOG, Leatherman, Victorinox etc are going to be good tools. When dealing in the cheapy range there are some good deals, but you really have to know what you are looking for to pick them out of the crap that's out there too. So, to be on the safe side, look for one of the big brands you see here, and you really can't go wrong.
Since any of them will do what you want, the real decision is based on options- for example, do you really need wire strippers, or can you make do with the slot in the cutters on the plier head and the knife? Do you want things like scissors or a file? What kind of money do you want to spend? Do you use any specialized bits that would require a bit driver, standard or otherwise? How would you prefer to carry it?
Frankly I don't think you can go wrong with any of the tools anyone mentioned, so really, find one that is pleasing to you aesthetically, and is in the price range you want to spend, and go for it. They will all have a lifetime warranty, and their customer service is pretty good, so you don't really have to worry about repairs or service, accessories etc.
As for SOG's compound leverage system, I am kind of torn on it. The gears trade distance for force, which means that while you may be putting twice as much pressure on the head as you are the handle, the handles have to move twice as far to do it. Bad news for folks (like me) with small hands. However, my father is almost 70 and refuses to slow down despite his hands not being as strong as they used to, and so the compound leverage allows him to do things that he wouldn't be able to do with other pliers. He loves the compound leverage even though his hands are a bit smaller than mine, because it's a more important tradeoff for him. Of course, since it also means the handles have to be opened wider to grip the same sized nut, it means he has to get a wrench more often than if he was carrying another tool.
All in all, it's a real feature with real function, not a gimmick at all, but I'm not completely sold on whether or not it's really a function that is right for everyone. If you have larger hands, the extra travel of the handles may not be an issue for you. If you have arthritis, it may be a lifesaver like it is for my father. If, like me you still have strong but small hands, you may prefer other tools instead, unless of course you tend to cut coat hangers a lot, in which case the compound leverage would come in handy!
I realize that may not help you much, but it's the best I can say. I can tell you what I prefer, and everyone here can tell you their preference, but without knowing everyone and their specific circumstances, that probably won't help you too much!
And, like your car analogy, some folks won't buy anything but Toyota, others prefer Ford, and others like Hondas, when in fact they are all just using them to drive to and from work, and to the mall on weekends! Same function, different personal choices.
Def
-
Thus spoke Zarathustra.
-
Grant, thanks for the thorough response. And yes, any substantial work will be done with proper tools.
I'm looking to carry the tool concealed with pocket clip. I've been spending more and more time in the board room and I don't want to intimidate someone or feel out of place with a big sheath stuck to my hip. Does that disqualify the ST300? I haven't seen a pocket clip for that.
Just personal taste, but I don't like the handle cover for the SOGs. Minor gripe, but I gotta decide somehow.
Surge vs. Charge . . .
Surge with extra bits, bit extender, pocket clip = $98
Charge(comes with clip), bits, extender = $114
-
Which Charge are you considering?
-
@electroman187 said:
Surge vs. Charge . . .....what a trouble.....i have both (mine is a charge tti)and fortunately for me is not a problem to carry the two togheter.....but if i'd make a choice under constriction,i'd choose the surge....
yes,it's bulky, but it's more versatile than the charge for tough jobs...better scissors, replacing blades, and the awl....i can't have my edc mt without an awl...(for this reason i modded my tti with an awl... :D)
i hope my thought helps you....
-
@electroman187 said:
Lots of great responses! Thank you.Grant, I was hoping to simply purchase a tool that was already outfitted. I guess I should spend some time in the SOG forum and look into the possibility of customizing my own Power Assist. How do you feel about the compound lever action?
As far as cost, I will only spend as much as I need to be satisfied. Just like a car, house and any other purchase, I am always looking at price-point. $52 shipped for the ST300... Though I really like the Surge, no clip and it may be too big for EDC.
It's kind of addictive shopping for these and looking at all the options...
Not if you have strong willpower, like me.

::) Welcome sir! :D
-
Just to keep your expectations reasonable , most plier heads are investment cast . They are no better than medium duty . I would get a Wave or Charge , and throw a small pair of Knipex needlenoses in the pocket . the ones I'm thinking of have three stripping notches and a crimping die , are small in size , and tuff as nails . Save the multi for general utility , specific applications aren't their strong suit .
Chris
-
@Styerman said:
Just to keep your expectations reasonable , most plier heads are investment cast . They are no better than medium duty . I would get a Wave or Charge , and throw a small pair of Knipex needlenoses in the pocket . the ones I'm thinking of have three stripping notches and a crimping die , are small in size , and tuff as nails . Save the multi for general utility , specific applications aren't their strong suit .Chris
And if you have the crimper on the dedicated pliers, then you don't need to get Charge for the crimper and you can get the far more affordable Wave.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
