Show your slip joint's thread!
-
Well, in the seller's defense, it's not such an easy knife to photograph! ;) I've used two different cameras here, so you will see white balance variation from one to the other.
1970 (10 dot) Case Barlow
All-around this knife is virtually like new. The knife as pictured is how I received it, except that I did clean up a bit of the discoloration on the blade spines and springs with a green scotchbrite pad. There are no cracks at all in the bone scales. The walk and talk is excellent, but there is some lateral play in the main blade. I have to say that I'm a bit surprised by how thin the blade stock is. I've always viewed these barlows as workhorses, but it's not as heavy duty as I imagined.
-
Canal Street Cutlery Three Blade Cannitler, Amber Stag Carved Bone (1 of 400)
-
Nice shots there on what looks to be some fine cutlery!

-
That's a beautiful pocket knife.

-
NutSAK,
Very nice bud. That Barlow is pretty clean. And they are workhorses. Been a staple for a very long time, one the most long lasting and enduring slipjoint patterns in American Cutlery. For a pocketknife it don't need heavy blade stock to do it's job for a very long time.
Despite the white balance your pics came out real good. I have similar problems taking pics of my knives, or at least use to. I try to only take pics of my stuff under natural light. No matter how many options and doo-hickeys my camera may have I just can never really get good pics under incan or florescent lighting. I gotta have daylight or they come out looking like crap.
So, what do you think of that CSC? It looks real good, and I love that bone. How's the backsprings on that? And BTW, did that one come with the dual-finished blades.....polished on the mark side and satin on the pile side?
2xTap
-
wasnt the barlow originaly made in Sheffield England and is a pretty old desingn as im sure i had one back in the early 80's , i had a few sheffields back then but i remember one in this shape,

paul
-
Zed,
There have been many claims as to who created the pattern and who first produced it. Both over in England and here in the States. It is likely it was originally a Sheffield design, but no one knows for sure. The earliest mentions are of a man named Obadiah Barlow of Sheffield England having been the inventor of the Barlow Knife in late 1600's.
2xTap
-
There have been many claims as to who created the pattern and who first produced it. Both over in England and here in the States. It is likely it was originally a Sheffield design, but no one knows for sure. The earliest mentions are of a man named Obadiah Barlow of Sheffield England having been the inventor of the Barlow Knife in late 1600's.
2xTap
thanks for the info mate, i guess he didnt have a patent for it
:D -
@2xTap said:
Very nice bud. That Barlow is pretty clean. And they are workhorses. Been a staple for a very long time, one the most long lasting and enduring slipjoint patterns in American Cutlery. For a pocketknife it don't need heavy blade stock to do it's job for a very long time.Very true, and with the thin stock and CV blades, it should be one heck of a slicer!

@2xTap said:
Despite the white balance your pics came out real good. I have similar problems taking pics of my knives, or at least use to. I try to only take pics of my stuff under natural light. No matter how many options and doo-hickeys my camera may have I just can never really get good pics under incan or florescent lighting. I gotta have daylight or they come out looking like crap.Thanks. I usually try my best to use natural light too, but I haven't been around much lately, unfortunately. It's been cloudy and I've been working long hours. There's really no substitute for natural light, especially if it's dispersed and not glaring, such as early or late in the day. These shots were taken under warm CFC can lights that have a similar temperature to incan. It would have helped to have something to soften the light a bit--I had to work really hard at getting the right angles for glare reduction.
@2xTap said:
So, what do you think of that CSC? It looks real good, and I love that bone. How's the backsprings on that? And BTW, did that one come with the dual-finished blades.....polished on the mark side and satin on the pile side?The Canal St. Cannitler is pretty unique. While it's a canoe pattern, there are a few things that set it apart, the most important in my opinion is the variation of blade width. The main blade is FAT--three times thicker at the tang than the pen and sheepsfoot (coping) blade. The main blade tang rides on both backsprings. The thin secondary blades were important to me, as I wanted the small blades to have a bit more control and finesse. I do wonder at this point how good of a slicer the main blade will be, but it really isn't much thicker than a Victorinox Pioneer/Soldier main blade past the tang so it should be just fine.
The fit and finish are spot on. The dye is striking in person and carving in the bone is excellent, with smooth blends into the bolsters. The pins and shield are well set so there are no protrusions. The liners and backsprings are snug and well finished with just a hairline space on one of the liners. The secondary blades are fairly "flexy" since they're thin, and that combined with the sheepsfoot having slight lateral play means there will be some rub on the main blade. That doesn't bother me, as this will be a user and I think it's to be expected with a pattern as compact as this. All blades had very good, even, bevel grinds out of the box, so it didn't take much time to bring them to shaving sharpness even with the D2 steel.
I did have some concern about the backspring on the main blade, as this is where the main complaint of this knife seems to be. Rest assured, the spring is not lazy or weak. True, it doesn't close like a bear trap, but it snaps open with authority. To me the snap feels just like a Victorinox Farmer, and I've been living with that level of spring tension for years with no issues, so it's good enough for me. The snap on the smaller blades is firmer on closing.
All in all I'm very pleased with it. It offers a lot of utility and very good ergonomics in a compact frame.
I think the only things that might improve it for me is some swell in the scales to round the grip out, and possibly a half stop on the main blade. Oh and BTW--the paperwork says "polished mark side" but, on my knife, mark and pile sides are equally polished to a sheen similar to a SAK. I've read that D2 can't be mirror-polished easily, and that's fine with me because I prefer a satin or brushed finish. -
NutSAK,
Yeah, I have a hell of a time with glare as well. My new camera does a pretty good job of auto-correcting this but it then makes the pics come out a bit darker than they actually are. I really got to work around my camera placement to get my shots just right. And this usually entails hovering the camera almost directly over the knife........hence why my pics have alot of "reflecto" in them!
Sounds as though you have a winner in that CSC. I should be getting me one but my money just keeps going to other things. Anyway, looks like it's got the build it should have, and it is a damn good looking piece. Are you making this one a user?
I know CSC has done some runs of their slippies with blades polished all the way around but their standard set-up is the old style of polished on the mark and satin on the pile. Wasn't sure if this run was done that way or not.
Yeah, D2 Tool Steel is a weird one. I've been in many discussions over the years about this. D2 can take a mirror polish but it doesn't go full. D2 always takes on a faint orange peel affect to the surface of the steel when polished. I have a Queen-built piece or two with polished D2, and looking at your reflection in these blades there is always a real slight haze to it. On real close inspection you can see this OP affect. It's just the nature of this steel.
Glad you got a good one and are enjoying it. It's a classic pattern of true American origin.

2xTap
-
@2xTap said:
Sounds as though you have a winner in that CSC. I should be getting me one but my money just keeps going to other things. Anyway, looks like it's got the build it should have, and it is a damn good looking piece. Are you making this one a user?You bet! It's in my pocket at the moment and I don't see it going anywhere for a while. You really do need one of these
, and there's a nice run of 50 in smooth buffalo horn available at a good price. PM me on that if you're interested. Hell, if I talk you into it I'll feel like I'm just returning the favor! ;) :D@2xTap said:
Yeah, D2 Tool Steel is a weird one. I've been in many discussions over the years about this. D2 can take a mirror polish but it doesn't go full. D2 always takes on a faint orange peel affect to the surface of the steel when polished. I have a Queen-built piece or two with polished D2, and looking at your reflection in these blades there is always a real slight haze to it. On real close inspection you can see this OP affect. It's just the nature of this steel.A light orange peel is exactly what I would call the finish on this one, both sides. It has a more polished finish than the brushed, satin finish on my Queen trapper (dogleg) jack.
One thing I failed to mention in the comments is that, though the "Cannitler" is a whittler canoe, I wouldn't want to use this as a whittler very often. The way the main blade protrudes from the frame when it is closed would make for an uncomfortable grip after using the small blades for a duration of time. I bought the knife because I like pen and sheepsfoot blades as an option but I would buy a true whittler if that's what my aim was.
-
NutSAK,
Cool, should make for a excellent EDC piece. After a while of using it give us a update sometime on your thoughts of it as a carry piece.
In Smooth Buffalo Horn you say.....one of my favorite handle materials. I would likely be all over that except I just recently got offered first dibs on a collection that is being sold and I got a few hundred dollars worth of knives that is going to be heading my way. A Case Classic, several Robesons, and a couple Schatt & Morgans. My knife fundage is tapped for about the next month or so! :(
2xTap
-
You're a lucky man 2xTap!
can't wait for all the pics! ;) -
These two arrived, a 6 blade Colt stockman, as suggested by 2x, with surprisingly deep stag scales, shown with its twin brother and a Chinese kissing crane “toothpick”, which looks like the product of a marriage between a peanut and a toothpick, shown with two suspiciously similar Buck toothpicks.
The Colt stockman is quite nice and has a deep, greyish stag scales. The blades work well and there are no problems with the springs, like there were with the equivalent RR. It comes in a nice display box.
The Kissing Crane, with a main blade similar to the Bucks but with a different grind, has a good finish; not as good as the Bucks, or RR, but a lot better than some Italian made Kissing Crane sodbusters I got. The blades are sharp and well centred but there are some rough edges on the bottom side and on the bolt heads.


.jpg)
-
there great DKS

i just ordered my first rough rider,

-
You will not be dissapointed.

The scales on yours look like they were made from the same material as the yellow buck toothpick I have.
-
@dks said:
You will not be dissapointed.
The scales on yours look like they were made from the same material as the yellow buck toothpick I have.
cheers mate, ive read a lot of good things on here about RR's and for the price they seem like something even i could collect, yes i said collect and not use :D although as ive been carrying the buck 303 all week i see me carrying this alot as well

-
dks, that Colt stockman is a dandy! It looks great with the dimpled & lined bolsters, and you got a fine example of stag scales there.
-
Yes, I was pleasantly surprised with the stag on the Colt, I expected a much flatter looking stag, for the price and was quite suspicious of buying a knife with a gun brand name.
Zed,
There have been stories of people skinning deer with a RR slipjoint so I think they can be used quite safely. I, too, tend to buy because I like, rather than need.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login