Show your slip joint's thread!
-
part 1, what I got that was reasonably OK
-
part 2, The problems...
A crack, scales falling off (steel warrior), off centre blade, bolt sticking out, flaking Buck Creek, soft, flaky stag buck creek.
As I said, I am in contact with the seller and he is more than happy to replace any of them... I am trying to see if postage cost will be covered.
The stag on the buck creek is very similar to some stag I got on some, much cheaper, schrade deerslayers, i.e. not the most brilliant quality.
I have had problems with scales on buck and RR before so I know these occur with other, good quality, slipjoints.
For me, the Buck Creek are reasonably expensive knives (luxury items where looks and finish are very important) so I expect a much better level of finish than with the chinese made knives. I think Buck Creek and to the extend that I know, German Bulldog knives are not of the most brilliant quality, they seem to be below, similarly priced Case knives, from my limited experience...Zed, I still cant see the pictures...
-
@dks said:
part 2, The problems...A crack, scales falling off (steel warrior), off centre blade, bolt sticking out, flaking Buck Creek, soft, flaky stag buck creek.
As I said, I am in contact with the seller and he is more than happy to replace any of them... I am trying to see if postage cost will be covered.
The stag on the buck creek is very similar to some stag I got on some, much cheaper, schrade deerslayers, i.e. not the most brilliant quality.
I have had problems with scales on buck and RR before so I know these occur with other, good quality, slipjoints.
For me, the Buck Creek are reasonably expensive knives (luxury items where looks and finish are very important) so I expect a much better level of finish than with the chinese made knives. I think Buck Creek and to the extend that I know, German Bulldog knives are not of the most brilliant quality, they seem to be below, similarly priced Case knives, from my limited experience...Zed, I still cant see the pictures...
what pics ? :D
-
I am reading the text on the screen and looking at the pictures on the mobile.... :D
What do you think of the stag, especially the bottom of the dirtbuster? Should I complain? I am still not happy with the "look" of them, so I will definitely exchange the trapper, whatever.
-
OK, on the same topic :> Schrade, I am sure one day all these will be appreciated more and worth a looooot of money!

These were bought because they were interesting, colourwise, and I did not at the time have any of the brand.
The deerslayers are OK, supposed to be handmade..., but still not as good as the RR ones. They are my retirement investment..

The stag scales are not totally aligned with the liners, you can feel the liner sticking out, but the rest are better, though you have the odd bolt sticking a bit too high.
The small trapper and the large stockman are not bad, a bit of blade play but useable.
The red peanut(?) and the sodbuster (like a Jr Case but a quarter of the price) have a very rough opening feel, they have not been finished properly. I have filed them down a bit and improved the movement but they really need to be taken apart and sorted.
The large stockman and the small peanut have quite interesting scales, very colourful, and I just had to have a yellow sodbuster, but did not want to buy another case (cost).
-
some lovely stuff there mate, love the red handled P-nut, you have a lot of slip joints dks
i like the schrade custom series i have, its fit n fitting is all good and has very sharp bldes, i know as cut my finger last night at work lol, nice looking knife as well, -
Its an investment....
-
dks,
The Stag on that Steel Warrior is just plain screwed all to hell, that is just horrible. Definitely that one has to go. Can't see anything wrong with the Dirtbuster, might be missing something.
Anyway, if you are unhappy with any of them for any reason, if you can, I say return them. Don't go about with things you don't want. Be happy with what you spend your money on.
2xTap
-
Alrighty, just got a slew of new ones myself. Well, new to me anyway. All of these are Queen-built Robesons. Production of these was around 2004, short run and long discontinued SFO material.
Robeson Rootbeer Bone Improved Muskrat:


Robeson Caramel Wormgroove Bone Improved Muskrat:


Robeson Antique Green Bone Improved Muskrat:


Robeson Raspberry Bone Improved Muskrat:


These are all 4" in the closed position and built on a slight serpentine style frame. The only real difference between them all is that the Rootbeer Bone and Caramel Wormgroove versions have rounded bolsters and the Antique Green and Raspberry Bone versions have squared bolsters.
These are single backspring Muskrats and all feature the same build......nickle/silver bolsters and shield, brass liners and pins, 420HC Stainless blades, Shuredge blade etch and tang stamp, and all have a virtually impeccable level of Fit and Finish. The only real fault I can find in any of them is on the Caramel Wormgroove Bone one. It's backspring is noticably lighter than on the other three. Not weak, but the others are rather stout and this one is just easier. Also the main Clip Point blade on this one has a ever so slight lateral play in it. Outside of that can't find a fault.
Been a while now since I have been able to add any new Robesons to my collection as they are made in low numbers and in a "on again/off again" fashion, and they only show up here and there. Glad I got the opportunity on these, and at the price I got them for which was just sweet!

2xTap
-
I'm not a fan of typical muskrats, but I do like these "improved" patterns with with the Wharncliffe. That rootbeer is beautiful! It's my favorite of all the frames too, serpentine with the rounded bolsters.

-
NutSAK,
I've never been one for the typical Muskrats either, that was until I got that Stag one from GEC. I do prefer the blade set-up of the Improved versions, they are like the old Hawbaker Specials that CSC is currently making now. And GEC has a version in their Furtaker line which now has me very interested.
But with these, for me, it was more that they are Robesons than anything else.
2xTap
-
2xtap, these look really nice, I am beginning to appreciate, good, jigged bone more lately!
The caramel and the improved are very unusual and interesting.Thanks for sharing.
Maybe I need to save some money and get something really well made, cut my losses.
Though I can still not see the main pictures on the screen, I can now click on the thumbnail, below the picture, and see them on image shack
Thanks.Oh, I am sending the Steel warrior and the trapper back, keeping the rest.
-

I like the way they've patterned the scales on this one. Very fishy :)
-
@2xTap said:
I do prefer the blade set-up of the Improved versions, they are like the old Hawbaker Specials that CSC is currently making now. And GEC has a version in their Furtaker line which now has me very interested.I sure wish you hadn't mentioned the CSC.... ::) Luckily it appears to be a bit out of my price range.
I'm impressed with the many different patterns that GEC offers, but I find it strange that they have a muskrat and a trapper both in the Furtaker line with the same clip/wharnie combo. Also, I think true muskrats should have a single spring, not two, just like a true whittler should have two, not three. That's just me, I suppose. ;)
I damn near bought that green Tidioute Furtaker Trapper Mike had in the "EDC" section, but someone else got to it before I made up my mind. :-[ Oh well, another knife I didn't need! :D I bought that red Humpback CV "whittler" instead.
Terry
-
@dks said:
Though I can still not see the main pictures on the screen, I can now click on the thumbnail, below the picture, and see them on image shack
Thanks.dks,
I am thinking it has something to do with your computers settings, you can see my thumbnails but not the fullsize hotlinked pics. Something is blocking them. But I can't really answer as to what, for I am somewhat PC-impaired.
2xTap
-
@NutSAK said:
I sure wish you hadn't mentioned the CSC.... ::) Luckily it appears to be a bit out of my price range.I'm impressed with the many different patterns that GEC offers, but I find it strange that they have a muskrat and a trapper both in the Furtaker line with the same clip/wharnie combo. Also, I think true muskrats should have a single spring, not two, just like a true whittler should have two, not three. That's just me, I suppose. ;)
I damn near bought that green Tidioute Furtaker Trapper Mike had in the "EDC" section, but someone else got to it before I made up my mind. :-[ Oh well, another knife I didn't need! :D I bought that red Humpback CV "whittler" instead.
Terry
Yeah, the CSC Hawbakers are somewhat overpriced. And considering for the same money you can get a Furtaker from GEC that's alot more knife with a superior build.
Not sure why you find it weird that two different patterns would have the same blades, is quite common actually. You can find Jacks, Barlows, and Gunstocks with the same blades. Standard Trappers and Moose patterns with the same blades.
Too bad you missed out on that particular Furtaker. They are sweet knives. If you ever get the hankering for one again...........


.......I highly recommend getting one. ;)
The only way you can get a slipjoint built better is going custom!

2xTap
-
@2xTap said:
Not sure why you find it weird that two different patterns would have the same blades, is quite common actually. You can find Jacks, Barlows, and Gunstocks with the same blades. Standard Trappers and Moose patterns with the same blades.Hmm... yeah, good point. Hell, I'm not sure why I think half of the things I do! :D
-
Not sure why you find it weird that two different patterns would have the same blades, is quite common actually. You can find Jacks, Barlows, and Gunstocks with the same blades. Standard Trappers and Moose patterns with the same blades.
Hmm... yeah, good point. Hell, I'm not sure why I think half of the things I do! :D
Senility perhaps! ;)
They say as you get older the first thing to go is the mind. And I should know, I'm only about a year older than you and I have lost most of mine already!

2xTap
-
Not sure why you find it weird that two different patterns would have the same blades, is quite common actually. You can find Jacks, Barlows, and Gunstocks with the same blades. Standard Trappers and Moose patterns with the same blades.
Hmm... yeah, good point. Hell, I'm not sure why I think half of the things I do! :D
Senility perhaps! ;)
They say as you get older the first thing to go is the mind. And I should know, I'm only about a year older than you and I have lost most of mine already!

2xTap
You're only 4 months older, actually, so we're probably in about the same boat, except that I'm considerably more slippy poor... ;)
I still look damn good though, and that's what matters! :D At least that's what my wife tells me, and surely she wouldn't lie... ???
Terry
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







