Small knife rust resistance experiment
-
What an eye opener! :o
Great experiment.

-
Does the term 'stone washed' apply here? :D
-
so a few more up closer pic's. Not the best sorry, bad low lighting...anyway:


Interesting to note, the former fresh bade suffered most where the line was tied to it(but the other blade didnt). The former salt blade got a slightly raised area where it was rusting in the very first week of the experiment, but didnt get worse, whilst part of the cutting edge really suffered.
Both still cut fairly well!
Ill see how well I can clean them up over the next week. -
Its fantastic to know that SAKs can stand up to so much. Those blades are going no where in a hurry.
-
This has been the best blade/corrosion test ever. :)
-
Very nice test.
-
I'm no science major... But wouldn't the movement of water (tide) hinder the formation of rust on the surface of the blade? (I could be way wrong...)
-
I'm no science major... But wouldn't the movement of water (tide) hinder the formation of rust on the surface of the blade? (I could be way wrong...)
Rust needs air, as well as salt and water, so putting it in the tide is necessary to give it all three magic ingredients.
-
So for the grand finale, how did they clean up...
(again, sorry for quality, pics taken late at night under lamp)


So not bad overall, but the once invincible 'fresh' blade really didnt like that line being tied around its pivot, and the other blade never fully recovered from the rust at the tip.

Considering how little the 'fresh' blade rusted until late in the play, its quite disturbing how bad that pivot rust got. I dont think it backs up it being because its a high wear/friction zone however, since as mentioned the steel is the same throughout, its not coated + the other pivot was fine. Also, largely neither blade got much rust on the sharp edge which is wear point. Having the line on it without a doubt acted as a cover of sorts, perhaps keeping the salt content constantly on the blade throughout the tide cycles. The soak test at home didnt affect that blade, but did the other to a larger degree than its time in the ocean...
So a salute to these two little blades, they have come away scared, but not dead! 
-
thank you for posting the experiment! 
-
@HawkeyX said:
I chose a place you can only access at low tide, but who knows, a scavenger may find them and take them.

So...its either an update next week, or...Hey Hawkey,
Some one posted a link to this thread in a more recent post - So I enjoyed reading about your very interesting experiment. Nice one - Well done.
I think the next test would be to leave them in the sea for six months - then to see what happends!!I worked in Auckland for a few months last year - and it was very nice to see Rangitoto framing the background of your experimental site :)
For anyone reading this thread who does not know Auckland Bay - Rangitoto is the flat, conical (is that a contradiction) island in the background of the shot.
And yes it is volcanic - And what is really interesting is - If Hawkey had taken this shot 600 years ago the island would not have been there!!
:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login