Skeletool durability
-
Hi all,
The Skeletool has been very highly recommended by many of the members here, and I have been considering one. However, I have some doubts about the durability of the tool. In my research, I have read literally dozens of reports of the pliers failing, even on CX models. While I realize this is probably only a small percentage of the total units produced, it does concern me. I don't want to end up in a situation where I am relying on the tool and have it fail. I know it's not meant as a heavy duty tool, and I wouldn't be using in such fashion; mostly for any required roadside repairs on my bicycle during commuting and some occasional recreational riding. However, I am still concerned about plunking down anywhere from $70 - $90 for a CX (the range of prices I've seen) for a tool that's supposedly a top of the line tool only to have it fail.
Can anyone shed any light on this for me? Has anyone had any issues with this tool or any failures? I'd like to get a CX for EDC use because I bike a lot and I hate combo blades. I also EDC a few other things as well so the minimalist tool selection of the Skeletool would be okay for me.
Any experiences or thoughts on this tool will be appreciated.
-
I have used the Skeletool for several years and never had any issues with teh pliers. I too have seen reports of it braking. I use mine hard almost every day and never an issue.
-
I've used mine a number of times harder than I should have. No issues with the pliers at all (screwdriver bit spring broke, but that's it).
-
Used mine a lot too with no Pliers issues. The horrendous blade play problem on the other hand has made me stop carrying the thing.
-
I abuse my tools. :o
There, I've said it. :(
If it's in my pocket, it is liable to be used as a prybar, get hammered on or have something put on the handle to increase the torque. ::)
I have sent back my Skeletool once. After I twisted the jaws when I used them to twist off a faucet head from a pipe. They still worked, but the jaws weren't lined up.
I am highly confident in the quality of the Skeletool pliers.
-
The CX was my edc multi since 2008, I stopped carrying it a few months back in favor of the Juice (couse of the scissors). I've never had any problems with the pliers, and I didn't baby it. Nor with any other tools on it. The black does show signs of wear, but that's about it.
@thebullfrog, what kind of bladeplay? Up and down, sideways? Did you try tightening the pivot screw?
-
But one must allways remember with the skeletool series. It was never meant to hack an airfield out of the jungle. It's light EDC use(but it could be used in a survival situation if push comes to shove). Remembering that will keep you from abusing your lttle friend!!

-
The skeletools pliers have been redesigned since their introduction.
I have two CXs; one which i bought as soon as it became available (combo blade), the second i bought just the other month (plain blade), there is a subtle difference in the depth and shape of the plier "weight saving" cutouts which was done to increase the strength of the pliers after the many failures of the originals.........i assume. It might be worth looking at some of the failure pictures to determine which iteration of the plier design failed.
One way to spot the difference is that the two longest cutout slots on the jaw face are the same length on the new type but different lengths on the older jaws. That in not the only difference however.The picture shows the older style of plier

-
It sounds like they've corrected the problem. I think I'll get one in a while then.
-
If you have the extra cash,go for the PE CX,just love that 154cm PE blade.

-
@enki_ck said:
@thebullfrog, what kind of bladeplay? Up and down, sideways? Did you try tightening the pivot screw?Both directions actually. I can tighten the pivot so hard that the blade literally will not move without using two hands, and it still has side to side play. One of these days it'll go back to LM, but I've never gotten around to it. Great tool otherwise.
-
I have a buddy who beats the crap outta his , my former apprentice has one in his tool bag - he's not exactly gentle . They gotta be reasonably tuff . I had the screwdriver bit holder jam on mine . I believe the bitholders have also been tweeked .
I'm quite fond of the Skele and the Freestyle . Their big Bro., the MUT is very tuff . Good DNA all around .
Chris
-
It looks like Ill be the odd one here.
I purchased a CX about last november. The newer one with the PE 154cm blade.
Now, dont get me wrong, I love the tool. Its very nice, and easy to carry. I especially like it because I am usually only carrying a folding knife when I walk out of the house because I kind of got tired of carrying a plier-based tool (which I am going to start doing again tomorrow, thanks to me coming back here today). The Skeletool is very easy to carry in lieu of a folding knife.
My one gripe about it may be questionable durability. For work, I repair small equipment. One time, shortly after I got it (even though my toolbox is sitting right there) I wanted to test the tool out a little bit. So, my first job of the day was to service an edger. While assembling the Edger, I think I was trying to install a pin, then bend the ends of the pin at the bottom so that it couldnt come out.
The tool kinda disappointed me there because I felt the plier head start to twist and stopped before I broke the tool. I wouldnt have called it abuse, but maybe the pin was too large to be using a Skeletool on.
The other small thing that happened that wasnt really that big of a deal to me was I was using the skeletool to help install a nut. Somehow, the pliers slipped off of the nut and the cast pliers deformed a little bit at the tip.
Not a huge deal to us all. But something that I have had to watch out for.
The Skeletool did great at cutting up a wire coat hanger though. Very impressed there.
-
I'm really torn on getting a new EDC tool... I currently have an Octane, a Suspension, and a Style CS.
I've been wanting a new EDC tool that isn't too bulky or heavy, has a pocket clip, doesn't have a lot of redundancy in its tools, but still has a good selection of tools.
I've been mulling an S2, but the lack of a pocket clip and the fact it has too many flatheads in it are turn-offs for me.
I like the Skeletool CX because of its PE blade and pocket clip, but I wish it also had scissors and a file... :(
I'm thinking maybe I'll just get a Style PS and tear it and my CS down to make one with pliers, scissors, and a blade. I never really use the file, so maybe I might have to go modding to make the perfect pocket tool for me.
Ah, who am I kidding? Then I'll just want something bigger... or with a different tool compliment, and so on. God, this is a sickness, isn't it?
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
I'm really torn on getting a new EDC tool... I currently have an Octane, a Suspension, and a Style CS.I've been wanting a new EDC tool that isn't too bulky or heavy, has a pocket clip, doesn't have a lot of redundancy in its tools, but still has a good selection of tools.
I've been mulling an S2, but the lack of a pocket clip and the fact it has too many flatheads in it are turn-offs for me.
I like the Skeletool CX because of its PE blade and pocket clip, but I wish it also had scissors and a file... :(
I'm thinking maybe I'll just get a Style PS and tear it and my CS down to make one with pliers, scissors, and a blade. I never really use the file, so maybe I might have to go modding to make the perfect pocket tool for me.
Ah, who am I kidding? Then I'll just want something bigger... or with a different tool compliment, and so on. God, this is a sickness, isn't it?

-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Ah, who am I kidding? Then I'll just want something bigger... or with a different tool compliment, and so on. God, this is a sickness, isn't it?Sickness? Not at all.
If you like the S2 you could put an adhesive clip on the scales, something like a Nite-Ize Eclipse adhesive clip.
-
Amici,
I once feared the durability of the Skeletool, but after a few years using one for EDC, still no issues, and this has been through the ringer.. With everything, there's always a bad apple in every bunch..Cheers,
Serge -
@sergemaster said:
Amici,
I once feared the durability of the Skeletool, but after a few years using one for EDC, still no issues, and this has been through the ringer.. With everything, there's always a bad apple in every bunch..Cheers,
SergeThe original Skeletool plier head design <u>was</u> kind of prone to breakage. As such, there are quite a number of pictures of broken Skeletool pliers floating around (I broke one myself).
However, I'm pretty sure the problem was fixed by Leatherman. Not so much an issue of "bad apple", just a design flaw.
-
I too have a skeletool, regular one with serrated blade, so far no issues whatsoever. I must say, however that the head is not for heavy duty applications. I had once used it to straight a copper lengt of about 4-5mm thickness and I had to finish the job with a swissgrip (what a tool!!), as I was twisting the SK´s head under the preassure. That said, I am also aware of the first batch of flawed SK´s, having read various english, spanish and dutch forums, as well as hearing comments of ppl I do talk too offline about MT´s in general.
then again, if you need heavy duty you go ST300 and that is hardly EDC.
-
[quote author=El Rago link=topic=29223.msg502895#msg502895 date=1311154322
then again, if you need heavy duty you go ST300 and that is hardly EDC.
[/quote]I beg to differ!
Been carrying a Core everyday, just switching to at ST300 this week. Just need a heavy duty belt :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login