Tool perception - have we got it wrong?
-
Just a little inane ramble of a tired mind ….
Last night I got thinking about thinking. Do we over think our tool choices? Are some tools REALLY as good as we think in comparison to other manufacturers/models? Are others REALLY as bad as we perceive them to be?
This started when I got my Juice KF4 and Vic Timekeeper yesterday. I eagerly opened them up and realised afterwards I had looked them over more with the mindset of a tool critic rather than just being happy I had got a new thing (or two) and wondering how well they will be in my daily activities. "The handles pinch a little, but then it’s an older model with heads stamped USA, 2001 date codes blah blah blah". I dug out my (much chastised) CS4 as a comparison, and found that all of a sudden I didn’t hate it quite as much as I had before.
The CS4 was a massive disappointment for me when I got it, but mainly due to what I got in comparison to the money spent rather than just the tool alone. The cost element has now depleted as it’s a while since I got it, and what remains is a tool which is …. well it’s alright I suppose. Not the greatest engineering triumph known to man, but is it REALLY as bad as I thought back then? I’d have probably been very happy with it indeed if it only cost me £25, but it cost much more and that’s probably where most of the venom came from.I then started thinking about the tool which started me off down this line, a Gerber Suspension, my first ever pliers based multitool. I thought it was pretty poor even though I had nothing to compare it with back then, and knew very little about other tools. That said, there were a few times when I needed “something” to do a task and the Suspension was the only thing to hand. Needless to say the task was completed, the world didn’t fall off its axis and all my fingers and toes were still attached. I decided I would try to go for a while, maybe even a month or so, with my CS4 to see whether I can get past my initial views and see how it fares when it’s all I’ve got (Although in fairness I will probably still have my Swisstool in my bag if things go squiffy)
Generally speaking I am biased towards certain tools and manufacturers and biased against others. I am also convinced that I am not alone with this. How many guys prefer Leatherman because of their own mindset rather than the tools itself? Quite a few I’d guess. Hype, branding, group psychology, patriotism? This was why I have a tendency to be overly critical of LM, because to me they have prove themselves more to overcome my aversion to “hype” (probably the wrong word, but it’ll do for now). Then again I’m generally biased towards Victorinox in much the same way, and find it hard to view any of their tools badly in comparison with other designs or manufacturers. Hypocritical - nah, just honest :D :P
Anyone else brave enough to say their tool choices could be done with a more open mind? Sometimes it’s not easy to be open minded, prejudice is a natural survival instinct we all carry otherwise our species would be long gone. I’m pretty sure I don’t need my survival instincts taking over if I’m choosing what MT I’m putting in my pocket in a morning though. They sure make things much easier than bashing stuff with rocks tied on sticks.
BTW … I really like the Vic Timekeeper … and the KF4 too
:D :D :D
-
Ive been in this same thought Al, ive tried most MT's and many SAK's. for me personaly a pocket knife has served me well over the years , i never use a tin/bottle opener but a sharp blade has come in handy lots of times, my wave has been a very handy companion n many camping trips and on sites over the years so a keeper as far as im concerned, we all have our favourites on here and its nice to try out many of them when possible but i know what works for me and these days i generally stick to them, ive pretty much gone fall circle now and happy with what i have for my general EDC ;)
-
An interesting topic to be sure.
I can honestly say, I have tried most MTs out there. I have even EDCed a good variety during my holidays to know what I like and what I don't like. I am governed above all by a good streak of practicality however, and thus, I am relegated to the Leatherman Knifeless Fuse due to work restrictions for 10 months out of the year. The other two months does leave me with some experimenting, and of course weekends as well.
I can also say I am not prejudiced in any way shape or form when it comes down to multi-tools. I enjoy well made, well engineered tools. I dislike the opposite. This means I will go to bat for even the cheap Chinese items that meet those criteria, even taking into consideration the retail price for what you get. I am no tool snob.
I suppose I am blessed. I know I can only wear knifeless items at work, so I don't worry about the rest. Heaven knows I have a good tool selection to choose from, but due to work restrictions, I don't worry about tool selection because I can't wear most of it anyways. Makes life simple...which is something I enjoy very much. :D
-
I definitely have my biases, and my tool ownership reflects that. I buy mostly Leatherman tools because I like them best. However, I recognize that this is as much (or more) aesthetics as function; my first MT was a PST. I have friends who EDC'd Gerber tools in the mid-90's, and they are still strident Gerber fans today, even though they may not have purchased a MT in 15 years and have no idea what is available today. I have a couple Gerbers (love my MP600), and a couple SOGs (compound leverage and a killer leather sheath), and someday I want a SwissTool (or 3). But I will always focus on LM the most.
-
This topic touches on a realization that I had a couple weeks ago.
I have never liked SAK's for no good reason. I have never owned one or even carried one. But, when I look at them, something inside me says "Not for me".
On the other hand I am a big fan of Leathermans. My first was a Juice S2 and I've like the Leatherman products ever since.
There are a lot of forum members here that are passionate about their SAK's so Victorinox and Wenger must be doing something right, but I didn't feel good about them and I couldn't put my finger the the source of my prejudice against SAK's.
I started thinking about the first knives that I had as a kid. My favorite was a Camillus Cub Scout knife. It had a stout carbon main blade and was hefty. The disappointing knives that I had back then were cheaply built, had highly polished blades and were light in weight. The light went on above my head and I realized that my impression of SAK's was misplaced. While SAK's and the disappointing knives of my youth both have highly polished blades and were light weight, but the similarities end there.
Recently I found a Victorinox Adventurer at a local store mis-marked at $12.95. That particular model isn't appropriate for my EDC needs, but at that price it couldn't be passed up. I grabbed it up and have been pleased with the quality of the knife.
I will still carry my trusty Juice, but SAK's offer one advantage over the LM's. The scales are easily changed. I'm working on a set of maple scales for the Adventurer now. After I get the process figured out, I'll move on to more attractive wood and more SAK's.
-
@Chako said:
... Heaven knows I have a good tool selection to choose from...Heaven's not the only one that knows you have a good tool selection... we've all seen the pictures. :D :D
From my perspective, sometimes it is most definitely the deal I got which makes the tool seem more favorable.
It's been much more difficult for me to get a good deal on Leatherman stuff because brand name wise, they pretty much dominate the market. Not to say that it isn't justified in that Leatherman does a very good job of advertising and backing up their warranty.
I haven't had to test out Vic's warranty, but then maybe that says something about Vic products. I have gotten quite a few good deals on Vics and even though I have found other items to EDC, sometimes I go back to the good deals because it gives me a warm feeling inside. ;)
-
@MeadMaker said:
I have never liked SAK's for no good reason. I have never owned one or even carried one. But, when I look at them, something inside me says "Not for me".I was like that for years. I just thought they were a bit naff and gimicky - I found it hard to take them seriously - again without ever trying one. It wasn't that long ago when I bought a vic tourist as my first SAK and realised how wrong I was ... there's been a few (ok, maybe slightly more than a few :P ) added since then. :D
@Chako said:
An interesting topic to be sure.I can honestly say, I have tried most MTs out there .... Heaven knows I have a good tool selection to choose from ...
I'll certainly not argue you are one of the more eclectic ones mate :D So how many of your tools go on test drives? Interesting to see you've chosen (or had chosen for you :-\ ) a knifeless fuse from your myriad of options ... I had wondered for a while how you'd go about chosing what to carry from your assortment. Looks like your job has saved you about 2 hours every morning and a fortune in headache pills :P

But if you're choices weren't limited .... ???

(definitely with you on the well made cheapies BTW
)@airballrad said:
I definitely have my biases, and my tool ownership reflects that. I buy mostly Leatherman tools because I like them best. However, I recognize that this is as much (or more) aesthetics as function; my first MT was a PST. I have friends who EDC'd Gerber tools in the mid-90's, and they are still strident Gerber fans today, even though they may not have purchased a MT in 15 years and have no idea what is available today. I have a couple Gerbers (love my MP600), and a couple SOGs (compound leverage and a killer leather sheath), and someday I want a SwissTool (or 3). But I will always focus on LM the most.I will say this for LM, they certainly make sure they give you plenty of options. I also have more LM's than any other maker (not counting SAK's) at the mo, purely down to me exploring different options (although I the number may drop a bit soon) - so I've not been TOO closed minded in my purchases I suppose, mainly just in my tool use and appraisal. I've also been lucky in getting most of my LM's in great deals/trades with members here - I wouldn't have tried to get them otherwise.
-
It's a fair point and well made. I honestly try and look for the good points in any new multi I get (and am often quite forgiving) while at the same time I try not to be blind to any issues. I also try and separate any 'issues' into various category's; poorly designed, cheaply made, design compromise, cost compromise etc. Helps keep things in perspective IMO.
If you've noticed the word 'try' in that last paragraph a few times then it's because I also acknowledge that gut reaction plays a huge part. My first multi was a Supertool and I loved it, next was a PST and I was really disappointed. :-\ Looking back my reaction was certainly partly due to the well documented drawbacks with the PST, but mostly it was just the fact it wasn't my beloved Supertool. Do note that I have managed to forgive the PST for it's shortcomings (even though I do prefer the PST II) but I have yet to feel the love for my Skeletool or PPP.
-
Thanks mate
I think that comparison you made to a previously owned tool is a good point actually.I liked the SOG Powerlock, but it was too big to carry and I wasn't convinced about some of the tools. The PPP gave me a pocketable version with the best (for me) of the tool set and no handle covers - so I liked it. If I had got the PPP first, would I have liked it the same
Maybe the fact I couldn't connect with the Pulse was I hadn't spent time toting round and using a PST (or similar) for a while to feel the "benefits" of the Pulse
Would I have had such strong issues with the CS4 if I hadn't had SAK's first
I've not tried a Skele ... but it wouldn't be something I'd reach for anyway with the other options I've got.Well day one of CS4 carry completed, and fingers and toes all present and accounted for. I'm actually looking forward to trying to recalibrate my views on tools, and seeing whether my favourites and biases change. Must remember to pick up a battery for my Timekeeper so I can let that out for some fresh air!
@ Chako - Do you have any favourite tools (for carry) when you're not bound to the knifeless fuse?
-
Well I can honestly tell you it won't be the Gerber Recoil anytime soon.

Hmmm...
I am partial to these tools in no given order.
Leatherman Super Tool 200/300.
Leatherman PST II.
Leatherman Pulse.
Gerber Freehand.
Gerber MP600.
Victorinox SwissTool X.
SOG PowerLock.
Bear & Son Super Bear Jaws. -
I've never met a tool that I didn't like :D
That being said, I do indeed have my preferences. And they run the gamut, Leatherman, Vic, Sharade (the old one), Kershaw, etc...
And in fairness, I always give every tool the chance to try and measure up to the power of the


-
I my Multi buying reflects my other tool buying . I buy the best I can afford , and most suited for the task .
99% of what I ACTUALLY do , could be handled by a SAK like an Alox Soldier or Tinker Small .
Chris
-
My tools get "Farm Duty Beatdowns". If I have to go to a back up of some sort, or the tool fails based on its design, then it heads out of rotation for the long term.
Some examples:
Vic SwissTool Spirit: Beautiful mirror like finish, lovely click into place tools. However, add grease, oil, diesel fuel, etc and suddenly that ultrasmooth finish makes the tool nearly impossible to handle. No pocket clip.
SOG PowerPliers: Love the compound leverage but, the other tools in the handle bend with the slightest sideways pressure. The little spring on the 1/4 driver is a little to fiddly for work in a pasture (try to find that in the grass).
Spyderco Spyderench: The pliers fall apart way too easily. Enough said.
Basically, I need a tool to just work when I FINALLY get the pieces lined up, I have to hold them in place and blindly grab for the tool to fix them in place. No drama from the tool. Generally, that's what I get from the LM Charge/wave series (and as well as the original PST and Skeletool).
Btw, the Juice series fails mainly because the flat drivers are a pain to get out (literally if you're not careful :ahhh)
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
My tools get "Farm Duty Beatdowns". If I have to go to a back up of some sort, or the tool fails based on its design, then it heads out of rotation for the long term.Perfect! It either works or it doesn't! Just how tool selection should be

I'm with you on the Spirit, I love mine to bits - but there's no way I could even try to use it at work. That role is reserved for the Wave. I've not found any other folding pliers that work better in that environment (perpetual grease and grime). I caught myself reaching for the CS4 earlier today and thought better of it. I'd feel the same about taking the Spirit to the boat. If that slips out of my hand it could be a very expensive day - but at least down there I can go for Swissgrip as I don't need to pocket carry. Again, best in role for me from what I've handled (wet hands, oils and greases and unforgiving tasks) - but does occasionally need needlenose accompanyment from time to time I've discovered. It's away from these areas where things get a little fuzzy for me, and can be vulnerable to being ... biased? blinkered? narrow minded? (I really need to get some sleep)
I agree on the Juice drivers too. I must remember to take a diamond file to the flat drivers to soften the corners a smidge. I'd rather risk having a driver slip occasionally than take a bite out of my finger everytime I go rooting through them.
-
@turnsouth said:
I've never met a tool that I didn't like :DThat being said, I do indeed have my preferences. And they run the gamut, Leatherman, Vic, Sharade (the old one), Kershaw, etc...
And in fairness, I always give every tool the chance to try and measure up to the power of the


Not even a Gerber ... ducks for cover :P :D :D
Out of interest, how early in your MT timeline did you get the Core? Was that your first heavy duty multi?
-
@50ft-trad said:
I've never met a tool that I didn't like :D
Not even a Gerber ... ducks for cover :P :D :D
While I never found Gerber's to be my cup of tea, it's not that I don't like them. I suppose that if there were no other tools on earth... :D
And I do keep a Radius in my collection, mostly so I can see the "What the Smurf!" look on people's faces, when I hand it to them. ;)
Out of interest, how early in your MT timeline did you get the Core? Was that your first heavy duty multi?
I started with one original ST, and when the ST200 came out, I got about a half a dozen to keep in handy places (Cars, BOB, tool box, EDC. My daughter still has one in her glove box.) When I got my first Core (I think it was a replacement for a broken ST200 I sent to LM) I was hooked. Been trying out the ST300, but I'm not sure if its new features will overcome its shortcomings when compared to the Core. Time will tell...
-
Honestly, when it comes to being biased FOR tools Victorinox gets the nod. Now I own several makes and models but Vic hands down has proven itself in real life situations to do what needs to be done, without failure while being pleasing to the eye. Or my eye anyways. Mind you the only tool I have ever managed to break was a Swisstool, but then again I dont think it was engineered to use the scraper as a chisel. Being hit by a five pound sledge. For five years. I guess it earned its failure.
Now when it comes to being biased AGAINST tools...I just don't care for Wengers. There I said it.
Nothing wrong with 'em I guess, just not for me. -
I'm pretty new to Leatherman tools having only picked up my first non-keychain sized one, a KF4, several months ago. I loved it when I got it and still love it. Then I got a Charge TTI and really loved it. Then I got all the bits and accessories and loved it even more. Then I got a Swisstool Spirit X and was blown away by the craftsmanship :o As nice as the Charge is, it just seems frumpy compared to the Swisstool. But when I started carrying the Spirit, I missed having all those Leatherman bits and the few special hardware store bits I keep with it, I also missed the pocket clip and the one hand opening blades, and the cutting hook, and the wider opening pliers. So I went back to carrying the Charge, in an urban environment it just seems more practical. But I love Victorinox knives very much and would feel naked without one, so I always have a Farmer or Super Tinker or OHT with me as well. I just got a Vic Explorer and am loving this tool, forgot how useful and fun it is to have a magnifying glass. So basically it's primarily about practicality for me. The Spirit is better made and each implement is a work of art, but for me the Charge wins for it's functionality and convenience.
-
@grimm_kaosboy said:
Mind you the only tool I have ever managed to break was a Swisstool, but then again I dont think it was engineered to use the scraper as a chisel. Being hit by a five pound sledge. For five years. I guess it earned its failure.
What a magnificent way to void a warranty :D :D :@theonew said:
I'm pretty new to Leatherman tools having only picked up my first non-keychain sized one, a KF4, several months ago. I loved it when I got it and still love it. Then I got a Charge TTI and really loved it. Then I got all the bits and accessories and loved it even more. Then I got a Swisstool Spirit X and was blown away by the craftsmanship :o As nice as the Charge is, it just seems frumpy compared to the Swisstool. But when I started carrying the Spirit, I missed having all those Leatherman bits and the few special hardware store bits I keep with it, I also missed the pocket clip and the one hand opening blades, and the cutting hook, and the wider opening pliers. So I went back to carrying the Charge, in an urban environment it just seems more practical. But I love Victorinox knives very much and would feel naked without one, so I always have a Farmer or Super Tinker or OHT with me as well. I just got a Vic Explorer and am loving this tool, forgot how useful and fun it is to have a magnifying glass. So basically it's primarily about practicality for me. The Spirit is better made and each implement is a work of art, but for me the Charge wins for it's functionality and convenience.Interesting! I prefer the Spirit for "clean" carry, and the Wave for dirty work. I don't think the Swisstool or Spirit have ever left me wanting in an urban setting., I do wish the Spirit had a proper lanyard attachment though (i.e. on the end) so it would work with a suspension clip. I find suspension clips safer as the tool is wholly within the pocket and the smaller clip draws less attention
-
Like theonew, I'm pretty new to the carrying a Leatherman/Gerber/whatever. For years, my everyday tool was my Vic Tinker. My LM Blast saw only light use, even though a set of pliers is occasionally very useful at work. I would have been perfectly happy with that set up, but NO! I had to find this site when, on a whim, I got a Wenger SI and was looking for info about it. Nowadays, me setup at work is either my Kick or Wave on my hip, and a SAK of some sort in my pocket. Occasionally I'll carry my MP450, which I was nervous about first using, judging from what I had read here about Gerber. Shows how wrong I was, the MP450 is a great little tool and I'm very happy with it. As far as SAKs go, that Tinker turned into 12 all of a sudden, ranging from a Classic to the OH Trekker I just received today. My idea on tools seems to be if it looks neat, it's mine. No drawer queens here though, everything in the collection had seen its share of carry time. The plus for me is that whatever tool I'm carrying, it works for what I need it for and that's all I require.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login