Interesting Comparison
-
I've been thinking for a while now why I have so many Wenger's with so called "soft" backsprings so I did a closer inspection and found that all of them has cracked liners on the backlayer tools,I did a mock up on my bench with the backspring and blades and the backsprings are fine there's absolutely nothing wrong with them,then I compared the Wenger liners with Victorinox liners and you can clearly see that the Vic liners have a lot more "meat" as the hole is much further from the edge of the liner,all these Wenger's are on the old side so I don't know if the new ones are still the same.

cracked Wenger inner liner

messed up outer liner

-
Nice detective work!!
-
That's a very interesting idea, nice work.

-
that's really clever. I would have assumed that the steel was simply tempered more soft. We have to look at new ones now, to see if they have the same flaw waiting to happen, or if they have changed the design.
-
That is interesting. Good theory!

On the liners for models with backspring tools, does the crack only affect the tools on the back, or the blades as well?
I also noticed that the Wenger inner liner you show with a crack has a similar hole location when compared to Vic's alox knives. I haven't heard much about the alox knives developing weak springs, so I wonder if the more stout scales make a big difference?

-
@gustophersmob said:
That is interesting. Good theory!
On the liners for models with backspring tools, does the crack only affect the tools on the back, or the blades as well?
I also noticed that the Wenger inner liner you show with a crack has a similar hole location when compared to Vic's alox knives. I haven't heard much about the alox knives developing weak springs, so I wonder if the more stout scales make a big difference?

absolutely the blades as well. Without the middle pin/back tool being held tight to the backspring there's less pressure on the spring and so less tension on the whole layer, it would absolutely make for 'floppy' or lazy action on the blades.
-
That is interesting. Good theory!

On the liners for models with backspring tools, does the crack only affect the tools on the back, or the blades as well?
I also noticed that the Wenger inner liner you show with a crack has a similar hole location when compared to Vic's alox knives. I haven't heard much about the alox knives developing weak springs, so I wonder if the more stout scales make a big difference?

absolutely the blades as well. Without the middle pin/back tool being held tight to the backspring there's less pressure on the spring and so less tension on the whole layer, it would absolutely make for 'floppy' or lazy action on the blades.
Gotcha. I kind of figured as much, but wasn't sure if maybe it was the 4th pin that provided the pressure.
Thanks for the clarification!
-
Very interesting stuff here. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login