Cheap and cheerful???
-
I am not advocating stealing anyone's designs.
However, this is a forum for discussion of multitools- all of them, be they real or copies. We have discussed knockoff SAKs and Leathermans too, so why the special treatment for Peter?
This forum is not beholden to any manufacturers- it is loyal to it's members, and if they want to discuss a certain tool then so be it.
Def
-
Someone one shouldn't be told that stealing is wrong. Just because someone hasn't sued another yet doesn't mean it is right to steal in the meantime. Right is right, wrong is wrong. People should be doing what is right irregardless of who is aware of that person's actions or not. It shouldn't be left for the LEO, court, lawyer, etc. Use you're $ to do what is right.
Discussing and condoning are two very different things. Sure, discuss the copy. I expect that. I also expected that most people would not be in favor of it and not go and make the purchase. Maybe I'm just the minority here, but it was how I was raised. -
I agree that people should vote with their $$, but you can't be upset when they vote differently than you may.
To be honest, Peter could license some of his designs to a large scale manufacturer and crank out some affordable production versions of his tools while still maintaining his custom, limited run market. The very fact that he hasn't makes me wonder if these copies are really that important to him. If anyone is in contact with Peter they can tell him to contact me by email, through Facebook or through this forum and I will be happy to offer any/all help I can to put him in contact with a company that will do his designs justice.
Add to that the very limited availability of his current line and he's just feeding the copy market. After all, if I want a specific tool and it's not available from him, how else am I supposed to get it?
I'm not condoning or condemning purchasing copies, I'm just suggesting a scenario in which a buyer may feel justified in purchasing a copy. Similar to kit cars- I can't afford a '67 Shelby Cobra myself, but I can afford a VW chassis and a fiberglass body kit.
Individuals are welcome to spend their money any way they like. It's part of living in a free and democratic society. And Multitool.org is dedicated to discussion about tools, regardless of where they come from.
Def
-
@Death's Head said:
Wow, I don't visit this forum often, and I am quite surprised by the degree of acceptance regarding stealing.Is it stealing? In order to steal a design, the design has to be officially owned by someone. There are very clear procedures to do this. It's called a patent. If these procedures are not followed, then this design can't truly be stolen, since it doesn't belong to anyone.
If Atwood has patented his idea, he has a bit more legal standing. Not you, or me. If he hasn't, he can claim that the idea is his. But any copies are not actually stolen, and are actually free to be copied. This isn't some revolutionary reading of the rules. It's the way the system works, and has for a pretty long time.
-
Yeah, having a patent is a documented way of owning an idea, but does one need documentation at all times to tell him what is right and what is wrong.
Teaching someone early in life about right and wrong starts at home. And I'm pretty sure most of us do not start with teaching our little ones regarding pantents, trademarks and other lawyer related topics.
The point is, it is still someones idea... actually, it's not only that. This particular product is an exact replica one someone else's design, not a design that was inspired by another. And the manufacturer is now producing and selling this design.
Nobody does the right thing all the time, but I would figure that most of us who would do something wrong would know it was wrong and not have to be told the action was wrong.
It is unfortunate we live in a time where too many people feel it is OK to take an idea when they feel they will not be punished for it. Call me old fashioned then.
Lastly, I believe that not condemning one for their actions is quite similar to condoning. -
I don't know, I have no problem with the Chinese making a copy of Atwood's stuff.
They're never, ever, ever, ever going to take a cent away from him - people who know the name Peter Atwood or JD Ryan or Brian Flud or Jared Price or Ray Kirk or any of the other "boutique" tool or knife makers will ever buy a Chinese tool instead. The more likely scenario is that people buy a one piece tool, find they like it, start researching and then haul out the wallets for the "good" stuff.
Don't believe me? Go ask Coach or Gucci or Prada or Microsoft why they don't work harder to shut down piracy in Asia.
-
@jekostas said:
I don't know, I have no problem with the Chinese making a copy of Atwood's stuff.They're never, ever, ever, ever going to take a cent away from him - people who know the name Peter Atwood or JD Ryan or Brian Flud or Jared Price or Ray Kirk or any of the other "boutique" tool or knife makers will ever buy a Chinese tool instead. The more likely scenario is that people buy a one piece tool, find they like it, start researching and then haul out the wallets for the "good" stuff.
Don't believe me? Go ask Coach or Gucci or Prada or Microsoft why they don't work harder to shut down piracy in Asia.
I haven't read a post in this thread about "dictating moral values".
Do what you like, feel what you like, and express what you like. That's what I am doing. I'm just expressing my opinions, and it just happens to be different from the majority here.
I don't know if knifemakers or companies such those listed above are losing money or not. I assume so because I have read about the companies cracking down on bootlegs and imitations. Why they don't work harder? Not sure. I can only make assumptions. Maybe there's a limit to what they can do before it is no longer cost effective. That's my assumption. -
@Death's Head said:
Yeah, having a patent is a documented way of owning an idea, but does one need documentation at all times to tell him what is right and what is wrong.
Teaching someone early in life about right and wrong starts at home. And I'm pretty sure most of us do not start with teaching our little ones regarding pantents, trademarks and other lawyer related topics.
The point is, it is still someones idea... actually, it's not only that. This particular product is an exact replica one someone else's design, not a design that was inspired by another.Thing is, if it's patented, Atwood can use the patent to go after copies. And after a set number of years, the patent expires, and copies are fair game.
Yet, time and again, I'm told that even if there is no patent, I'm supposed to limit my consumer choices as if one exists anyway. Which actually goes beyond the protections of an actual patent, as the enforcement is up to the patent holder, not unconnected third parties like you and me. Not only that, I presumably am supposed to honor this non-existent patent in perpetuity, a power that a real patent would never endow. Because that's somehow the difference between right and wrong.
No. I understand the feelings behind such a position. But the wheels come off when put under scrutiny.
-
Well, definitely nobody is going to be punished over something like this. Of course one will do what he is comfortable doing.
I'm not an expert on the topic of patents, but are there such things as international patents? -
As I see it the G3/G5 Prybaby is the best design Peter has ever done, thus I'll humbly add my two cents to this discussion.
First of all, the only one who should get his panties in a bunch is Peter Atwood himself. I am really appalled by the "Chinese Way" of doing business. It reflects badly on them and will catch up. That out of the way, a businessman has to protect his interests and go after such practices by trademarks, patents and lawyers. An email to Peter to inform him of this blatant theft and a vote with our wallets is all that is needed at the moment.
Secondly, some incoherent ramblings. I am getting more and more alienated by the "Atwood hype". Is he an artist or a businessman? He obviously is in assembly line production on a rather large scale. His designs have become stale. His method of distribution is "strange" and a business case all in itself. He doesn't trademark or patent. So why doesn't he get his act together? A licensing to an impeccable knife/multitool company for his basic tools and artsy, innovative tools in the current business format?! A win-win for both the maker and the many customers?!
-
@Seamaster said:
As I see it the G3/G5 Prybaby is the best design Peter has ever done, thus I'll humbly add my two cents to this discussion.First of all, the only one who should get his panties in a bunch is Peter Atwood himself. I am really appalled by the "Chinese Way" of doing business. It reflects badly on them and will catch up. That out of the way, a businessman has to protect his interests and go after such practices by trademarks, patents and lawyers. An email to Peter to inform him of this blatant theft and a vote with our wallets is all that is needed at the moment.
The "Chinese Way" of doing business? American knife and tool companies copy designs from each other on a very regular basis. They've also been doing it a lot longer - Ka-Bar and Schrade, for example, made well-known copies of the Buck 110 Folding Hunter for years and years. In fact, the Schrade Lb7 folder is still made to this day.
Also, if I remember correctly we had this discussion multiple times when PocketToolX (then MK7) first started showing models of the Piranha and it was being compared to various Atwood tools.
Out and out copying tool designs is by no means limited to China. Or the US. Heck, there are very well made German knives patterned on Swiss Army knives being made to this day.
-
Here's my take on the issue; if I want to buy an Atwood right now then I simply can't, not without getting into the price inflated second hand market, where the re-sale value seems to be even higher than the original price, or am I wrong?
The way Mr Atwood seems to run his business means that he is never going to have stock sitting on the shelf waiting to be sold, so these copies are not ever going to make any difference to his current business model, or income. And good luck to him, it's a very interesting and clever way to run a business.

Would I prefer it to be at least a little different from Mr Atwood's design? Absolutely yes I would, but at lest it's only a copy and not a fake claiming to actual be an Atwood.
Do I think Mr Atwood will loose any money? Not in a month of Sundays. :D In fact, as was pointed out earlier in the thread, these could easily be 'gateway' tools to someone who would then go on to try and but a tool direct form Atwood. If the person could get their hands on one that is. ;)
-
@Death's Head said:
Well, definitely nobody is going to be punished over something like this. Of course one will do what he is comfortable doing.
I'm not an expert on the topic of patents, but are there such things as international patents?Yes there are such thing as international patents, but they only apply in countries that are willing to honor such things.
Patents are virtually worthless to someone like Peter by the way. A patent is a document stating that you own something and are entitled to all the rights that go along with it. Very handy, but the reality is that small businessmen like myself, Peter, JDR, Raker Knives and many of the other companies listed in this thread simply cannot afford to enforce a patent. It involves lots of legal fees, and that's assuming it's even a domestic dispute, which in today's world is not likely. If you have to chase a patent across a border it costs a lot more, especially if you have to go after it in places like China, and if you do follow it that far, the company that made it is likely to "go out of business" for an hour, re-open with a new sign on the door and continue to knock off your designs under a new name, meaning you have wasted all your money and have to start from scratch.
That's a bit simplified mind you, but if you chat with a lawyer for any length of time (s)he will probably tell you the same thing.
What you can do with some success is communicate with Customs Officials in countries that do honor patent and trademark law to have out and out fakes confiscated upon entry into their country. But, this often means they need to be direct copies, such as in the case of red handled Swiss Army Style knockoffs featuring some variety of a Swiss Cross. As you can see by the number of SAK copies available today, this is also pretty ineffectual, but at least it means that direct knockoffs are seized and your brand is relatively protected.
I don't condone stealing ideas but it is a fact of life. The up shot is, I can't see Peter losing any money off of this, and in fact, probably gaining money as it potentially introduces new people to the market who may purchase one of his tools later, and it galvanizes his existing customers as loyal buyers. This doesn't mean we should purposely promote this tool as a favor to Peter, but it also doesn't mean we should condemn it either.
It is a tool and it's available for purchase, therefore we have not only a right, but a responsibility to review it. Here at Multitool.org a tool stands or falls on it's abilities, not what's etched on it's side.
Def
-
Well said, Grant.
Jekostas, I was a bit vague on the "Chinese Way" for a reason, muddy waters so to say. A discussion about this won't lead to anything positive. I'm all for "Made in China" as long as there is a level playingfield. Grant slightly alluded to what is involved in going after such practices, so let's leave it at that.
While I agree that Peter Atwood won't loose any money on this, it is all too obvious that his intellectual properties have been appropriated. He surely is not the inventor of the pocket tool (a search in google books will turn up adverts for such tools in Popular Mechanics etc. from a hundred years ago), but this surely is a copy of his G3. Not even one attempt to improve his design.
As to this garnering him additional customers, I'm not so sure. The two markets are at the opposite ends of the spectrum. A potential buyer of this copy wouldn't even know who the originator is.
-
Maybe not initially, but if they like it enough to research it or lose it and try to go online to replace it many of them will read sites like this one and learn the truth.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
-
Having looked at the two pictures the cheap tool is not an exact copy as the cut outs on top and bottom are different. Minimal change from the Atwood which I am sure was the design brief but still a change. As for it being a fake it is clearly branded differently to an Atwood so that accusation does not hold up either. Manufacturing has borrowed each others ideas since time began (soft drinks spring to mind) with small changes applied. The other example I keep coming to would be hex bits. Someone somewhere came up with the idea however there are lots of companies out there producing hex bits in there own name now which to me all look the same.
True I would not like some one stealing my invention. However it does go on everywhere as described above and in the other posts above. I for one had more than my fair share of cheap leatherman knockoffs before getting the real thing. Yes they where naff and broke quickly, but without that frustration I would never have finally taken the plunge to get a proper leatherman.Anyway can we please get back to showing the pictures of tools which keeps us all entertained?
-
I agree that patents are probably worthless to someone like Atwood, as they tend to be to any small time inventor. The interesting thing here is that Atwood's success does not depend on his inventions or his "intellectual property". It depends on his business acumen and luck. Both of which he seems to have. He basically sells man-baubles for premium prices, and has carved out an enviable niche for himself. This is far more security than any claim on intellectual property can bestow.
-
The discussion about buying or not buying knock-offs will rage endlessly because that is the type of topic it is. Many have very strong beliefs on either side of the discussion and nobody is likely to change their minds.
But the original complaint in this thread was not about the buying of knock-offs. It was about supporting the buying of knock-offs.
kirk 13 started the thread with a picture and comments about a tool he purchased on Ebay. Some other members observed that it looked like a direct copy of an Atwood design.
Gadget Guy complained "It makes me sick that you guys support a direct copy! Mods: This is my opinion only which Def says I'm allowed." No problem so far, but that statement left me a bit confused. Was Gadget Guy sickened by the members or the mods?
Grant replies saying "Mods: This is my opinion only which Def says I'm allowed" Seems right. This is a forum for discussion, not an for enforcing one member's beliefs over another's.
Gadget Guy responds with "No drama here... I do not agree with supporting fakes, so I will not support a forum that does. Please delete my account when you get a chance." Now I am confused. Is he saying that, by allowing a discussion about a knock-off, that Grant and MTO support kock-offs? That is a bit of a stretch. This forum has covered many topics including other discussions about copies, but I don't remember Grant or any other admin. supporting or recommending the design, manufacture or sale of knock-offs.
Gadget Guy may have quit over the apparent support of copies by other members of MTO. That doesn't make sense though. There seems to be just as many members who not only don't support the purchase of knock-offs, they are offended by it. In fact, that is a very good reason to let the discussion continue. Let the members on both sides of an issue present their views.
I don't agree with some of what is written in this forum, but that doesn't stop me from reading the posts here, in fact it is one of the things that helps keep things interesting.
Threeme2189 made an interesting observation. We've talked about plenty of knock-offs and cheap alternatives before without any ill effects."
If we can discuss copies of other items without such outrage, why should a discussion about an Atwood knock-off be any different?
Its too bad that a member was offended enough to quit. Hopefully after some time away his curiosity will tempt him to come back and see what is going on here.
-
In John's defense, as he stated, he is very passionate about the works of small makers like Peter Atwood. Because of this he tends to be somewhat overprotective, and if I may, somewhat hot blooded when the discussion comes up. This is not meant to insult him in the slightest- in fact, I wish to heck I could create a product that inspired people to get behind it like that.
The down side is that John (using him as an example though the same thing can happen to most of us), can be offended by things, that when analyzed later on by a cooler head, seem quite different from what was initially read into it. At the time, he likely saw our support of a discussion about a blatant attempt to rip off a friend of his as support for a thief, which I'm sure all of us would react similarly if we were in his position. No one likes to sit idly by and watch their friend get ripped off.
As time goes by and we examine the details without holding a grudge we can see that it is in fact just a harmless, yet interesting discussion over something that exists within our range of topics. I hope that when John cools down and checks this thread out that he will decide to come back to us, but that is up to him, and as I said, there are no hard feelings.
This leads me into the speech I've made so often before, and yet hate having to make again. The short version is that a forum becomes very boring when everyone thinks the same way about everything. When folks are not allowed to have differences of opinions it is no longer a forum, it's an "againstum."
Def
-
Let's put an end to this. Someone already buy one of these suckers. Use it hard. Put it away wet. Write a honest review here on MTO. That's the way it's done here. I've got my doubts regarding steel choice, heat treat, wrench sizes, thickness etc. Anyone who compromises the design process also compromises production.
I'm not buying. I'm invested in the real thing from the golden years (2002 to roughly 2007) with special requests and no egos involved. Today, there are competitors with original ideas that are worth a look. Thinking of it, I should probably unload the stuff before the Atwood bubble bursts.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



