Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Cheap and cheerful???

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Keychain and One Piece Tools
107 Posts 1 Posters 17.3k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Keychain and One Piece Tools
  4. Cheap and cheerful???
Cheap and cheerful???
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • AimlessWanderer Offline
    AimlessWanderer
    Posts: 17,518
    AimlessWanderer Offline
    AimlessWanderer
    wrote on last edited by AimlessWanderer
    #50 Quote Reply

      Drifting back to the tool for a bit ...

      I applaud your passion John, but I suppose I draw the line in a different place as to what is a fake. Is a vaccuum cleaner other than a Hoover a fake? What about a mass produced car other than a Ford? Too diverse - OK - what about ball point pens?

      I must echo again that these are not counterfeit. These are not items pretending to be something they are not, or pretending to be made by someone they are not. They are just cheaply produced similies. You relate to the Atwood tools as an art form made by someone who is an artist first and a tool maker second, so lets examine other art forms .... fashion ... yes you have firms making knock off Levis, trying to scam buyers into buying their inferior good by fraudulently assuming the name of a market leader ... then you've got other firms just making cheap jeans with a nondescript totally seperate branding. I would **not ** knowingly buy knock off Levis - I **would ** buy otherwise branded cheap jeans - even if they were styled after one of the bigger name's products.

      Hopefully this clarifies the differentiation that a lot of people are putting on this topic. Immitation is the sincerest form of flattery, and it's not IMHO fraud or theft is this particular scenario. If I thought it was theft, I wouldn't condone it and I'm very sure there ain't many others here that would either.

      EDIT: I ought to add I've been in manufacturing all my working life, both from the perspective of a service provider and a OEM so I fully understand the passion behind your views. We just have different interpretations of where imitation/inspiration becomes theft

      The cantankerous but occasionally useful member, formally known as 50ft-trad

      1 Reply Last reply
      • jekostas Offline
        jekostas
        Posts: 2,549
        jekostas Offline
        jekostas
        wrote on last edited by
        #51 Quote Reply

          @50ft-trad said:
          Drifting back to the tool for a bit ...

          I applaud your passion John, but I suppose I draw the line in a different place as to what is a fake. Is a vaccuum cleaner other than a Hoover a fake? What about a mass produced car other than a Ford? Too diverse - OK - what about ball point pens?

          I must echo again that these are not counterfeit. These are not items pretending to be something they are not, or pretending to be made by someone they are not. They are just cheaply produced similies. You relate to the Atwood tools as an art form made by someone who is an artist first and a tool maker second, so lets examine other art forms .... fashion ... yes you have firms making knock off Levis, trying to scam buyers into buying their inferior good by fraudulently assuming the name of a market leader ... then you've got other firms just making cheap jeans with a nondescript totally seperate branding. I would **not ** knowingly buy knock off Levis - I **would ** buy otherwise branded cheap jeans - even if they were styled after one of the bigger name's products.

          Hopefully this clarifies the differentiation that a lot of people are putting on this topic. Immitation is the sincerest form of flattery, and it's not IMHO fraud or theft is this particular scenario. If I thought it was theft, I wouldn't condone it and I'm very sure there ain't many others here that would either.

          EDIT: I ought to add I've been in manufacturing all my working life, both from the perspective of a service provider and a OEM so I fully understand the passion behind your views. We just have different interpretations of where imitation/inspiration becomes theft

          Actually, fashion makes a very good example because there is a lot in common between fashion and tools.

          Namely, it was decided a long time ago in US and International Courts that individual parts of clothing and design could not be patented because the holder of a patent on say... men's shirt collars could control the market to the detriment of the consumer for years. This has not, to my knowledge, proven negative in any way to the consumer or the fashion industry as a whole.

          It's the same in tools - individual components cannot be patented. You can't hold a patent on a box wrench, you can't hold a patent on a hammer. You might be able to get a patent on a very specific mechanical means of doing the job a box wrench or hammer does, but even that's kind of murky - Spyderco was unable to trademark the round opening hole even though it was a Spyderco design for 20+ years. Benchmade has a patent on the Axis lock but that didn't stop a ton of companies from taking the basic design, tweaking it very slightly and making their own versions (Spyderco Ball Bearing Lock, Sog Piston lock, Sog Arc Lock, etc.). Look and feel patents wouldn't work either - Mr. Atwood himself has said that he was inspired by old style alligator wrenches, and they would be considered prior art.

          1 Reply Last reply
          • Threeme2189 Offline
            Threeme2189
            Posts: 2,021
            Threeme2189 Offline
            Threeme2189
            wrote on last edited by Threeme2189
            #52 Quote Reply

              I don't like stealing or being stolen from as much as any decent guy.
              But where do we draw the line?
              If people didn't "borrow ideas" from one another we would just have 1 kind of everything. And many things wouldn't exist today.
              Why buy a samsung galaxy? it's a rip off of the iphone.
              There are so many cheap alternatives to original higher priced products that have some kind of brand or a name that's worth more money.
              Why should I buy gap when I can get old navy clothes for less?
              Many technological advances have been made greatly due to taking somebodies idea or invention and changing it, and I'm sure a large number of times the other side didn't like the fact that someboy used their idea.

              Like I said before, if Peter Atwood wants to go after them, that's his decision. I won't
              As long as I have a choice, and it's legal then I will decide which product to buy.
              If I decide to go the cheap way I'll be fully aware of the consequences.
              If I buy a fake product that claims to be original, that's whole other story.

              By the way, this is a very interesting discussion.
              I won't hold a grudge to anyone and I do hope it doesn't get out of hand.

              Chuck Norris' preferred iron supplement is rebar.

              1 Reply Last reply
              • cerbera147 Offline
                cerbera147
                Posts: 3,242
                cerbera147 Offline
                cerbera147
                wrote on last edited by
                #53 Quote Reply

                  I've got an Atwood :salute: :tu:

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • theonew Offline
                    theonew
                    Posts: 1,294
                    theonew Offline
                    theonew
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #54 Quote Reply

                      Here's a couple of interesting articles about design patent infringement:

                      Design Patent Infringement Post-Egyptian Goddess

                      Design Patent Infringement Analysis and the Fubar

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • turnsouth Offline
                        turnsouth
                        Posts: 2,538
                        turnsouth Offline
                        turnsouth
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #55 Quote Reply

                          That's interesting. It seems that the courts ignore functional features, and only look at ornamental features when deciding on infringement.

                          So in this case they would most likely disregard the wrench, cap lifter and pry bar, leaving only the ornamental imprinting and edge design. Both of which seem to have been purposefully changed in the Chinese model.

                          Very interesting indeed...

                          Never underestimate the power of the fleece

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • jekostas Offline
                            jekostas
                            Posts: 2,549
                            jekostas Offline
                            jekostas
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #56 Quote Reply

                              If anyone is interested, I posted my thoughts on another one-piece tool by this same company over the in the reviews section: /topic/30886

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • theonew Offline
                                theonew
                                Posts: 1,294
                                theonew Offline
                                theonew
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #57 Quote Reply

                                  @turnsouth said:
                                  That's interesting. It seems that the courts ignore functional features, and only look at ornamental features when deciding on infringement.

                                  So in this case they would most likely disregard the wrench, cap lifter and pry bar, leaving only the ornamental imprinting and edge design. Both of which seem to have been purposefully changed in the Chinese model.

                                  Very interesting indeed...

                                  Actually, I saw the Egyptian Goddess ruling as having a positive effect in a case like this. Would it pass the "ordinary observer test"? I wouldn't think so. There is just too much similarity overall. If Mr. Atwood had a design patent in the US I would bet a simple "cease and desist" letter from an attorney would be enough to get the importer to drop it from their line. Most companies don't want to get involved in a lawsuit they know they can't win.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • jekostas Offline
                                    jekostas
                                    Posts: 2,549
                                    jekostas Offline
                                    jekostas
                                    wrote on last edited by jekostas
                                    #58 Quote Reply

                                      @theonew said:

                                      @turnsouth said:

                                      That's interesting. It seems that the courts ignore functional features, and only look at ornamental features when deciding on infringement.

                                      So in this case they would most likely disregard the wrench, cap lifter and pry bar, leaving only the ornamental imprinting and edge design. Both of which seem to have been purposefully changed in the Chinese model.

                                      Very interesting indeed...

                                      Actually, I saw the Egyptian Goddess ruling as having a positive effect in a case like this. Would it pass the "ordinary observer test"? I wouldn't think so. There is just too much similarity overall. If Mr. Atwood had a design patent in the US I would bet a simple "cease and desist" letter from an attorney would be enough to get the importer to drop it from their line. Most companies don't want to get involved in a lawsuit they know they can't win.

                                      The Navy tools all have their own branding applied quite clearly to them. There is no attempt to pass them off as Atwood tools. You give an "ordinary observer" an Atwood and the Navy tool and it would be easy for them to tell the difference.

                                      And there are no US-based importers, so a cease-and-desist letter wouldn't do anything anyways. If the Navy tools end up anywhere except China they're sold as one-offs.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • theonew Offline
                                        theonew
                                        Posts: 1,294
                                        theonew Offline
                                        theonew
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #59 Quote Reply

                                          @jekostas said:
                                          The Navy tools all have their own branding applied quite clearly to them. There is no attempt to pass them off as Atwood tools. You give an "ordinary observer" an Atwood and the Navy tool and it would be easy for them to tell the difference.

                                          That's an interesting point. I'm meeting my patent attorney friend for drinks later, I'll ask him what he thinks.

                                          @jekostas said:
                                          And there are no US-based importers, so a cease-and-desist letter wouldn't do anything anyways. If the Navy tools end up anywhere except China they're sold as one-offs.

                                          That was really just hypothetical example of how one might be able to protect their intellectual property without a protracted court battle.

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • Death's Head Offline
                                            Death's Head
                                            Posts: 81
                                            Death's Head Offline
                                            Death's Head
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #60 Quote Reply

                                              @jekostas said:

                                              @50ft-trad said:

                                              Drifting back to the tool for a bit ...

                                              I applaud your passion John, but I suppose I draw the line in a different place as to what is a fake. Is a vaccuum cleaner other than a Hoover a fake? What about a mass produced car other than a Ford? Too diverse - OK - what about ball point pens?

                                              I must echo again that these are not counterfeit. These are not items pretending to be something they are not, or pretending to be made by someone they are not. They are just cheaply produced similies. You relate to the Atwood tools as an art form made by someone who is an artist first and a tool maker second, so lets examine other art forms .... fashion ... yes you have firms making knock off Levis, trying to scam buyers into buying their inferior good by fraudulently assuming the name of a market leader ... then you've got other firms just making cheap jeans with a nondescript totally seperate branding. I would **not ** knowingly buy knock off Levis - I **would ** buy otherwise branded cheap jeans - even if they were styled after one of the bigger name's products.

                                              Hopefully this clarifies the differentiation that a lot of people are putting on this topic. Immitation is the sincerest form of flattery, and it's not IMHO fraud or theft is this particular scenario. If I thought it was theft, I wouldn't condone it and I'm very sure there ain't many others here that would either.

                                              EDIT: I ought to add I've been in manufacturing all my working life, both from the perspective of a service provider and a OEM so I fully understand the passion behind your views. We just have different interpretations of where imitation/inspiration becomes theft

                                              Actually, fashion makes a very good example because there is a lot in common between fashion and tools.

                                              Namely, it was decided a long time ago in US and International Courts that individual parts of clothing and design could not be patented because the holder of a patent on say... men's shirt collars could control the market to the detriment of the consumer for years. This has not, to my knowledge, proven negative in any way to the consumer or the fashion industry as a whole.

                                              It's the same in tools - individual components cannot be patented. You can't hold a patent on a box wrench, you can't hold a patent on a hammer. You might be able to get a patent on a very specific mechanical means of doing the job a box wrench or hammer does, but even that's kind of murky - Spyderco was unable to trademark the round opening hole even though it was a Spyderco design for 20+ years. Benchmade has a patent on the Axis lock but that didn't stop a ton of companies from taking the basic design, tweaking it very slightly and making their own versions (Spyderco Ball Bearing Lock, Sog Piston lock, Sog Arc Lock, etc.). Look and feel patents wouldn't work either - Mr. Atwood himself has said that he was inspired by old style alligator wrenches, and they would be considered prior art.

                                              For your information, the Spyderhole has been AA registered trademark since Jan 1995.

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • jekostas Offline
                                                jekostas
                                                Posts: 2,549
                                                jekostas Offline
                                                jekostas
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #61 Quote Reply

                                                  @Death's Head said:
                                                  For your information, the Spyderhole has been AA registered trademark since Jan 1995.

                                                  Yet Spyderco was unable to stop Benchmade from using it in the Ally, Soldat, Vex or Pika series of knives because it was decided that it was an unenforceable trademark. The Soldat, Ally and Pika are still being produced and sold right now.

                                                  Thanks for proving my point.

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • Death's Head Offline
                                                    Death's Head
                                                    Posts: 81
                                                    Death's Head Offline
                                                    Death's Head
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #62 Quote Reply

                                                      :sak:

                                                      @jekostas said:

                                                      @Death's Head said:

                                                      For your information, the Spyderhole has been AA registered trademark since Jan 1995.

                                                      Yet Spyderco was unable to stop Benchmade from using it in the Ally, Soldat, Vex or Pika series of knives because it was decided that it was an unenforceable trademark. The Soldat, Ally and Pika are still being produced and sold right now.

                                                      Thanks for proving my point.

                                                      No problem. I'm glad you feel I proved a point you had difficulty proving yourself. Just kidding buddy. :D
                                                      On the same token, the knifemaker Mick Strider has attained the license to use the Spyderhole on his customs which he does, but he refuses to use the Spyderhole on his productions because of trademark infringements, whether it can be enforced or not. I give Mick Strider respect for his decision on his usage Spyderco's hole.

                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • cerbera147 Offline
                                                        cerbera147
                                                        Posts: 3,242
                                                        cerbera147 Offline
                                                        cerbera147
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #63 Quote Reply

                                                          @jekostas said:

                                                          @Death's Head said:

                                                          For your information, the Spyderhole has been AA registered trademark since Jan 1995.

                                                          Yet Spyderco was unable to stop Benchmade from using it in the Ally, Soldat, Vex or Pika series of knives because it was decided that it was an unenforceable trademark. The Soldat, Ally and Pika are still being produced and sold right now.

                                                          Thanks for proving my point.

                                                          Wasn't there an out of court settlement / agreement between Spyderco and Benchmade?

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • jekostas Offline
                                                            jekostas
                                                            Posts: 2,549
                                                            jekostas Offline
                                                            jekostas
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #64 Quote Reply

                                                              @cerbera147 said:
                                                              Wasn't there an out of court settlement / agreement between Spyderco and Benchmade?

                                                              They did for a while, but that agreement was annulled because Benchmade wasn't giving credit to Spyderco for for the Hole in literature. Didn't stop Benchmade from continuing to use it, though.

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • Death's Head Offline
                                                                Death's Head
                                                                Posts: 81
                                                                Death's Head Offline
                                                                Death's Head
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #65 Quote Reply

                                                                  Has there been any release of any new models from Benchmade using the Spyderhole? I'm just wondering if an agreement was made for it's use with currently released models and no future releases from Benchmade.

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • jekostas Offline
                                                                    jekostas
                                                                    Posts: 2,549
                                                                    jekostas Offline
                                                                    jekostas
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #66 Quote Reply

                                                                      Edit: Forget it.

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • shecky Offline
                                                                        shecky
                                                                        Posts: 148
                                                                        shecky Offline
                                                                        shecky
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #67 Quote Reply

                                                                          @Gadget Guy said:
                                                                          I used to be Peter's top five customer. He would make custom pieces for me and basically make anything I asked of him. He got to the point where he was simply too busy to do that for any of his customers and that was hard for everyone, especially me. I don't cry about it though. :'( Peter has been good to me and is a really great guy, but he cant please everyone. Peter is an artist first and a tool maker second.

                                                                          This hints at one reason I suspect some folks take umbrage at copied things: defenders against copying often have some kind of skin in the game, even if it's not tangible, like pride. I've seen this with other things, like knife designs and so on. It seems that the more pricey and exclusive ownership is, the more passionate the opinion over copies.

                                                                          I realize yours is a passionately held position. But it does not strike me as particularly strong, as your case hinges on your personal moral authority, not on any particular damages perpetrated.

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • Freudian Frog Offline
                                                                            Freudian Frog
                                                                            Posts: 4,230
                                                                            Freudian Frog Offline
                                                                            Freudian Frog
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #68 Quote Reply

                                                                              Awww, I'm in late on this party. Anyway, there is nothing patentable on an Atwood tool, literally nothing. :P

                                                                              And as an artist, he should be able to sell his art despite similar products anyway. :tu:

                                                                              Got those frog legs.

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • theonew Offline
                                                                                theonew
                                                                                Posts: 1,294
                                                                                theonew Offline
                                                                                theonew
                                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                                #69 Quote Reply

                                                                                  @jekostas said:
                                                                                  The Navy tools all have their own branding applied quite clearly to them. There is no attempt to pass them off as Atwood tools. You give an "ordinary observer" an Atwood and the Navy tool and it would be easy for them to tell the difference.

                                                                                  Well I had a strong suspicion this was wrong but figured since I had access to an expert I'd wait until I spoke with him. According to my friend you would just claim the shape of the object and not any surface treatment such as branding. So even though one tool said Navy and the other Atwood the only issue for determining design patent infringement would be whether the "ordinary observer" found the shape of the Navy tool to be substantially similar to the Atwood tool, and I think it's safe to say that Navy would lose this battle in court. Since there is no design patent on this tool this is all academic but it do think it worth noting that if an artist or designer is concerned with theft of their intellectual property they could obtain a design patent on their work for about $1000, less if they did it themselves. Utility patents on the other hand are very expensive and really need to be very carefully written by a smart and experienced patent attorney in order for the patent holder to be given good protection.

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 3
                                                                                  • 4
                                                                                  • 5
                                                                                  • 6
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                                                  3. Keychain and One Piece Tools
                                                                                  4. Cheap and cheerful???
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0