Time to get nasty!
-
I think plastic is alright in the beginning, especially when new, but over the years it gets brittle and breaks.
We'll see how these petroleum products hold up over the next few decades! -
I'm all keen now for a "Pocket" multi showdown and/or big Pic comparison.
SOG PPP
Vic Spirit (?)
LM Sideclip
LM Kick
LM PST
LM Juice.is the MP400 Gerber's official offering for "pocket sized" multis? (As opposed to Keychain, Full Size, or Large - as defined by Leatherman)
The ? on Spirit is because I am not sure if this is considered a Pocket or Full size (as the Swisstool is generally considered Large), I guess since it is the only option from Vic, it will have to do.
-
I don't care for the Juice lineup at all - they seem over-priced, over-weight, and under-strength.
I've seen a couple of Juices break in use on backpacking trips. In both cases, my original Leatherman was able to complete the task that had broken the Juice. (One broke while repairing a white gas stove and the other broke while repairing a pack frame.)
That's a shame really as I would say the Juice is a very solid tool. I do however completely agree with the price! They do seem very high, but a quility tool nonetheless. I have a KF4 and I really like it and would chose it over my PST for EDC.
Well, Juices do have the advantage of greater compactness for EDC, but no advantage in weight over a PST. Juices are too heavy for pocket carry for me (as is the PST) and I don't EDC a tool in a belt sheath.
For the same weight, I'd as soon have something more robust as a backup/repair tool.
After seeing a couple of the Juices break in action, I don't really trust them as backup tools. They're better than nothing, but not that good for their weight.
.
-
LOL I pocket carry my Supertool sometimes and it doesn't bother me. Maybe you need bigger pockets. :P
-
I've heard Benner packs, I always thought they meant something else!

-
@WhichDawg said:
I've heard Benner packs, I always thought they meant something else!
:D
-
How's the fam boss Benner? and where's all the new pictures with the new camera huh?!
-
@WhichDawg said:
How's the fam boss Benner? and where's all the new pictures with the new camera huh?!There good ta! :D
As it so happens, I have just done a load more! :) Stay tuned for a new topic in the general tool discussion forum in the next few minutes.
-
The ? on Spirit is because I am not sure if this is considered a Pocket or Full size
I pocket carry a Spirit and it is a bit big but it's also much smoother than anything else it's size so I think it makes a great pocket carry tool. I'd include it in a test.
-
LOL I pocket carry my Supertool sometimes and it doesn't bother me. Maybe you need bigger pockets. :P
If you regularly pocket carry a Supertool, then you're a better man than I am, Gunga Din. Certainly a better prepared man. More power to you!
.
I wouldn't say that, I have 2 children. :D
-
I have a bitch with the Spirit , its so close to being the perfect multi . The problems -1) needs a hole opener like the one hand treker on the master blade , 2) needs a pocket clip in the worst way , and 3) needs beadblasted handle halves - its uber slippery !
Almosts piss me off more than complete misses , ie the whole Gerber line up !
Chris
-
Only thing that I dont understand about the Spirit is the Squared off Blade,wish they would offer a Spear Point Option.
Dtrain
:sak:
:tool: -
The Spirit S offers that, but you lose the scissors!
-
I am growing a little disillusioned with the Leatherman line as well. I've said it for years that the older models seemed tougher and better built then the newer ones, and more functional. No they didn't lock, no the handles weren't comfortable. But they could do it all. And it FELT like they were indestructible. I own the Sideclip, and it's a little tank. The newer tools....... I don't know. Expensive, plastic inserts, bulky...... I just don;t think I'm into Leatherman anymore. The VIC line of multitools are worth complaining about as well. They are good, solid tools, sure, but tools are meant to be useful, not pretty. The polish on them needs to go. The handles are slippery when wet, and the drivers slide all over the place. Plus, the tension on the tools, while a good idea, are just too darn strong. They are nail breakers. Also, why are there only two models? I know they each have "subspecies", but in essence, you have the Swisstool and the Spirit. That's it. What's up with that? They have TONS of knife based multitools, but just the two plier based ones.
Sog, Gerber..... I'm actually pretty turned off to the whole plier based line of tools period. Maybe I'm the one doing something wrong (Actually, it's probably IS me doing something wrong), but I've stripped many a bolt with those pliers. I'd rather use a set of pliers, or a wrench. I know I don't always have one on me, and that's the whole point of a multi, but for me personally it's just not very practical. Plus I don't really have too much of a NEED for pliers. I basically never use them, other then when I'm building or taking something apart at work or at home, and when that happens, I have access to dedicated tools. I use a knife all the time, and if it carries with it some small tools to work with, that works better for me. -
@WhichDawg said:
My biggest complaint is the price of Leathermans, 120.00 usd for a Charge XTi?! (I'm talking retail)
Why are they so much? does it cost that much to make good screwdrivers? or is it because they are
so popular, and that is what the public will pay? (I won't) I haven't and won't buy many Leathermans
because of their price. Don't get me started on their plastic parts on the cheaper models! :DI think it's due to the fact the body of the Charge is titanium
-
My biggest complaint is the price of Leathermans, 120.00 usd for a Charge XTi?! (I'm talking retail)
Why are they so much? does it cost that much to make good screwdrivers? or is it because they are
so popular, and that is what the public will pay? (I won't) I haven't and won't buy many Leathermans
because of their price. Don't get me started on their plastic parts on the cheaper models! :DI think it's due to the fact the body of the Charge is titanium
The thing about that, as Def has pointed out before, is that the body is NOT made out of titanium. It's made of metal. The SCALES are the only thing made of titanium.
-
It's made of metal. The SCALES are the only thing made of titanium.
Steel.
I still don't know if the Charge scales are any better than the folded Wave style.
-
@Navajero316 said:
I use a knife all the time, and if it carries with it some small tools to work with, that works better for me.You need to start modding your tools and make some SuperSlabs*. I've been tossing it around for a while since I have some parts and handles I just don't know if I'd use it over my regular multis. May work for you though.
SuperSlabs (a term stolen from someone else on this board) are when you remove one handle from a typical multi, remove the plier head and load it out with whatever tools you like. It takes on the form factor of a SAK but slightly different and more customizable.
A Wave/Charge SuperSlab would be ideal for me but the startup cost is way to high.
-
Would you be able to put tools at both ends of a SuperSlab? Just looking at my kick and i think it would be possible, just move the pivot from the other handle to where the plier pivot used to be.
Roadie
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login