Any love for Wenger?
-
Harder to mod. :(
Personally, I love the Wenger S557 AND the Ranger Mike Horn. Really good SAKs. My Mike Horn Ranger is a regular EDC, especially if I think I'm going to be driving a lot of screws/bolts.
The 85mm size is much more pocket friendly.
-
For me, vics were all I owned or even knew about growing up. I recently bought a keychain size wenger and the quality on it is pretty bad. I don't know if that is representative of their whole line, but it turned me right off from buying any more.
-
For me it generally is the price. Why buy a Wenger Traveler for $30something when you can get a Vic Climber for $25. Especially when most people think Vic has better fit and finish.
Wenger does have some cool models though. I must admit I have been looking at getting a Wenger Swiss Clipper recently.
Also: That damned Wenger can opener. Vic models win me over most of the time because of it. Why settle for a single function can opener when the Vic gives you a can opener, small flathead, and small philips head driver.
-
I collect both Victorinox and Wenger. My EDC for many years has been a Wenger Traveler. The 85mm length seems to fit my pocket better than the 91mm Victorinox, and the short Vics don't currently have scissors. Conversely I prefer the greater length of the Wenger Pocket Tool Chest to the Victorinox Mini Champ. On the other hand a Victorinox Huntsman is my usual choice when outdoors, and there's an old Champion sitting in the desk drawer as I write. Believe there's a Fieldmaster in the car glovebox, and a large 111mm Vic (don't remember which one) in the survival kit in the trunk. So both brands are in regular use.
Karl
-
When I was growing up Vics were far more common than Wengers and less expensive. Now that I can afford either the reason I choose Vic is:
- the small screw driver on the can opener
- Vic reamer is actually useful
- majority of Wengers seem to come with a nailfile instead of the small blade.
- I prefer the slightly longer handle of the 91mm Vic
- You can get plus scales for the Vic
-
Well since some people like them I have a freebie for you wenger fans. I received some free stickers in the mail. I will share them to the first five to ask.
-
I like Wenger. In fact, I'd go so far as to say I prefer them - the scissors are my most used item on the SAKs I have and I like the Wenger backspring scissors better than the Vic leaf-spring scissors. Also, just got some Wenger Fingernail Clippers and they're quite good (and fun to fiddle with).
-
The ones who know me around these parts know I'm a real and dedicated wenger fan, my favourites being the commander, traveler and formost the forester/17 models. I actually collect the forester variations. What I like the most are the scissors and the can opener, and also the fact that some of them have a locking main blade.
-
The very first Wenger I ever got was a second hand Forester and it was terrible, everything just felt wrong and lived up to all the bad press I'd heard about Wenger. :( Then I got a Commander from Neil and a new 120mm Ranger and I was converted, both excellently well built SAKs. Followed up with a Evo 17 and a SI and I couldn't be happier.

-
I love the Evo type grips.I have a J10,EvoGrip 18 in yellow(oh so pretty..),a J554,EvoWood14(?),and a pair of Evo81s(Translucent blue and Patagonia Yellow).
Things I like1)Evo type grips,very good ergonomics!
2)Scissors!
3)Semi locking screwdriver
4)Nail file on a decent sized SAKBetter than Vic?Maybe not,but they are very charismatic,and more inovative than Vic
-
I much prefer Vic to Wenger for various reasons, BUT, I really like the Wenger Standard Issue.
-
I really like some of the Wenger stuff. Sure it's not quite as high quality compared to the Victorinox but they make some interesting sometimes odd tool/knife combinations. I agree the Wenger Standard Issue is a solid piece and probably their best knife. The SOSAK 2010 KOTY, a Wenger EvoWood 18, is my always EDC and the huge Mike Horn Ranger if I need something stronger.
My favourite Wenger is my Director (thanks Felinevet!)
http://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Wenger+Director
it has a manual telescoping pointer. I was an IT trainer back in the late 80's and the ultimate accessory was one of those pointers (I never had one). The fact that Wenger put one in a knife is just ultimate geek. -
I tend to prefer Vic from what I have experienced. However, Wenger seem to be trying very hard to establish new markets, and to fix up their older problems, like weak backsprings. I have no trouble imagining what Vic knives will look like in two years - slightly improved versions of their classic models, but I'm pretty sure Wenger will surprise me in a good way with their new stuff.
-
So no one wants free stickers? Just ask I'll send them to you.
-
@tattoosteve99 said:
So no one wants free stickers? Just ask I'll send them to you.Steve,
Thanks for the offer, but I already have an inch-thick pile of Wenger stickers, flyers and brochures; not to mention a dozen catalogs. By the way I checked with the Wenger store in Boulder recently and they still don't have 2011 catalogs.
Karl
-
When it comes to the feel of Wenger backsprings I think we can be a little unfair. Most of the time folks are comparing Vic's 91mm springs to Wenger's 85mm ones. Now if we compare them to Vic's 84mm line the difference becomes far less obvious, if there at all. :)
-
Wengers are a lot less common, at least from my experience.
Most people, unaware of the Swiss Army knife history, assume that they are just trying to copy Victorinox, so they are of a lesser quality; so they do not buy them and prefer Victorinox.I like the Wenger scissors feel and the locking flat screwdriver.
I also like their cigar cutter for its look, though it is not that good to use. -
I prefer Victorinox because they have better built quailty, but I own some Wengers I really love. I would say Wenger makes the more innovative SAK, Vic more traditional. I like them both. An Evowood might be my next EDC.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login