Rediscovering Wenger
-
@Gareth said:
The ongoing feeling that Wenger is of a slightly lower quality does persist. :-\ Several factors are to blame here IMO.-
Wenger did indeed seem to go through a really rough patch in QC about 5-10 years ago (very roughly anyway). This seems to not be an issue any more.
-
85mm Wenger blades are thinner than the Vic equivalents. Though the can opener layer is very much the same thickness.
-
**Wenger's 85mm backsprings are notably 'softer' than Vic's 91mm ones and people don't like the difference. IMO the comparison is a little unfair as if you compare the Wenger to the Vic 84mm SAKs then the difference is far less noticeable if at all. **
All-in-all Wenger's do feel different to Vic, but I'd dispute the opinion that they are lower quality these days.
This is what does it for me, primarily. I EDC a Vic 84mm (cadet), and I still think the Wenger's snap is lacking compared to it. I don't think the Wenger's snap is a defect, though, I just prefer the Vic's.
Wengers are usually much more expensive than Vic for similar models (at least around here), and I have noticed a lower level of fit and finish.
For example, my only current Wenger (I have gifted the rest) is an '04 SI. When compared to an '04 Vic Soldier, there are more gaps between the springs, liners and scales, the snap is weaker, and the main blade tip hits the spacer next to the awl when closed.
That being said, I think Wenger has much more interesting designs, especially lately. I love the evo scales, the pocket tool chest has a great tool load out and the titanium line is pretty exciting (hopefully they make one with a more normal blade ::) ).
So, basically, I agree with Gareth that the issue is primarily one of differing feel between the brands.
-
-
Oh, I almost forgot. One thing I really like about Wenger is that their backsprings are flush with the liners. I HATE the feel of cellidor Vics because of this, and won't carry them*. This is primarily why I gravitate towards and carry alox.
*Except for the Recruit (no back side tools) and 111mm series (backsprings are flush). I have, and use, these.
-
I started out with a Wenger Master which I had for over 15 years and loved. Then recently I got into Victorinox SAKs starting with a Compact. Although I was used to the Wenger tools and found Victorinox a little awkward at first, I gradually came to prefer Victorinox and will probably never go back. One example of the subtle differences between the brands is the scissors. The Wenger scissor handle is skinny so when you cut something that requires a lot of force, the handle painfully digs into your thumb. The Victorinox scissor handle is fatter and more comfortable. I also prefer the springs on Victorinox scissors and pliers because the tool stays in place when you open and close it. The Wenger scissors and pliers use the back spring for tension which results in the whole tool moving as you open and close it. Another preference I have is for Victorinox tweezers which seem to open wider and have more springiness than Wenger tweezers. Little things like this add up for me though I wouldn't say that Wenger SAKs are poor at all. I just prefer Victorinox.
-
@donnyq said:
The Wenger scissor handle is skinny so when you cut something that requires a lot of force, the handle painfully digs into your thumb. The Victorinox scissor handle is fatter and more comfortable. I also prefer the springs on Victorinox scissors and pliers because the tool stays in place when you open and close it. The Wenger scissors and pliers use the back spring for tension which results in the whole tool moving as you open and close it. Another preference I have is for Victorinox tweezers which seem to open wider and have more springiness than Wenger tweezers. Little things like this add up for me though I wouldn't say that Wenger SAKs are poor at all. I just prefer Victorinox.I am with you on that. Those Wenger scissors cut great but if force is needed it hurts some. I too prefer the Vic tweezers but I do like the way the tweezers fit into Wenger scales. I find sometimes a Vic tweezers head might get damaged some and will inadvertently pop out when you remove it from your pocket.
I really dig the Wenger EVO scales especially in the Grip version. I wish they had more colors and would make scales available for sale to us.
-
@donnyq said:
I started out with a Wenger Master which I had for over 15 years and loved. Then recently I got into Victorinox SAKs starting with a Compact. Although I was used to the Wenger tools and found Victorinox a little awkward at first, I gradually came to prefer Victorinox and will probably never go back. One example of the subtle differences between the brands is the scissors. The Wenger scissor handle is skinny so when you cut something that requires a lot of force, the handle painfully digs into your thumb. The Victorinox scissor handle is fatter and more comfortable. I also prefer the springs on Victorinox scissors and pliers because the tool stays in place when you open and close it. The Wenger scissors and pliers use the back spring for tension which results in the whole tool moving as you open and close it. Another preference I have is for Victorinox tweezers which seem to open wider and have more springiness than Wenger tweezers. Little things like this add up for me though I wouldn't say that Wenger SAKs are poor at all. I just prefer Victorinox.Welcome to the forum donnyq! (says another newbie) Really good first post. And I think you sum it up great in the end.

To me the design of the knife shape is a lot more important than how wide the tweezers open. The locking screwdriver of a Wenger is worth a lot more to me than a bit of discomfort when I cut a string or a zip tie. Having the accessories on the inside of the scales, making the knife more streamlined, seems like a much bigger deal to me than the specifics of the toothpick.

-
Just a note on quality personaly I think the early 80's wenger soldiers were much better knifes than the equivilent vic mainly down to the finish on the main blade
Today I picked up a model 1908 wenger soldier and it is perfect also the use of Brass liners makes it look great (I think the fact it has spent the last 60 years or so in a case has helped it maintain its finish :) )
-
Wow that last one is beautiful! Where do you find all those beauties! :D
-
that 1908 Wenger is in amazing condition, did you have access to a time machine or something? ;)
-
Wowzzer!! that really is a beauty... and the case is nice too.
-
@kinskibrain said:
Welcome to the forum donnyq! (says another newbie) Really good first post. And I think you sum it up great in the end.
To me the design of the knife shape is a lot more important than how wide the tweezers open. The locking screwdriver of a Wenger is worth a lot more to me than a bit of discomfort when I cut a string or a zip tie. Having the accessories on the inside of the scales, making the knife more streamlined, seems like a much bigger deal to me than the specifics of the toothpick.

Thanks kinskibrain. I do agree that Wenger has some very clever features like the locking blade on a 85mm knife. I was surprised to find this feature not available on equivalent Vicorinox knives. The Wenger plier jaws can also be locked in an open position which is neat.
-

Ok, Got my EvoGrip 18 in yellow today. Will post some pictures later. I like the tension. Nicer on my nails than Victorinox but still snappy and of great quality. The Vic is stiffer and I can understand why some really like this. I have not made up my mind yet, but right now I prefer the smooth action of the Wenger.
The Evo 18 is a little too thick. It's a little thicker than my Vic Forester! I love the shortness of the Wenger.
The knife came sharper than any Victorinox I have bought. I could cut newsprint against the grain with the factory edge. Not a perfect cut, but cutting newsprint against the grain is really good for any knife of this cost.
The saw is sharp but too short. But I like to think of saws as a sort of heavy duty serrated blade. It cuts things.. like a second knife.. sort of :P
The scissors I have not yet made up my mind on. I really like the spring design and the serrated edges. I don't like that both arms move. One should stay still.
The combo tool is a little small but love the lock. Genious.
Have not tried the can opener but it's really well sharpened and I like the bit in the instruction booklet showing how to use it to make a drinking hole in the can.
The nail tool is functional but I personally would prefer a small blade there. Can't have enough knives.
The pick and tweezers are great and the inboard mounting is much preferable to the Vic solution.
The ergonomics are actually really nice when you use it. The very thin knife blade sliced through some vegetables like it was nothing and I had wet hands. It felt really good and secure in my hand. The sculpted handle translates into precise control of the edge angle. Far more practical than the classic SAK design but not as good looking.
Great compact packaging too.

-
Sounds like you've happy.

-
@jaydar said:
Just a note on quality personaly I think the early 80's wenger soldiers were much better knifes than the equivilent vic mainly down to the finish on the main bladeToday I picked up a model 1908 wenger soldier and it is perfect also the use of Brass liners makes it look great (I think the fact it has spent the last 60 years or so in a case has helped it maintain its finish :) )
That is just magnificant
-
I really prefer wenger's tweezers, scissors and main blade, and I love evogrip, but I just cannot use the can opener. Also no alox range! That's why they're 2nd best for me.
Quality-wise, I've seen differences in the past but we're talking about the difference between Victorinox's A+ and Wengers A-, it's not a serious thing, only if you compare directly with Vic. And I'm willing to believe they've addressed that now.
-
Thanks Gareth, Yes I am very very happy about these Wenger knives. Anyone on this forum who does not own a Wenger Classic really should get one. There is something about the compactness of the Wenger together with that absolutely stunning logo, with an ever so slightly different shade of red (a manufacturers secret according to Wenger), and the lack of disturbing accessories on the outside make the Wenger visually much more pleasing than a Victorinox.
The relatively thin blade of the 85mm tool surprised me today. I spent some time on the Spyderco Sharpmaker at 30 degrees inclusive and then stropped the blade and the result was one of the sharpest knives I have ever experienced. I could cut hairs of my arm without touching the skin! I can easily slash and cut swirls in newsprint. The only other blade I have achieved the cutting hairs in air feat with is my Opinel. I also have or have owned Spyderco, Fallkniven, EKA and a bunch of Victorinox but this thin thin Wenger blade is sharper. It slices, sails through anything.
I'm not worried about it breaking since I never use a folding knife hard. I always carry good quality fixed blades if I am expecting serious cutting tasks.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
