Rank 'em scissors!
-
Love scissors! but,
I don't have experience with most product of the popular MTs out there (LMs, SAKs and Wengers),
So I have been wondering how would you rank their scissors.Mostly I have been wondering about scissors of Vic ST/Spirit, Vic Classic, LM Wave/Charge, LM Surge, LM Micra, LM Juice and LM style CS.
How would you rank them, 5 being the best and 1 being the worst among above bunch, in things like cutting finger nails, fabric, paper, cardboard, jeans, etc. -
Micra 4.5 losing a bit because of the thicker body getting in the way, Juice 4, larger SAK and LM ones 3, small SAK (classic etc) 2 and small LM (kick etc) 1.5.
bigger scissors are easier to use and have more leverage. However, all of the above will cut OK and better than no scissors -
I own all of the tools you mention except the surge. Best scissors are hands down are the ones on the swisstool. Large and precise. Next I would pick the regular sak scissors on the 91mm models. The spirit scissors arent the best but they are functional. The LM wave scissors are too small for me to use for what I used scissors for, but they do function nicely for their size. The juice scissors were nice when the tool was new, but they havent held up great for me, they dont feel precise anymore and the pivot has loosened.
-
Vic SAK and Swissstool scissors are the best. Hands down. You can't find better. 5
Vic Spirit scissors are a good. They're easy to keep sharp due to the large and thick bevel, but that also makes them ill-suited for fine work. They are also limited in how wide they can open, but that can be fixed in a few minutes with a file. 4
The scissors on the full-sized Leatherman tools are laughably tiny. 2
Leatherman Micra scissors are the ONLY good scissors that Leatherman makes. period. 4.
Leatherman Juice scissors are are a floppy, loose mess. 2
-
@shamus said:
Vic SAK and Swissstool scissors are the best. Hands down. You can't find better. 5Vic Spirit scissors are a good. They're easy to keep sharp due to the large and thick bevel, but that also makes them ill-suited for fine work. They are also limited in how wide they can open, but that can be fixed in a few minutes with a file. 4
The scissors on the full-sized Leatherman tools are laughably tiny. 2
Leatherman Micra scissors are the ONLY good scissors that Leatherman makes. period. 4.
Leatherman Juice scissors are are a floppy, loose mess. 2
I agree with this statement best. Victorinox scissors are by far the best out there.

-
For major work, I like the Micra/Style CS just for their size and capability. For detail work I like what's on the Vic Rambler. I have a Charge TTi & Juice S2 with scissors, and they do work, definitely not superior tho. No experience with large Vic scissors.
-
Only had experiance of the Leatherman Surge, but can definately say they work and perform excellently for me. i give LM Surge a 5
-
have a Charge TTi & Juice S2 with scissors, ***and they do work, ***
That's not really a ringing endorsement considering any pair of scissors can work, unless they're broke. Let's raise the bar a little and consider: do they work well? And in that case Leatherman falls woefully short in its current lineup. For good full-sized MT scissors you have to hitch a ride in a TARDIS and get a PSII or original Wave. The only exception is the Micra, but it's an old tool .
-
@shamus said:
The only exception is the Micra, but it's an old tool .The Micra is still in production.
Most Swiss Army knives are a lot older than the Micra. :D
Also the style CS scissors are just as good, and it is a new tool.I have all the tools mentioned by the OP, apart from the spirit >:( ... and I choose the Micra whenever I need scissors.
-
Vic Spirit: 2/5. Mostly due to their limited opening, short length and thick tips, they actually cut fine.
Vic Classic: 4/5. Drops a point for it's short length, but otherwise excellent.
LM Wave/Charge: 3/5. If I'm honest this is hard to quantify as I don't know why I'm not keen on them, but I'm just not.

LM Surge: No idea, never tried them. :D
LM Micra: 4/5. Really like them, but their rather broad blades can make them tricky for small detail work.
LM Juice: 3/5. I'm more of a fan of these than some folks are, comparatively long blades makes for quick cutting in paper and fabrics. Let down by a gritty feel and really soft backspring that doesn't pull the scissors back in place when you are putting them away.
LM style CS: 4/5. Same as the Micra.
91mm Vic: 5/5. Really the best all-round scissors to be found on a MT IMO.
-
@shamus said:
The only exception is the Micra, but it's an old tool .
The Micra is still in production.
Most Swiss Army knives are a lot older than the Micra. :D
Also the style CS scissors are just as good, and it is a new tool.I have all the tools mentioned by the OP, apart from the spirit >:( ... and I choose the Micra whenever I need scissors.
My point was that LM is not producing any new designs with good scissors... just the old reliable micra. ;)
Good point on the CS. But it seems to me the CS scissors are the same design as the micra scissors.
-
I am surprised nobody mentioned the Wenger Scissors too.
I allways think of them as more robust than Victorinox scissors because of their sturdier spring system.
Some people, though, do not like the "teeth" they have.
But, if you are cutting string or fishing line they may help. -
@dks said:
I am surprised nobody mentioned the Wenger Scissors too.I allways think of them as more robust than Victorinox scissors because of their sturdier spring system.
Some people, though, do not like the "teeth" they have.
But, if you are cutting string or fishing line they may help.They are a nice scissors but I use mine for paracord mostly and well the teeth aren't the best option.
-
91mm Vic: 5/5. Really the best all-round scissors to be found on a MT IMO.
I was under the impression that SwissTool and SwissTool Spirit had these scissors. I guess I was wrong.
I believe the Vic Huntsman II have these scissors. Yea they are really nice.
well I don't have a Swisstool but yes AFAIK they are exactly the same as the ones on the 91mm Victorinox SAKs (the Huntsman being a perfect example). However the Spirit's scissors are definitely not the same thing at all. :-\

-
@Gareth said:
well I don't have a Swisstool but yes AFAIK they are exactly the same as the ones on the 91mm Victorinox SAKs (the Huntsman being a perfect example).You're right I just checked the swisstool and 91mm sak scissors are the same size. Not interchanable as the base part is just a tad longer, but the scissor part is the same. I had always assumed the swisstool scissors were bigger since they 'felt' bigger.
The spirit scissors are odd, but still cut well and are precise. You can actually cut slightly tougher materials with them as you get more force albeit on a smaller cutting length.
-
I've handled mainly the following different scissors types, with my personal opinions on each one:
-
VICs 91mm - the best, good for precise cut and some strength can also be applied - 5/5
-
VICs 58mm - second best imo, are precise, but small and only suitable for light cuts - 4/5
-
Wengers 85mm - can't give a precise cut, but can cut thick stuff, eg cardboard or several pages at once of phone lists - 4/5
-
LM PS4 / Style PS - they... work, but aren't precise, aren't ergonomic, and for being small are only suitable for light cuts - 1/5
-
LM Charge/Wave - the same considerations as the PS4 ones, but they're a little bigger - 2/5
-
LM Surge - big and heavy, suitable to apply pressure and cut thick things, however not good for precise cut - 3/5
All the above scissors can easily cut standard paper. Where I note differences is on cutting very thin layers of something (eg. plastic) or flexible but resistance stuff (eg. gauze). I always have an hard time doing it with the LM versions: they tend to bend the material, instead of cutting it.
-
-
My views on this:
- 91mm Vic- very precise, can cut well through many different materials. 5/5
- 74mm Vic- a bit bigger than the 58mm, and really my most used scissors, as my Executive is always on me. 4/5 mostly for the size.
- Micra- Not as precise as the Vic, but a decent pair of scissors. A bit on the thick side. 3.5/5
- Juice S2 - Gritty, not precise, kind of a pain to use honestly. Weak backspring makes for a mushy feel to opening and closing. 2/5
New to me- Wenger 85mm. I just picked up an Evogrip S18, but I've only had it for about an hour, and haven't had a chance to try out the scissors yet. :) I do like the spring setup better than the leaf spring on the Vics though.
-
The wenger I have the lower portion of the scissors moves as you cut and it drives me nuts. The spring is nice, but I wish they could have made it work so the tip isnt bobbing up and down as you cut. If it wasnt for that, I'd rank them higher.
-
Always been a fan of the Swisstool/SAK scissors. You just can't go wrong with them.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login