Rank 'em scissors!
-
@Gareth said:
well I don't have a Swisstool but yes AFAIK they are exactly the same as the ones on the 91mm Victorinox SAKs (the Huntsman being a perfect example).You're right I just checked the swisstool and 91mm sak scissors are the same size. Not interchanable as the base part is just a tad longer, but the scissor part is the same. I had always assumed the swisstool scissors were bigger since they 'felt' bigger.
The spirit scissors are odd, but still cut well and are precise. You can actually cut slightly tougher materials with them as you get more force albeit on a smaller cutting length.
-
I've handled mainly the following different scissors types, with my personal opinions on each one:
-
VICs 91mm - the best, good for precise cut and some strength can also be applied - 5/5
-
VICs 58mm - second best imo, are precise, but small and only suitable for light cuts - 4/5
-
Wengers 85mm - can't give a precise cut, but can cut thick stuff, eg cardboard or several pages at once of phone lists - 4/5
-
LM PS4 / Style PS - they... work, but aren't precise, aren't ergonomic, and for being small are only suitable for light cuts - 1/5
-
LM Charge/Wave - the same considerations as the PS4 ones, but they're a little bigger - 2/5
-
LM Surge - big and heavy, suitable to apply pressure and cut thick things, however not good for precise cut - 3/5
All the above scissors can easily cut standard paper. Where I note differences is on cutting very thin layers of something (eg. plastic) or flexible but resistance stuff (eg. gauze). I always have an hard time doing it with the LM versions: they tend to bend the material, instead of cutting it.
-
-
My views on this:
- 91mm Vic- very precise, can cut well through many different materials. 5/5
- 74mm Vic- a bit bigger than the 58mm, and really my most used scissors, as my Executive is always on me. 4/5 mostly for the size.
- Micra- Not as precise as the Vic, but a decent pair of scissors. A bit on the thick side. 3.5/5
- Juice S2 - Gritty, not precise, kind of a pain to use honestly. Weak backspring makes for a mushy feel to opening and closing. 2/5
New to me- Wenger 85mm. I just picked up an Evogrip S18, but I've only had it for about an hour, and haven't had a chance to try out the scissors yet. :) I do like the spring setup better than the leaf spring on the Vics though.
-
The wenger I have the lower portion of the scissors moves as you cut and it drives me nuts. The spring is nice, but I wish they could have made it work so the tip isnt bobbing up and down as you cut. If it wasnt for that, I'd rank them higher.
-
Always been a fan of the Swisstool/SAK scissors. You just can't go wrong with them.
-
i kinda prefer wenger scissors so i'd rate ' em 4/5.
vic classic: 3/5
-
I don't understand the Juice scissor bashing that goes on in here. I've owned a few Juices and have been very pleased with the scissors. I preform both heavy and light duty cutting with them and have no problems.
Someone here said that the Juice scissors don't hold up. I bought my <u>used</u> CS4 six years ago. I use the scissors daily and have never had to sharpen them. Because of some of the comments that appear in this forum I started to think that I might have just gotten used to them and that may not be as good as they were when I got them, but this recent experience proved to me that the Juice scissors hold up very well. While visiting my wife's family, her brother, brother in law and I were preparing fishing equipment. My six year old Juice SC4 was used quite a lot, especially scissors. When my brother in law picked up my juice to cut some braided line he said "wow these things are sharp".
I have never used large SAK scissors, but I do have a Vic Rambler and I can honestly say the I don't find the Vic scissors to be any better than Juice or PS4 scissors. The Vic scissors do look a little nicer, but that does not matter to me.
-
@MeadMaker said:
Someone here said that the Juice scissors don't hold up. I bought my <u>used</u> CS4 six years ago. I use the scissors daily and have never had to sharpen them. Because of some of the comments that appear in this forum I started to think that I might have just gotten used to them and that may not be as good as they were when I got them, but this recent experience proved to me that the Juice scissors hold up very well.I EDC'd my juice S2 for about 6 months and loved it. The scissors started to losen up to the point where you have to push diagonally down on them while you use them to get the blades to meet nicely. The pivot is sloppy and loose now. Thats why I dont love them, and from reading others posts, im not alone. Maybe your older one was made better, mine sure wasnt. Too bad too, since other than that its a great tool. The scissors were still sharp mind you, its just the sloppy pivot that is the issue.
-
@MeadMaker said:
I don't understand the Juice scissor bashing that goes on in here. I've owned a few Juices and have been very pleased with the scissors. I preform both heavy and light duty cutting with them and have no problems.Someone here said that the Juice scissors don't hold up. I bought my <u>used</u> CS4 six years ago. I use the scissors daily and have never had to sharpen them. Because of some of the comments that appear in this forum I started to think that I might have just gotten used to them and that may not be as good as they were when I got them, but this recent experience proved to me that the Juice scissors hold up very well. While visiting my wife's family, her brother, brother in law and I were preparing fishing equipment. My six year old Juice SC4 was used quite a lot, especially scissors. When my brother in law picked up my juice to cut some braided line he said "wow these things are sharp".
I have never used large SAK scissors, but I do have a Vic Rambler and I can honestly say the I don't find the Vic scissors to be any better than Juice or PS4 scissors. The Vic scissors do look a little nicer, but that does not matter to me.
I agree!

-
My favorite scissors are the ones on the LM Micra.
I feel if the scissors can cut things like hair, fingernails, and clothing they're good enough for me. It's not too often that I find myself sitting around cutting construction paper.... usually I'm using them for fingernails, or using them to cut little squares out of a cotton t-shirt when making char-cloth... other than that, if I'm cutting something, it's with a knife.
The ONLY thing I've had a "little bit" of trouble cutting with scissors would have to be 550 paracord.... other than that, I like and can use them all without problems. That's just me though ;)I like the scissors on my Vic Huntsman, LM Wave, Style CS & PS, Wingman, and Juice S2... I've also used scissors on a SOG Powerlock... and never had problems with any of them except with paracord. Now, I ONLY use a knife for 550 cord.
-
@MeadMaker said:
I don't understand the Juice scissor bashing that goes on in here.
......I have never used large SAK scissorsThat explains it. :) :D
-
Out of the ones I have used or own:
91mm Vic SAK & SwissTool - 5/5 : Best out there... period.
LM Juice S2 - 4/5 : I scored this an bit higher than Gareth because they are big like the Vic 91mm's, the ones on my Juice are actually pretty tight and work really well for most things I cut.
LM Charge TTi/Wave (new)/Blast - 3/5 : Small.
LM Wingman - 2.5/5 : A bit floppy but fairly large and works well enough. Still new to it though...
SwissTool Spirit - 3/5 : Again, I scored this one a bit higher than Gareth because they are solid but small and don't open very wide but in use, it's OK.
Gerber MP400 - 2/5 : Small and chinsy.
Gerber Diesel - 2/5 : A bit bigger and chinsy.
SOG PowerLock - 2.5/5 : Meh, works I guess.
-
From reading this thread and others, some Juice scissors are tight, others are floppy. Again, it points to the shakiness of LM’s fit &finish department. Seriously, they need to work on that.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login