Seven Bids Retracted, 3 Items on eBay, Very Odd!!!
-
The Chinese identity fellow who is involved in these strange bidding retractions I sold to a couple of months back and had no problems. It was a minor amount of money and he said he is a student and is located in California right now. I did a Google search on that number he uses and found some kind of website in China that he evidently uses.
http://www.microsofttranslator.com/bv.aspx?from=&to=en&a=http://tieba.baidu.com/i/151496114/others
It seems he and the other one is only using that retracted bidding tactic on higher end SAK's.
As far as eBay goes, I have turned in folks for shill bidding, and other types of scams that I found out about over the years and never have I seen a member kicked off for it. Instead they change user identities.
-
@dodge_911 said:
That seller's got some more vintage stuff, for normal prices too : a Solo, a Seaman and a Woodsman...
I'm interested in the Seaman, but a little weary of buying now...The seller is great, and unless you see some strange bidding on the items you are interested in you should be OK. And I won't be bidding on those nice items you are eyeing so many would consider that a plus as well.
-
@ICanFixThat said:
The seller is great, and unless you see some strange bidding on the items you are interested in you should be OK. And I won't be bidding on those nice items you are eyeing so many would consider that a plus as well.That's so nice of you, but I'm kinda rethinking these knives.
I found a Cybertool 29 I really really really like/want, but the seller doesn't offer international shipping.
I'm trying to get him to use insured shipping or FedEx or something, so he doesn't need to worry about losing the shipment, so my budget's gonna go to that. So bid away![update]
Got a reply from the seller, he just forgot to add the international shipping. I just thought he wasn't willing to ship overseas. I've had replies from other sellers in that way. -
@ICanFixThat said:
Different bidders, but these two auctions look a little suspicious:VICTORINOX Alox RARE Pioneer Settler NIB - 0.8050.20 - $153.50
http://www.ebay.com/itm/18078163450VICTORINOX Alox RARE Pioneer Pruner NIB - 0.8060.20 - $153.50
http://www.ebay.com/itm/180781664239The high bidder in those auctions is legitimate - he bought a couple things I had for sale a while back. Nice guy in Norway with a serious alox addiction.
-
Jazz, Ya those auctions all seemed to go well, but those two knives went for some pretty good coin, I guess a couple collectors were missing those ones, or wanted these nice specimens.
--
Dodge, in the past I often had to contact sellers to see if they would ship overseas about 50/50 on the chance they would. I don't bother so much anymore as I hate bugging people, but it is worth checking if you really want something.
-
Man this really chaps my hide. I can't imagine that this is the only area this is happening in, either. I collect watches along with SAKs and I'd bet dollars to donuts that there's a lot of this going on in that arena as well.
I hope Ebay bans their entire IP.
-Al-
-
A variation: I've run into a couple of cases where I lost the bid, then within the hour was offered a second chance on the knife for my maximum bid because the "winner" had backed out. Makes you wonder if some dealer was using a shill to run up the price, then canceling his bid.
Karl
-
This happens regularly and is generally legit.
Sometimes the seller has two of the same items and can sell them both this way, by selling to the highest bidder and to the 2nd, 3rd highest too, for the amount they bid.
The funny think is that the highest bidder ends up paying more than the other, lower bidders, for the same item, so he is not actually a "winner"
-
The same buyer 3***3 is still active and bids also at the same items I want.
I have mail contact with the seller and sent him a link to this topic.
He is worried now and thinks he was scammed before because 3 of
his items are sold to cheap at this same guy.
He don't know or can't see if this was happend by retractions.
That buyer does not use the trick always, some are regular biddings.
The 3 biddings he won from these seller are 3 alox burgnard SAK's.
180767496020, 180767496622, 180767497096.
Did some one here lost this biddings?This seller sold yesterday at ebay one Farmer with bail for $411.00
and one Settler for $237.00, but these were regular biddings.
I won yesterday from him an red Rancher without keyring for an nice bid.
This seller has many nice alox items for sale I think but now 33 steps
in I will not bid against him.
Last week 33 was not bidding, but now at the new listed items he bids at all.
The seller is 'cpasion' and sells new/old alox SAK's. -
No reason to worry unless you see another bidder below his max bid and the bid is exceeding item value before the end of the auction. Otherwise they are not able to keep legitiment buyers from bidding. The buyer was not scamming every sale... and I'm not sure if he has done any more since his scam was uncovered, his buddy may have had some restrictions placed his bid retractions.
-
I also contacted the seller: (cpasion), about this for the 2 ebay users.
Quote from: cpasion
Dear armèe-suisse,
All bids by 13817224310 cancelled. I have also blocked 13817224310 and special_justicker from further bids.
- cpasion
-
Quote from: Chris Pasion
Guys:
Thanks for the heads up on this scam. I have canceled all bids by 13817224310 on my current auctions and have blocked this user and the other user special_justicker from any further bidding on my auctions. This of course will only work until they change user id's and start all over again.
Anyway, please post this information on the forum because my reputation is everything to me and I'm sickened by this practice. By the way the fellow from Norway is my best customer. He is 100% legit and a very nice person to deal with. He does bid high, and as a seller I appreciate that, but as a buyer I can see how that is sometimes hard trying to beat him.
Take care, happy bidding, and please pass this along to anyone concerned.
Thanks.
-
That's good news.
Also nice how members from this forum works on it to
protect others from this kind of scamming.
-
Caught in the act
Quote from: Chris Pasion
OK, here are some snippets of my back and forth conversation with the bidding bandit. I will continue to block this user. Feel free to post.
13817224310 has sent a message
Dear cpasion,
what's wrong with my bids? i have bought three knives from your store,never
have any problems, i did not buy your knives Recently just because they
were expensive,why now that you canceled my bid and do not allowed me bid
your items??!!-13817224310
Reply by: cpasion
I was made aware of bids of $200 to $400 on other victorinox auctions (not
necessarily mine) and 14 bid retractions by you indicating the wrong bid
amount. This kind of activity is very suspicious to me and I have been
made aware of high bids to discourage bidders then retractions made before
auctions end indicating the wrong amount was entered just so that the
bidder can win the auction at a reasonable price. This kind of bidding
practice hurts the seller and drives potential buyers away.... This is the
reasons for the bid cancelations. Yes you did pay for my auctions, but
this activity has made me very apprehensive and I want to avoid all
possible (direct or indirect) bidding activities that do not feel
right.-cpasion
Follow-up by: 13817224310
Dear cpasion,
i'm sorry but it will not happend to you~~,my friend and i just test this
kind of way ,but it does not work~,eBay had warned us about this, we will
not try it again~please allow me to bid your knives~~~ thank you very very
much~~~-13817224310
My response to this user:
I'm afraid for my auctions I cannot allow you to bid. Just seeing your user id 3***3 or 13817224310 or your friends user id on the bid list is driving potential bidders away. I was warned by several bidders on my past and present auctions, and they have told me they will not bid on my auctions if you or your friend are bidding. I'm just a seller trying to make the most that I can from my auctions and losing bidders is not what I have been an ebay seller since 1998 for. My feedback is 100% for a reason, and it is because I am 100% honest and sincere and allowing someone that practices activities that are not in line with my standards and practices is not a good way for me to be successful. Thanks for your 3 purchases, but that is all I'm willing to do.
-
It's a shame Ebay won't fix this and sellers have to resort to banning bidders.
-
Well done, armee-suisse.
-
Great News!! He cost me quite a bit of money. I'm glad there are some repercussions for his actions. Maybe he'll use his brain next time, but at his age I think he might already be a lost cause.
-
Haha, sounds like he got what he deserved! (from Chris Pasion at least) Nice work fellows!

-
suspicious?
Ok, so there were a few auctions I was keeping an eye on last night and the winner of one of the items appears to have a tendency to retract bids..
Bidder Information
Bidder: 3***3( 129)
Feedback: 100%Positive
Item description: Item Title: SWISS ARMY OFFICIER KNIFE - ARMÈE SUISSE VICTORINOX
Bids on this item: 2
** 30-Day Summary **
Total bids: 322
Items bid on: 213
Bid activity (%) with this seller: 11%
**Bid retractions: 16
Bid retractions (6 months): 17 **Maybe the whole process was legit... ???
Apologies if it is someone from here :DIn a couple of the items sold there the winning and 2nd highest bid differ a lot from what everybody else was bidding, though this might have just happened..
-
very strange...
you may make a wrong bid one or two times in a year, but 17 in 6 months...
ebay should be a little more protective with its sellers, because those are the ones who support the site.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login