Gerber Fan Club.
-
Here's another point worth looking at- everyone craps on the Crucial and rightly so, but the Crucial FAST is actually a good tool. While the ergonomics haven't changed, the assisted opening blade, better materials and longer drivers actually put the FAST version quite far ahead of the original Crucial.
Al- I agree and disagree with your points about quality control. I find that to be accurate for some of the low and mid point tools from Gerber, but I have rarely seen an MP600 or 400 with factory defects. Most of the time when I encounter a broken one it's because it was used for a job above it's abilities, which to me, speaks volumes about the inherent quality and feel that caused someone to think it could handle an extreme job. Now getting into the more involved tools, like the MP700, MP800, Diesel and Flik where they are somewhat more complex, yes, for those I will agree with your point, although I'm not certain the number of bad ones is as high as you are suggesting. I think you have been extremely "lucky" to have gotten as many bad ones as you have, although in your situation I'd probably feel much the same as you do.
Def
-
Yeah, I've seldom heard anything bad about the MP's quality - unsuitability of design maybe, but thats personal preference and like I say if it wasn't for my own preferences I'd own a lot more. All my disappointments were indeed on tools which had extra complexity, or where they were trying new concepts. I wasn't a fan of the Solstice for example - but it was bloody well made from what I could tell. My only experience of the MP400's and 600's is a DET which I tweaked a bit, but I got the feeling they'd be good dependable tools for many people
For the benefit of all I'd like to clarify that I've not been trying to "preach" here in any way, just vocalise my experience and share what would make a positive change to my own personal perception. I'll continue to keep trying Gerbers as they do keep pushing the boundaries and trying new concepts, but from my own perspective I would like to see a better success rate in quality. I generally have confidence in their designs, and I want to have the same confidence in manufacture when I try something new from them

Personally I see the delay in the release of the Balance as a step in the right direction. Something obviously wasn't ready for market - so they didn't let it out. Good on ya Gerber
I'm really looking forward to hearing what you find out on that at the show ;) -
The day anyone craps on someone else's actual hands on experience on this site is the day after I've folded up shop and started a Hello Kitty website.
When it comes to complexities in tools I think Gerber does indeed have some issues- the pawls on the Flik are a good example. They seem like an overly complex solution to a reasonably simple problem no one knew they had. This can lead not only to assembly issues but can even go as far back as component manufacturing issues since I believe Gerber contracts these out. If they were made in house by people who were on the process from start to finish I think we'd see a marked difference in not only the simplicity but also the reliability of these tools.
That makes the frustrating sometimes, but not bad- I love my Flik, despite it occasionally locking up on me.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
The day anyone craps on someone else's actual hands on experience on this site is the day after I've folded up shop and started a Hello Kitty website.:D
The pawls seem such a ridiculously easy issue to fix too. I'm sure making them from a one piece construction rather than two stacked pieces would greatly improve it - and make assembly easier and quicker to boot. Aside from that, I actually like the fact they added a feature to widen the grip slightly - when it works it does make the tool better to use in my mind.
An easier way altogether may have been to make the channels along which the plier heads slide to be slightly out of parallel. In other words theres room between the handles for the pliers when retracted, but not in the deployed position. As such when the mass of the heads moves towards deployment, the handles would be forced apart. This would mean that you would have to only hold one handle during the "flick" or the heads would not move - but in order to quickly deploy the Flik heads (slide forward and engage pawls in one move) you have to do the same thing anyway. The Spidie-drop style move by depressing the buttons and flicking the tool down away from the pliers would work too with less chance of letting go of the tool and smacking Granny in the face with it. :D :D There are a couple of minor tweaks you would need to do for this to work smoothly (slightly crown radius the seating inside the channel to compensate for changes in presentation angle on the two positions for one), but still simpler than the big bag of bits I sent to Metropolicity :D :D
... but at least they tried >:D
... and I think I'm still the Forum's biggest fan of the MP700 :D
... and as soon as a way of replacing the Octane blade with scissors is figured out I'm having one of those too

... put me down as a "tormented" fan :P
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Here's another point worth looking at- everyone craps on the Crucial and rightly so, but the Crucial FAST is actually a good tool. While the ergonomics haven't changed, the assisted opening blade, better materials and longer drivers actually put the FAST version quite far ahead of the original Crucial.Al- I agree and disagree with your points about quality control. I find that to be accurate for some of the low and mid point tools from Gerber, but I have rarely seen an MP600 or 400 with factory defects. Most of the time when I encounter a broken one it's because it was used for a job above it's abilities, which to me, speaks volumes about the inherent quality and feel that caused someone to think it could handle an extreme job. Now getting into the more involved tools, like the MP700, MP800, Diesel and Flik where they are somewhat more complex, yes, for those I will agree with your point, although I'm not certain the number of bad ones is as high as you are suggesting. I think you have been extremely "lucky" to have gotten as many bad ones as you have, although in your situation I'd probably feel much the same as you do.
Def
I have never handled a crucial FAST, but I'd like to. The only crucial I've touched is a base model at cabelas and I didn't even care to buy it even for fun. But like I said, the MP's I've handled lately have really impressed me.
-
I've posted pics of my Gerbers in other threads, but here's the latest bunch of keychain tools.. :)
-
Ok you all finally won me over and I ordered an MP600... my first gerber. I kept going back and forth and couldn't decide, so then I figured I should just buy it to remove the decision from my mind! lol. Might as well have at least one of each type of MT for the collection eh?
-
Much less stressful that way! :D
Def
-
I still have difficulty abiding by the whole Crucial handle geometry. It just doesn't click with my paws. That goes for the F.A.S.T as well.
With that said, I have handled quite a few Gerbers, and I agree with Def.
-
@Mercury said:
but I have to say I really miss my MP450. I would love to have it back.Oh, so now you want it back, eh? Make me an offer, but it'll cost ya. >:D :D I'll tell you, that MP450 which I got from Merc in a trade a while back has been the champ of my EDC tools. I have other LMs and Gerbers, but the MP450 has become my go-to. Is it perfect? Hell no. But backed up with a SAK like my Farmer or my Super Tinker, it's a workhorse of a tool, not too big, but not a worthless tiny thing either. The build quality is great, and it's a solid tool (rattly pliers notwithstanding-that's part of its charm). After Hurricane Irene, I was involved with clean up in the town I work in, which was badly hit. Flood waters and debris didn't stop it one bit. The Octane I've found to be a great light-duty tool as well. Like Grant, my only issue with it is the lack of locking notches in the closed position. I'll get around to grinding those in someday, but I'm lazy ::) . My MP600 hasn't seen much action, might have to take it to work tomorrow.....that or wait for my new Diesel to arrive in a week or so.
@Syph007 said:
Ok you all finally won me over and I ordered an MP600... my first gerber. I kept going back and forth and couldn't decide, so then I figured I should just buy it to remove the decision from my mind! lol. Might as well have at least one of each type of MT for the collection eh?Only one?
With that attitude how will your toolbox one day look like Chakos ? :) Congrats on the new toy! -
-
but I have to say I really miss my MP450. I would love to have it back.
Oh, so now you want it back, eh? Make me an offer, but it'll cost ya. >:D :D I'll tell you, that MP450 which I got from Merc in a trade a while back has been the champ of my EDC tools. I have other LMs and Gerbers, but the MP450 has become my go-to. Is it perfect? Hell no. But backed up with a SAK like my Farmer or my Super Tinker, it's a workhorse of a tool, not too big, but not a worthless tiny thing either. The build quality is great, and it's a solid tool (rattly pliers notwithstanding-that's part of its charm). After Hurricane Irene, I was involved with clean up in the town I work in, which was badly hit. Flood waters and debris didn't stop it one bit. The Octane I've found to be a great light-duty tool as well. Like Grant, my only issue with it is the lack of locking notches in the closed position. I'll get around to grinding those in someday, but I'm lazy ::) . My MP600 hasn't seen much action, might have to take it to work tomorrow.....that or wait for my new Diesel to arrive in a week or so.
You better be careful tom, I might take you up on that!
Glad it's doing you good. Would you perhaps be interested in trading that MP600 though?
-
Won't be the first time I was in a situation without a paddle Def, and I strongly suspect nor will it be the last. :D
-
I'm a big fan of the MP400 . Pictured here is the MP450 ( with file )

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
With that said, I have handled quite a few Gerbers, and I agree with Def.
You do realize that a statement like that may cause people to question your sanity, right?
Def
I have posted a few times in this thread already, I think gerber makes some very good tools. I am not sure I think they are the most innovative though, they introduce a lot of things but I am not sure they are all inovative :D I disagreed with Def :ahhh :ahhh Thanks Def! Just kidding but in all seriousness I think they are as innovative as leatherman.
-

I dunno; each of those boxes holds a Gerber Infinity Ultra-M with white LED (wish I had one or two red LED models); in addition to the one resting on top, I have two regular Infinity Ultras, too. My only Gerber at the moment is the FLiK, though I don't know if I'll keep it or not at the moment.
-
Good reading and pics, I really like the few Gerbers I've got, the MP600 BN is the most edc'd mt I have, always seem to come back to it and pair it up with a Gerber Shortcut, I do like sliding pliers


Very happy with this selection but yes I want more :ahhh

-
Good lineup BW...

-
-
Thanks chaps
notice the MPT plier tip, very slight stepped, not quite as bad as it may look.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login