Wenger SI debate
-
Oh and yes it is a swisschamp. :)
-
@Roadie said:
I could be wrong but i think the original Officers Knife was named in the Swiss language but the americans couldn't pronounce it very well so started calling them Swiss Army knives and the name stuck. I think i read it in my book i got from clavin i will go over it after my tea and try and find the quote.I was right.....of course :D :P

-
Ok here are a few pics of the SI...



And here's a pic that shows the hollow rivet...

And a close up of the mark...

-
Excellent pics of a very nice looking knife! Is it only a two layer tool?
-
Hmm Tim has some on his site, i could be quite tempted by them! I'll have to check my finances at the end of the month (got a few other purchases planed for this month) I am liking my Alox Farmer, are all the (fairly) modern ones Alox?
-
Nice knife you got there benner :)
-
@Roadie said:
Hmm Tim has some on his site, i could be quite tempted by them! I'll have to check my finances at the end of the month (got a few other purchases planed for this month) I am liking my Alox Farmer, are all the (fairly) modern ones Alox?I got mine from Tim. Bloody good price it was as well. :)
All modern farmers, soldiers and SI's are alox yes. (apart from the Wenger re-issue)
-
Everyone should have one of these older model Soldier or Pioneer series knives (Farmer is part of Pioneer series). I like them much more than the newer ones, because the tools aren't polished and rounded on the edges like the new ones. The screwdrivers on the old unpolished tools are sharper on the edges and grip screws with more authority.
I really like that old Soldat Ben.
-
I have no idea what this topic is about!
???However, I am leary of all this Wenger love? What's wrong with a Vic Sol?
-
@micky d said:
I really like that old Soldat Ben.
Looks as thought I may have been right then :D
So did we actually get to the bottom of this in the end? Does it mean soldat infantrie then ???
I suspect that "SI" does actually stand for "Soldat Infanterie", if the "SI" designation originates in the Swiss/German market. I think the "Standard Issue" label is probably only used in English speaking markets.
I've seen vintage Soldier knifes referred to by SAK collectors (Roger Remund included) as the "Soldat", as I did above. It makes sense that the model would be named "Infantry Soldier" or, in German, "Soldat Infanterie". However, the odd thing here is that Wenger is from a French-speaking canton, not German.
The short answer is that I don't know. :D Roger Remund (SwissBianco) would probably be the guy to ask.
-
That is what I am thinking and was trying to post a few pages back but couldn't seem to explain it too well. :)
I wonder what the bosses take of it is?
-
Actually, Soldat Infanterie isn't Geman, it's French, in keeping with Wenger's factory being in Delemont, a predominantly French section of Switzerland. SI can mean either that or Standard Issue to us English speaking folks, but it is more commonly known as the Soldat in most other places as that's what Wenger officially calls it, much the same way as we refer to the Victorinox version as the Soldier model.
As for what's wrong with the Vic Soldier, I'd say nothing. I prefer the Wenger SI because Wenger's main blade has more "belly" and the SI has a shackle or bail for lanyards, clips, or other tie down devices. The Victorinox however has a pointier awl.
Here's an article on SOSAKOnline that illustrates the differences:
Def
-
@Benner said:
That is what I am thinking and was trying to post a few pages back but couldn't seem to explain it too well. :)I wonder what the bosses take of it is?
I was having that problem too. The last time I posted about it I had been drinking and knew it would never come out right, so I didn't even try. I find that Monday mornings are much better for explaining things. :)
-
@Defender said:
Actually, Soldat Infanterie isn't Geman, it's French, in keeping with Wenger's factory being in Delemont, a predominantly French section of Switzerland.Actually, oddly enough, "Soldat Infanterie" is spelled the same way in French and German. I speak some French (used to be able to write fluently), and could tell the word "Infanterie" originated from the French language, but I had been looking at German translation books and, sure enough, they spell it the same way.
So, I guess my suspicion has been confirmed for the most part... (Thanks Def)
...and micky_d was correct again. ::)
-
:ahhh Of interest to me is that, while both the SI and Soldier are made to military specs they still have some differences as pointed out by Def. Although somewhat minor in some ways they are pretty significant. I agree with Def that, if you want to use a lanyard, etc. then the SI is the way to go. Personally I don't so I prefer the Vic but both are tanks and last a lifetime.
-
I was right :o, I guess if you post often enough, your bound to get something right :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



