Taylor Brands Booth
-
Pretty sad when a tool is so bad that you wouldn't give it to anyone for free
-
It is pretty sad that I bought one just to see how sad it was. I wasn't disappointed.
-
Pics or It didn't happen :P
-
See, I think the reason they issue them to the members of the RAN is in case they ever lose an anchor. This way they can tie all their "tough" tools together for a backup.
I imagine they are also good for line sinkers when deep sea fishing.
:D
-
Wow, that is really pathetic. My boss carries a made in the US Tough Tool, and he loves it. It certainly lives up to its name during all the use it sees both at the store and elsewhere. He's a volunteer fireman and the tool goes with him on calls. Good to know he's not carrying one of these new POS ones.
-
@Chako said:
They have been known to bend the tips of their knife blades and whatever long tools to fit it in there...if I recall a photo that was once posted on here. I do not recall who it was that posted it.THAT photo was pretty damning.
I think it was Bob (J-Sews) that posted the pictures of the knife blade being bent to fit into the handle.
@jerseydevil said:
Wow, that is really pathetic. My boss carries a made in the US Tough Tool, and he loves it. It certainly lives up to its name during all the use it sees both at the store and elsewhere. He's a volunteer fireman and the tool goes with him on calls. Good to know he's not carrying one of these new POS ones.I get phone calls and emails on a fairly regular basis from people who have questions about replacing multitools, what to get, where to get them and so on. I would say that at least 40% of the calls I get are from people who own old Tough Tools and either lost or broke them and want to know where they can get a replacement. I tell them all to buy something else as the Tough Tool that's available now is something they simply do not want. Just about all of them are very sad that they have to get something else.
My father is one of them- he has finally retired his Tough Tool with the broken blade in favor of his SOG Power Assist. He never did get along well with the Vic Spirit as it was too shiny and pretty to get dirty. I never thought I'd get him to give up that old Tough Tool. He still has it, but the Compound Leverage is better for his hands at his age.
Def
-
C'mon guys, you're being unfair. They weren't even supposed to be at SHOT, they just got confused on the way to the similar SH(something else)T show.
-
I doubt that- if you change the O to an I, it's still useful. Referring to anything from Taylor brands as such is an insult to fecal matter everywhere.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I doubt that- if you change the O to an I, it's still useful. Referring to anything from Taylor brands as such is an insult to fecal matter everywhere.Def
Yep, I doubt their tools can be used to grow vegetables!
-
Exactly- what use are a set of pliers that bend when you apply even moderate pressure?
Once again I issue my challenge to Taylor to prove me wrong. Send me any item from their lineup to test and I will put it alongside similar items in my collection and test them objectively to see if they are as bad as I am implying, or whether I am wrong. If I am wrong, I will happily issue a public apology for everything I have said about them.
At least a company like Sheffield, who could never be mistaken for a high quality producer can at least claim that while nothing special, at least their products work, and that they don't claim to be US tools, or even try to have them issued to military units. I would happily take a Sheffield before a Taylor Schrade.
Def
-
More seriously, it's no surprise to me that the tools don't work, and I think it's down to the design as much as the manufacturing quality.
Look how narrow the area between the pivot and the tool area is. This was ok on the originals, because of the high quality steel and high manufacturing standards, but even a minor drop in quality is more than enough to compromise the integrity of the tool. The construction standards of this tool could actually be equal to the Ganzos and other usable Chinese MTs (although I'm not saying it is), but that wouldn't be enough to make this design actually work.
-
Coulda, woulda, shoulda.
If you are going to put a tool on the market, especially if you are going to pitch it to governmental bean counters as a military tool you should test the thing. Failing that, I think they should be held accountable for any and all damages resulting from tool failure, meaning if any soldier or private individual is hurt or killed because this tool failed, they should be brought up on charges of negligence.
I can understand the odd accident resulting from the failure of a Leatherman, Victorinox, CRKT, Gerber or SOG tool because there are always going to be the odd defective one in the mix. But, to knowingly produce a tool that can't even handle basic tasks... well in my book that qualifies as fraud.
Def
-
..it shows how much weight should be placed on claims by manufacturers that their tool is "used by the military" or "approved for use by the military? etc. as if, only the best would be used by the military. :D
-
It would be, except equipment selections are often done by bean counters and not people who have ever been outdoors.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Coulda, woulda, shoulda.If you are going to put a tool on the market, especially if you are going to pitch it to governmental bean counters as a military tool you should test the thing. Failing that, I think they should be held accountable for any and all damages resulting from tool failure, meaning if any soldier or private individual is hurt or killed because this tool failed, they should be brought up on charges of negligence.
I can understand the odd accident resulting from the failure of a Leatherman, Victorinox, CRKT, Gerber or SOG tool because there are always going to be the odd defective one in the mix. But, to knowingly produce a tool that can't even handle basic tasks... well in my book that qualifies as fraud.
Def
Oh, I'm definitely not disputing that it's a POS that shouldn't be on their market, just speculating on why it's so bad. Producing a design that you can't make work with your manufacturing quality is just as bad as half-assing the production process on any tool.
-
Ha, I'm looking at a black tough tool right now, "happy" to say the knife tip isn't bent to make it fit into handle. :D thought I don't feel like paying $20 to see if the handle will bend.
-
It will. Bob's a strong bugger (machinists usually have strong hands from lifting and working with metal) but he really didn't put a lot of effort into it. I have no doubt he could have pretty well destroyed it if he'd had a mind to do it.
Which means, one of two things. Either all their tool line is like that in which case I wouldn't pay any kind of money for them, or they just happened to have a bad one at the show. Having a bad one at the show tells me these guys are so defective they don't even notice their product is crap, and that's a company I don't want to do business with either.
Def
-
have you seen the new navi tool. I am impressed with the locks and the bright l e d
-
compass mirror knife saw whistle are all very nice
my biggest complaint would be the scissors
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
