What do we have on the way?
-
50ft-Trad
I bought 3 knives from the Sheffield shop 12mths ago - all supposedly Sheffield made folding stainless steel army knives, 3 different versions. They were purchased as nostalgia pieces from childhood memories.
However, the brutal fact is they are all crap (sorry, don't like that word - but it fits).
I was so disgusted I drove over and swapped them for better versions. Honestly, myself and the shop manager went through the boxes in the store room trying to find a good example of each. Rubbish.As for Trevor, I don't think he's in the same league as Stan by a long way. From what I'm led to believe he simply assembles them, they're all just punched out blanks - though he's obviously trying to establish himself in that niche market ready for when Stan finally retires. If I were you I'd go onto ebay.com and source a genuine Wostenholm or the likes and get it shipped over. The modern fare here in Sheffield is an insult to the little mesters from that bygone era.
Sorry to be so negative, but I'd rather say it as it is.
-
I've found much of the pricier Wrights stuff and the gear Russell makes (premium line) at Taylors Eye to be quite good, though again it's stamped patterns dressed up nicely rather than the hand cut - make it up as you go, mind blowing perfection of Stan. The Rodgers modern stuff I've handled has been dire, Ibberson and Wostenholm can depend on the pattern/model. The guy at the Sheffield Shop (Paul I think it is) is a good bloke, and will let you try before you buy on everything he sells.
You're right the Mesters are long gone - but then I'm not in the affluence bracket for one of Stan's creations and neither are many other's, so in a way - it's hardly surprising.
-
Well it wasn't a complete disappointment, even though the guy had NO Sheffield knives with scissors. It wasn't a complete wasted journey though ...




It's not in bad nick actually, just needs a clean. Blades don't look like they've ever been sharpened ... but boy do they need it! Scale tools are both toothpicks, and not convinced they're originals. Walk and talk is a lot better than I expected, although the backspring tools don't have much snap to them and the awl is a real swine to get out. Hopefully a good clean and oil will improve matters.
All in all, I'm rather happy for £5 :D
... but the hunt is still on >:D -
"Affluence Bracket"
I can assure you I'm not in that bracket either, lol.
I saw Stan about 9mths ago - when I collected one of his knives.
He is still taking orders, honestly the man's a legend in his own lifetime - Have you read his book??
I take nothing from Stan - as you say he's in his eighties. BUT, and I hate to say this, there IS a marked difference between the knives he currently makes and those from several years ago. Don't misunderstand me they are fabulous when compared to most other knife makers, but when compared to his earlier work they just don't quite measure up.
If what you say is correct in that you had the opportunity to buy one of his knives but let it pass.......Ouch.
They are becoming rare to say the least. If you can get one, don't let it go.
As for the other makes you mentioned - I don't know enough about them to make an informed comment.
However, as good as Stans work is - the quality of Victorinox, to me anyway beats them hands down. I know they are not handmade, but in my view as I'm sure you'll agree Victorinox are simply just superb.
-
@tosh said:
"Affluence Bracket"I can assure you I'm not in that bracket either, lol.
I saw Stan about 9mths ago - when I collected one of his knives.
He is still taking orders, honestly the man's a legend in his own lifetime - Have you read his book??
I take nothing from Stan - as you say he's in his eighties. BUT, and I hate to say this, there IS a marked difference between the knives he currently makes and those from several years ago. Don't misunderstand me they are fabulous when compared to most other knife makers, but when compared to his earlier work they just don't quite measure up.
If what you say is correct in that you had the opportunity to buy one of his knives but let it pass.......Ouch.
They are becoming rare to say the least. If you can get one, don't let it go.
As for the other makes you mentioned - I don't know enough about them to make an informed comment.
However, as good as Stans work is - the quality of Victorinox, to me anyway beats them hands down. I know they are not handmade, but in my view as I'm sure you'll agree Victorinox are simply just superb.
I've only handled one of his older knives, and one of his newer ones. The one I turned down didn't blow me away like the other one did. It was Stan's name and stamp, but the feel didn't scream quality the way you'd expect from him. You're right, you can't knock Victorinox knives in the slightest, but the thing I like about a nice Sheffield knife (if you can find one) is it feels like a person made it, rather than a company. Not quite so sterile and uniform.
-
I know exactly what you mean.
I've hankered after a genuine Wostenholm for years, preferably two - one beat up with character and one As New.
By the way, the one you got today looks great, I would be proud to own that! - Is it the same "Richards" who still manufactures cutlery to this day. I actually went to school with his son...Ritchie.
-
@tosh said:
By the way, the one you got today looks great, I would be proud to own that! - Is it the same "Richards" who still manufactures cutlery to this day. I actually went to school with his son...Ritchie.Are you thinking Richardson? They still exist under the Amefa banner, but don't think Richards do

I have 2 single blade Barlow IXL's - clip blades. One is a rosewood bicentennial edition, the other a buffalo horn one.
OK, but a bit soft on the backspringJust found this online ...
Richards was founded in the 1930s by two German brothers whose names were actually Paul and Stefan Richartz. They came from Solingen in Germany (like sheffield a big cutlery manufacturing town) and they brought with them a skilled production engineer, Wilhelm Müller. The name of the firm was changed to Richards just before the Second World War. They mass-produced knives, scissors etc. which had the "lamp-post" trade mark. Their original factory was badly damaged in the war and in 1946 they moved to a new building at 55 Moore Street site - where Wickes is now. It was probably the largest cutlery-manufacturing firm in Sheffield, though the "traditional" cutlers tended to look down on them in view of their cheap, mass-produced output. My brother-in-law was caretaker there in the 1960s, by which time Müller was running the firm; I used to go with him on his rounds and I well remember the "rumblers" that lazarus referred to. Richards was bought out in 1977 by the Imperial Knife Company of the U.S.A. Richards closed in 1983 and the factory was demolished. Wilhelm Müller died aged 77 in 1982.
-
Sorry - You are quite correct..Doh!!
By the way, you heard from DeezNittles regarding the minibuck - I've just noticed you've put yourself down for one - me too for the other!!
But not yet had any response? How about you? -
There were TWO packages waiting for me when I got home from work today!

The RR Doctor's knife, the Remington mini toothpick, and the lanyards (bonus!) came from Ashley, and the stainless Leek was Parmenides' contribution to what has been a pointy week for me! You both rock!
-
@jerseydevil said:
There were TWO packages waiting for me when I got home from work today!The RR Doctor's knife, the Remington mini toothpick, and the lanyards (bonus!) came from Ashley, and the stainless Leek was Parmenides' contribution to what has been a pointy week for me! You both rock!

How's the snap on The Rough Rider Doctor? I have one too and there's a significant difference between the two blades, the smaller having a lot more snap/stronger backspring.
-
@enki_ck said:
How's the snap on The Rough Rider Doctor? I have one too and there's a significant difference between the two blades, the smaller having a lot more snap/stronger backspring.There is a definite difference. Like you said, the smaller blade does seem to have a stronger backspring. The large blade is easier to open, but it still opens and closes with a decent snap. I have a RR Congress that has a very lazy blade. The large blade on the Doc is MUCH snappier than that one. The f&f is pretty good, like my other Rough Riders. I like RRs, decent quality knife for the money. The Doctor is a new pattern for me to add to my ever-growing sipjoint collection
. -
I got (another) (Spare) BNIB NON CC BO PST on the way... :ahhh :D

-
-
Vic Compact, to replace the Climber+ swiped by a former coworker.
-
I got my Fenix E15 today, it's awesome!
-
Three left and one traded..

-
After a discussion on the gerber forum, realising I'd been think about one for two years, plus a couple of glasses of port, I ordered myself a Gerber Octane in red. Should be here in the next couple of days. :)
-
I have a Space Shuttle Master Craftsman on the way 8)

-
@Gareth said:
After a discussion on the gerber forum, realising I'd been think about one for two years, plus a couple of glasses of port, I ordered myself a Gerber Octane in red. Should be here in the next couple of days. :):D@Reinier said:
I have a Space Shuttle Master Craftsman on the way 8)
Thats very

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
