Serrated edges?
-
I have had both CRKT Neckolas models and I far prefer the serrated blade- but then I really only use it for kayaking.
For most jobs I prefer a plain edge as I find most serrated blades catch on things too much.
Def
-
Funny this came question up. Sunday night I BBQ some steak for the family and while cutting it with a good quality serrated steak knife that I had just sharpened on my SharpMaker, I was struggling with the cuts. So I pulled out my Buck Vantage Avid (13C26 Sanvic) non serrated and wow it sliced through the steak with ease. It was also recently sharpened on my SharpMaker. So I think I will find some steak knives that are not serrated.
While working on commercial fishing boats in Alaska I did cut a lot of line (rope). I used a serrated fixed blade Victorinox it worked well for the tasks. We did have some plain edged knives also that we mainly used for fish processing but did not use for cutting line as the serrated seam to work better. I did keep a "new" Victorinox attached to my rain gear for an emergency, such as being tangled in line and pulled overboard.
This was years ago before I knew much about knives so your slicing may vary. ;) -
OK, so I may not carry and use a serrated blade every day but I have found some good use for them. I was under the house last year doing some emergency plumbing with flexible but hard plastic lines about 20mm's thick. I had my Vic SwissTool with me and at first I tried the plain edge blade. It worked OK but it was not easy to slice through it. I flipped out the serrated blade on the same SwissTool and Wow! it cut through like butter. Since I had so much to do and many cuts to make I switched out for a 111mm knife with serrated blade for the rest of the work.

-
I prefer a half and half blade, although i dont use the serrations much i like to have them in case,although i do prefer a seperate serated blade for the longer stroke as some are too short to be much use, i like to have all types of saws on a MT when possible, i was going to order the half serrated blade for my pt and remove the full serrated one but decided to stick to a full blade and full serrated, but on a larger knife i dont mind :D thew got there in the end

-
I can appreciate the benefits of serrations in certain scenarios, but it's very rare I need them. Combo edged blades never seem to have serrations in the right place either. The main things I'll use a blade for are scoring things open so a PE tip works best, or sharpening a pencil so PE near the pivot is best.
If I was wanting serrations, I'd probably want them central on the blade on task thats used the full cutting length but not just one end of the blade. This is why I try to carry a PE blade for most jobs, then a second blade with serrations if I feel I might need them
-
@50ft-trad said:
I can appreciate the benefits of serrations in certain scenarios, but it's very rare I need them. Combo edged blades never seem to have serrations in the right place either. The main things I'll use a blade for are scoring things open so a PE tip works best, or sharpening a pencil so PE near the pivot is best.If I was wanting serrations, I'd probably want them central on the blade on task thats used the full cutting length but not just one end of the blade. This is why I try to carry a PE blade for most jobs, then a second blade with serrations if I feel I might need them
I was like this when i got the new soldier
as at the front, but actually its a good place, although would make this a hard blade to use for skinning type jobs, not that i do this :D but you never know ;) -
Every day I use my table knives!

Serrated edges on enamel last longer.
Good thing of course sice they would be a pain to sharpen...Some people I know prefer serrated blades for hard cured meat.
Butchers of course, that cut a lot of such meat, use plain edged knives.
Also for crusty bread; the serrations dig through the crust easily. -
I want to say serrated edges stay sharper longer anyways since there are multiple edges sharing the cutting. Also even when dull a serrated can still 'saw' through material. Thanks DKS now I'm hungry for steak and crusty bread! :p
Stay multi my friends
-
Oddly enough, used the Spirit's peanut butter blade for the first time today. Actually left the house without a slippie this morning, but quite glad I had serrations anyway. Received a large pallet of forgings at work earlier that was heavily wrapped in clingfilm. Spirit blade went through it like it wasn't there.
Normally I'd have my modified Wave handy, but that's at home in need of a serious clean up
-
...adding to Beerplumbers post, when cutting on a plate the teeth touch the plate but the actual edge between them does not since it is higher up, thus it does not get dulled by the harder enamel.
-
cheers for all the replies chaps. I can see where some of these situations would certainly be more easily done with a serrated blade, the plastic lines and heavy rope especially. However I was cutting up some seriously heavy duty cardboard this morning and decided to try both the PE and SE blade on my Supertool 200 and, quite honestly, the sharp PE blade was less work.

Long and short of it is that they're not something that I have any particular need for on a regular basis I guess. :)
-
being British I've decide to add a poll. :D
-
well, I said 4 as it was multitool specific and I do not cut my porkchop with a multitool...
I am too classy for that! ::) -
I'm with 50ft on this one... they have their uses, but I don't need one all that often.
That said, I did buy myself a Byrd Wings last fall, and it's a great knife for the money. I keep it on the waist belt of my hiking pack as a general hiking/camping utility knife. I like having the serrated blade for the rare occasion I might need to cut something like rope or straps. And for hiking and camping, I find having a good beater/utility blade to be highly useful. I pair it up with my WorkChamp which gets used for other types of stuff around camp, and eating, etc. Of course I'd never use my WC for stuff I use my Wings for, and vice versa.
The absolute worst though, are combo edges. I despise them. Unless you've got a really big blade, like on the Kabar tantos, CE blades never give you enough of either type of edge to be genuinely useful IMO.
-
Kitchen chefs know it all, serrated blades are good when the shell is harder than the inside: bread, tomato, melon and water melon, croissant :P, some cakes, pineapple, you name it.
For general materials I find the plain edge more appropriate.
-
I'd have to go with a combo edge if the tool only had one blade, ideally a Vic combo like the Spirit and OH Tracker with the serrations towards the tip but if it was a non folding fixed blade knife I'd go with a plain edge.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login