GEC knives; good for the money
-
As I said I actually like the knife now.
I think the problem is the expectations you have reading Bladerelated forums in which GEC, especially the "posh" Northfield brand, are described as perfect in every way, I call it "the Sebenza effect :D ", whereas they are good solid knives but not created by some divine force.I have not been able to find anything about their finish not being 100% perfect, so I expected perfection.

-
dks,
It is the expectation, for many when they get them they are absolutely perfect.....but on any given level of inspection. How one get's into thoroughly going over F&F is different than another. As I said earlier, on close enough scrutiny I could probably find any number of faults with a majority of the knives I own. But on a simple in-hand inspection as long as there are no gaps in fit, backsprings rest as they should and aren't stepped, grinds are even and clean, blades are sharp, backsprings aren't lazy, and the finish is how it should be.....they are perfect.
It's funny that this should come up as there is a dealer I know of that has had similar issues pop up from purchases, he has a return policy that is 100% for any reason.....and he has seen a number of returns of GEC's that have no QC issues or similar. Just knives being sent back as they didn't meet with customers expectations. He blogs about it here: http://blog.tsaknives.com/2012/01/06/time-for-a-rant.aspx
You made a good point about what you call the "Sebenza effect", it is like that. Not having had one and to hear what most others think of them, the expectations are high for a truely sublime piece of art. They are in their own right, works of art.......for what they are and how they are made at their price point the only way to get better is several hundred dollars above what they are going for and a waiting list.
2xTap
-
I think his blog entry should be a "sticky" in every traditional/slipjoint knife forum! :D
I agree that, despite what people think, these knives are quite cheap, for what you get.
Similar products from most makers would be more expensive.
Even RR posh models are around $30, so a GEC product from $70 upwards is not bad. -
Well I have a 73 and what has impressed me has been the overall quality and the fact that so much of it was done by hand...I carry it from time to time at work and on weekends and use it..She is far from a safe queen and seems to be developing a nice patina...I for one like the stiff springs...I wish there were more Pocket Knife Companies like GEC...I have owned a couple of Rough Riders and what 2XTap says is true...They are great for what they are,but something tells me that 20-30 years from now with a modicum of care my GEC will be still at it in my Pocket where the Rough Rider has gone by the wayside or fallen apart from use
Dtrain
-
If you do use it as a beater,you will learn to love that 1095 carbon steel.

-
I am currently trying to make/get some sort of pouch to keep it in so that I can carry it in my pocket, as a user, though I do not really like 1095 for cutting anything that I will eat; and usually I cut everything with my pocket knives, food, sticks, plastic bags....
My Moras and Marttiinis are 1095 Carbon steel and I am quite happy with them, though I do not cut food with them.As for the longevity of RR knives and really of GEC knives we can not tell as they both have not been around for that many years. People tend to forget that GEC is a new company too.
Swiss army knives have been produced mainly with machines for decades and they seem to last fine if not abused for several decades, a century even, so RR knives could well last longer than people expect them too. Theoretically the GEC should outlive them, but it all depends on the use of the kinife. I am sure my safe queens can easily survive 30+ years. :D
I have a cheap Chinese buck 110 lookalike which is over 20 years old and still going strong and that was not good quality or expensive. -
@dks said:
As for the longevity of RR knives and really of GEC knives we can not tell as they both have not been around for that many years. People tend to forget that GEC is a new company too.Swiss army knives have been produced mainly with machines for decades and they seem to last fine if not abused for several decades, a century even, so RR knives could well last longer than people expect them too. Theoretically the GEC should outlive them, but it all depends on the use of the kinife. I am sure my safe queens can easily survive 30+ years. :D
I have a cheap Chinese buck 110 lookalike which is over 20 years old and still going strong and that was not good quality or expensive.True, to an extent. The thing is with GEC is that they came into being, and are being built by, people who have been doing this a long time. And doing it in a very proven method using nothing but the finest materials......same way it was done in the past, and those knives make up the foundation of a large portion of collections out there now. We already know how long folding knives built this way can last.
With RR, they are built in a similar fashion to many other imports that have a history of falling apart. Granted, many of these are not built to the level of RR's, for they do have a more refined way of doing it. But where GEC welds, solders, and pins......RR glues. They are by their very nature not built for longevity. We know the quality of the steel and other materials that goes into GEC's, and we can see how they are built (go to GEC's website, every couple of weeks they post up new pictures of their recent builds, in shop pics of their construction.) With RR's we only know what they say in descriptions, as well as what little we glean from their importers. Most of what we know of them comes from owners, users, and those that work on a rehandle/customize RR's. And while RR has picked up a following for inexpensive quality there is a reason they are still not regarded in the same way a Case, Queen, GEC, CSC, Hen & Rooster, Boker, and others are.
There is also a reason why Rough Riders will never gain any collector value. A Rough Rider bought today will gain little if any value in 20 years time. I have GEC's that are a few years old right now that have already gone for twice their original cost recently.
Rough Riders are good knives, for what they are. I am a fan of them too. Been buying them since they first popped up through SMKW's. The quality of the build for the price is great, but I understand exactly what they are and don't expect anything beyond that. As to your mention of SAK's and their construction, yes.....they are built in a more modern automated fashion but their's is designed around many decades long knowledge. They have been doing it a long time and while they might be more automated they have done so around the premise of making more at the same quality. And they haven't skimped on construction of critical parts for the sake of making more money.
But even with them......ask yourself, how many people you know still have, or carry and use, their fathers, uncles, grandfathers chinese knock off or SAK from when they themselves were young? I know alot of of knife users and collectors and I know of none that have any. But I know a ton that still have their fathers, uncles, grandfathers pocketknives and many still use them and carry them. Hell, I have my Dad's old pocket knife from when he was in his teens.......American made Camillus from the 60's. And my wife has her grandfathers American made Schrade Old Timer stockman. Both are well worn but still going strong.
2xTap
-
I have GEC's that are a few years old right now that have already gone for twice their original cost recently.
2xTap
...and there I was, thinking of using mine. Now I am tempted to keep it as a safe Queen :D
First, don't expect all of them to do that. Some are more rare and done in smaller numbers, and in unique patterns, than others (I have GEC's done in limits of only 9 produced, one of only 14, and one that only 15 were made). GEC's are built to use.....so if that is what you got it for then by all means put it in your EDC rotation.
2xTap
-
I got another GEC, a Stag Conductor in 440C.

I wanted something reasonably sized, with normal pull and in SS and the Conductor was all that. (slim, single spring)




It arrived today from oldhundredcollectibles, with a free pouch which is quite useful for protecting a nice knife.

The knife was smaller than I expected and the stag seems varnished.

The pull is very good on both blades.I chose this knife, from pictures of several, because it had decent looking stag.
Problems?
There seems to be a suspicious line in the handles that could be a crack though I have no way to verify how deep it is. It does not open up if I push it with my nail and I am not about to stick a screwdriver in it…

Also one side of the bolsters has a minor dent, where the makers tried to push it down to be more flash with the stag.

Finally some of the gaps are a bit bigger than you would expect for the price/name of this GEC knife.

I intend to make this knife a user, which is why I asked for the pouch.

Some comparison pictures:


-
I also noticed that the shield pin was sticking out inside the body of the knife.
It does not seem to rub onto anything yet...
I do not know if this is common or not with pinned shields, but it is not visible in such a way in the Northfield trapper knife.

-
seeing a renewed interest in the stockmans, here is a bump, for fun.
-
-
@hiraethus said:

L-R: #14 Lick Creek boys knife, #66 Calf Roper, #15 Crown Lifter, #71 Bullnose, #47 Hayn' helperYou've got pretty good taste haven't you... you're alright...

Calf Roper and Crown Lifter especially... especially the Crown Lifter!
-
I watched a factory tour video, they were never on my radar before then, but they sure are now.......
What stunned me were the prices, these are expensive little knives........way out of my price range, not criticizing their prices but I am a little surprised they "get away with it".
Maybe someday I can find a 2nd hand one I can afford.......but I don't want one.......I want most of them

So that answers how&why they get away with it

-
@Fuzzbucket said:
You've got pretty good taste haven't you... you're alright...
Calf Roper and Crown Lifter especially... especially the Crown Lifter!
Thanks Fuzzy.

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
a little surprised they "get away with it".They are very good quality and reasonable value for money - about 50% more than an equivalent Case, and better finished. What's most impressive is the way they've cultivated the market, releasing what amounts to limited edition knives to a growing group of trad enthusiasts. They might only make a few hundred of a particular pattern - or a few dozen of an SFO (Special Factory Order) and then not make any more of that type for several years. Their production totals are interesting: http://greateasterncutlery.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/2016-PRODUCTION-TOTALS.pdf for example.
-
Frankly, I've owned three or four GECs, and the blade play varied between “noticeable” to “incredibly annoying”. None of them was what I would call without play. They are very pretty knives, but not for me. What GEC cares about is not the same as I care about. I have better experience with e.g. Case. Just wanted to add an YMMV to the other voices here.
-
@Steinar said:
What GEC cares about is not the same as I care about.Agree 100%. I think you hit the nail on the head.
I have a few GECs, and would say for me, I have about a 95% satisfaction rate. The few faults could be repaired by me (2nd grinds, sharpness out of the box), or were not really that big enough of a deal for me to send the knife back (spring tension, jigging pattern burn outs, blade rub). There was a time when new out of the box a GEC would barely cut paper and you had to sharpen it yourself. If someone came to GEC out of precision made modern flippers, a lot of that would be unacceptable.
When they first started up, people were hungry for tight, high quality slipjoints. There was much maligning Case and nostalgia for the good old days, and along came GEC with superior product. I think a lot of the hype was well deserved, but some of it also was honeymoon sentiment. To expect perfection from anything is a fool's errand.
As a side note, I think Case and Queen have upped their game a bit since GEC came out.
Anyway, it's important to keep a scope to what you expect from a knife/purchase. I don't have a 95% satisfaction rate from many other companies or brands. A good amount of the criticism given to pocketknives is so far off my radar that a negative YouTube review is meaningless to me, other than to see the knife in hand.
-
Queen? the understanding was that they only upped their prices, before closing shop...
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
