Survival Knives
-
Looks like I have opened a good can of worms with this one! It seems that while we all disagree on the details, we are all more or less on the same page though.
I will say that if the SHTF, someone please keep an eye on Chako as I doubt he's going to survive on his own very long relying on the Navitool! :P
Def
-
Great thread.
The funny thing about survival situations is that you can only prepare for so much. I feel that a multitool is much more likely to provide utility than a survival knife is. Ultimately it depends on the survival scenario as to what type of knife or tool will be most useful.
The tool you have with you will always be the most useful;I always have a multi-tool and don't own a survival knife.
I love Les Stroud's general respect for his environment. The premise behind his show is that each episode is a scenario in which he uses the materials he would likely have with him. and I find that the fact that he most often uses a multi-tool is realistic for me.
Bear Gryll's just rubs me the wrong way how he seem very cavalier about his situation and the environment around him.
When the SHTF you never know what you will actaully have with you so I constantly practice situational awareness, and constantly imagine, research and train to be able to make anything a survival tool.
-
It has a good compass, fire capabilities, and some sharp and pointy bits. The Navitool isn't all that bad. :D
-
The one think that bugs me about all the 'pros' with their survival knives is that thy seem to think that battening through wood is a must. Come on. First of all, where do these hardcore guys find all this nicely sawed logs to baton in the woods anyway anyway. The first time I saw someone do this I thought they were crazy. A good axe can do a hell of a lot of tasks, from tree felling, carving, game cleaning. I LOVE my granfors bruks small forest axe. For a cheaper option Estwings will last a lifetime.
Somewhat regional though an axe in Canada is as to a machete in the jungle.
I still want to try one of these as a modern Rambo style knife.. its one piece but hollow. It will probably suck, but I need to get one to know for sure.
http://www.knifecenter.com/item/SCHF1SM/schrade-extreme-survival-special-forces-5
-
I have to agree about the axe (or hatchet). Most anything can be done with an axe. Can't say the same for a multitool or a rifle. When push comes to shove, I'd also want a tough knife with me if at all possible.
I've read some positive reports about that Schrade knife, but I'd like to get my hands on one before I part with cash. I've owned a couple of the '80's hollow handle paper weights and don't want to waste any more money on what could be more of the same junk.
Dave
Sent from my iPad2 using Tapatalk
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Bob and I discussed this at SHOT after looking at the Les Stroud knives and I kept meaning to get everyone else's thoughts on it. The recent Opinel survival knife thread has reminded me about it, so here goes.When we looked at the Les Stroud knives at the show we saw that basically the knives weren't anything special (as expected) but they did have lots of gadgets attached to the sheaths like sharpeners, reflectors and places to wrap lots of paracord. In a survival situation, all of these would be handy, but then so would a Howard Johnson's. ::)
Survival, in my mind falls into two categories- lost in the woods and SHTF situations. If you are lost in the woods, I can't help but feel that your cell phone or a SPOT type GPS transmitter is your best friend, and probably a lot more useful than a knife. If you are lost in the woods, you probably want to be found, and you could use your knife to chop up some wood and build a signal fire and perhaps be rescued when a passing aircraft notices you, or you can press the panic button or dial 911 on your cell phone and help comes right to you. There are good reasons to have a knife, but if I had to choose one, I'd choose the phone or GPS emergency transmitter.
In a SHTF (Smurf Hits The Fan) type situation where you are on your own and there's no help in sight a knife could certainly be handy as well, but I think I would be more inclined to try and scrounge whatever I could. While I would appreciate a knife, it would be one of several dozen items I would want to secure, and perhaps not the highest priority item on the list- firearms, ammunition, food and clean water would top my list, although a knife would be a very close second tier need to the above items. Naturally a good knife would be important, and could perhaps aid in getting some of the above items, but they are also a lot easier to find, whether it be a kitchen knife or a decent sharp rock. Despite what Captain Kirk managed to do while being chased by a giant lizard man, it's somewhat difficult to build a gun from nothing.
In short, much like the survival knife craze of the 80's, the knife is a handy tool but is simply not what survival is about, no matter who's name is on it or how much paracord it has wrapped around it, the survival is in the person, not the tool. Because of this, I really don't care for so called survival knives simply because people will buy them and think they are prepared- they are not. The knife is a valuable part of survival, no matter the situation, but it it only a part.
Personally I think it's going to be easy to locate a knife in a SHTF type situation as there are going to be a lot of yuppie corpses clutching some really neat knives lying around.
Def
Whilst I agree with what you've written, I do feel you could have been a tad more tactful, subtle shall we say?? (Hmm, slander springs to mind).
But, on the whole I agree. Survival knives are just too limiting. Given the choice I'd pick this everytime obviously paired with my MT too.
-
@Biru said:
I've got an old book from the 70's on survival. It's by an Australian fellow named Graves. Quite a thorough book with rope weaving, lacing branches and even how to build mud houses. It's questionable how much of it would pertain to my area, but as a kid I thought it a real find. I found the part about eating cats a bit too much, but hey, when in Melbourne...Anyway, he recommends eschewing a knife or axe for a machete for survival use. I carry one in my emergency bag in my car. God help me if a policeman ever has need to search my vehicle!

Lets see how strong my Google foo is.... was it Richard H graves. Bushcraft: A Serious guide to camping and Survival.
Whilst i understand the machete over axe school of thought, small fixed blades like the becker Bk11, and izula (or even smaller CRKT RSK/ Becker remora) really make not paring a knife silly.
Ï'm hoping the 12"ontario cutlass/machete is the last machete i'll ever buy that meets my real requirements in form and function... But so far the CS Spetznav shovel seems a much better tool for the blade sensitive thoughtless blanket attitudes :D
-
You can tell Def, I am a big fan and user of the humble brick called the Navitool.
:DThis is my user...

I have these residing in my collection, and my user above.

-
This is turning into a great thread guys! And I agree with boss-man; we all seem to have slightly different interpretations and preferences, but we're all thinking pretty much alike. It seems that a knife alone is one of the less useful things to have in a lost in the wood type of situation.
I would really love to have GB small forest axe... it's at the top of my wish list for camping gear, but I know my wife would kill me for buying one. She just wouldn't understand why I'd need to spend $100+ for what would seem to her be nothing more than an overgrown hatchet...

I've been meaning to get Cody's book, but just never had a chance really. The outdoors skills classes I've taken were taught by people who've done Cody's training as well. Lots of good info, and I like his approach of working with the environment instead of against it. I like that about Les too, but I have a big problem with the way he does his editing... I mean, do we need a cut scene every 20 or 30 seconds? I mean come on... that's just gonna give me a seizure fer cryin' out loud!
Anyway, great thread! Keep it comin'! :)
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
I would really love to have GB small forest axe... it's at the top of my wish list for camping gear, but I know my wife would kill me for buying one. She just wouldn't understand why I'd need to spend $100+ for what would seem to her be nothing more than an overgrown hatchet...
Well... you can shave with it! The first thing i did when i got it was shave hair off my arm... others said it came that sharp so I had to know. How manly is it to see your husband shaving with an axe before heading into work! LOL. Tell your wife that.
A huge tree came down in my backyard last year. I chopped the entire thing up small enough to put in leaf bags... that axe was just a pleasure to use, light but perfectly weighted. I was going through the 10 inch trunk of the tree so fast it was just a joy to use. LOVE IT. I do baby that axe though, i wont chop near the ground with it. I have a full size Estwing for dirtier work, the all metal full size, its good too altough I did manage to bend it once.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
I would really love to have GB small forest axe... it's at the top of my wish list for camping gear, but I know my wife would kill me for buying one. She just wouldn't understand why I'd need to spend $100+ for what would seem to her be nothing more than an overgrown hatchet...

Well... you can shave with it! The first thing i did when i got it was shave hair off my arm... others said it came that sharp so I had to know. How manly is it to see your husband shaving with an axe before heading into work! LOL. Tell your wife that.
A huge tree came down in my backyard last year. I chopped the entire thing up small enough to put in leaf bags... that axe was just a pleasure to use, light but perfectly weighted. I was going through the 10 inch trunk of the tree so fast it was just a joy to use. LOVE IT. I do baby that axe though, i wont chop near the ground with it. I have a full size Estwing for dirtier work, the all metal full size, its good too altough I did manage to bend it once.
Oh, I trust you, believe me! You're preaching to the choir here... I know my wife though and unless I saved up and paid for it myself I'd be in the dog house for quite a while. :o I have a regular Fiskars axe, a 28" chopper, that has been a great tool. I've put a good convex edge on it and it does everything I ask of it, but it's not something I'd want to stow in my pack for backpacking or the like. I don't think it would be well suited to use as a lost in the woods kind of tool either. And, I know that having a tool with craftsmanship of a GB will be pleasing in and of itself.
So if I could only pick one tool to be lost in the woods with, I'd take my Work Champ first. I would also consider a Charge AL as well, but I don't actually have one, so I can't speak to that, but from what I know about them, I think it'd be the next most similar kind of tool.
If I could have two, then I definitely want an axe too, even my Fiskars would work, though of course I'd prefer to have the GB. From there, it's just typical stuff... saw, fixed blade, paracord, duct tape, etc.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
This is turning into a great thread guys! And I agree with boss-man; we all seem to have slightly different interpretations and preferences, but we're all thinking pretty much alike. It seems that a knife alone is one of the less useful things to have in a lost in the wood type of situation.I would really love to have GB small forest axe... it's at the top of my wish list for camping gear, but I know my wife would kill me for buying one. She just wouldn't understand why I'd need to spend $100+ for what would seem to her be nothing more than an overgrown hatchet...

I've been meaning to get Cody's book, but just never had a chance really. The outdoors skills classes I've taken were taught by people who've done Cody's training as well. Lots of good info, and I like his approach of working with the environment instead of against it. I like that about Les too, but I have a big problem with the way he does his editing... I mean, do we need a cut scene every 20 or 30 seconds? I mean come on... that's just gonna give me a seizure fer cryin' out loud!
Anyway, great thread! Keep it comin'! :)
Funnily it was my wife that bought me my SFA. :D
@Syph007 said:
The one think that bugs me about all the 'pros' with their survival knives is that thy seem to think that battening through wood is a must. Come on. First of all, where do these hardcore guys find all this nicely sawed logs to baton in the woods anyway anyway. The first time I saw someone do this I thought they were crazy. A good axe can do a hell of a lot of tasks, from tree felling, carving, game cleaning. I LOVE my granfors bruks small forest axe. For a cheaper option Estwings will last a lifetime.Somewhat regional though an axe in Canada is as to a machete in the jungle.
I still want to try one of these as a modern Rambo style knife.. its one piece but hollow. It will probably suck, but I need to get one to know for sure.
http://www.knifecenter.com/item/SCHF1SM/schrade-extreme-survival-special-forces-5
totally agree with this.
There are excellent reasons that different tools are popular in different environments, axes in temperate regions and machete's etc in more tropical areas. That said I don't mind being out and about without an axe, but I'll not go into the hills without a small sheath knife and, perhaps even more vital for survival, a good folding saw. -
Tosh, if you think I'm being slanderous in that post then you obviously have not seen my posts talking about the crap from Taylor Cutlery or United. I stand by what I say and I challenge anyone I have slandered to prove me wrong.
In fact, the Les Stroud Knives appear to be better than I thought they'd be. Unfortunately there were only mock ups at SHOT so I was unable to see the finished product but the specs sounded good. The reality is that I am not going to carry an overly bulky fixed blade with a sheath full of gadgets around all the time just in case the fan turns brown. I may keep it in a bug out bag, but if I have a bug out bag the it probably has the same stuff on the fancy sheath does, only in greater quantities. What I need to be able to survive with is what I have with me, which in many cases means a SAK and/or multitool.
I can be a lot more slanderous if you'd like though! >:)
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Tosh, if you think I'm being slanderous in that post then you obviously have not seen my posts talking about the crap from Taylor Cutlery or United. I stand by what I say and I challenge anyone I have slandered to prove me wrong.In fact, the Les Stroud Knives appear to be better than I thought they'd be. Unfortunately there were only mock ups at SHOT so I was unable to see the finished product but the specs sounded good. The reality is that I am not going to carry an overly bulky fixed blade with a sheath full of gadgets around all the time just in case the fan turns brown. I may keep it in a bug out bag, but if I have a bug out bag the it probably has the same stuff on the fancy sheath does, only in greater quantities. What I need to be able to survive with is what I have with me, which in many cases means a SAK and/or multitool.
I can be a lot more slanderous if you'd like though! >:)
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
Hi DEF
I'm sure you can...lol.
Hope I don't get on the wrong side of you!!

TBH I care not a jot about L/S knives and if the truth be told I don't even know what a L/S knife looks like.
I was merely surprised that you were so blatantly and publically slating the guy's products. I've always assumed there to be some form of mutual protocol on forums where we all in general try to avoid potentially damaging or slanderous remarks. As with any purchase, we all have a choice of wether we buy or we don't buy. If enough people refuse to buy his product then he'll either go out of business or hopefully better still learn his lesson and "up his game" and relaunch a better product we do want to buy.Given hindsight, maybe I shouldn't have posted my original comment - sorry if I've annoyed you in any way Def. I can always retract/alter the comment if you so wish.
Apologies

Tosh
-
I don't think Def has a bad side Tosh. You'll find that in general this forum fosters an atmosphere that allows us to all be honest even if our opinions are negative towards a particular product.
This is the very best part of this forum.
-
Ya this is one of the few forums where you can express strong opionions both good and bad, and not get bashed for it. Its nice! Like.. freedom!
-
Not to worry Tosh- your comments are welcome here. As the other guys have said, I am happy to have folks express opinions no matter which direction they go.
Perhaps I didn't explain myself properly though. The specs on the Les Stroud knives make them sound like they will be decent knives, and I have yet to encounter one in person to alter that thought in any way. I only used them as an example of the types of knives that I have issues with, largely because it was a discussion Bob and I had after leaving the Camillus booth at SHOT. My issue is not with the abilities of the knives themselves, be they Bear Grylls knives, Les Stroud knives or just survival knives in general, it's with the concept that the "survival" is in the knife, not the person.
Some people will survive whether they have a survival knife or not. Others will not, even with the most expensive survival knife on the market. I don't like the idea that companies promote by offering survival type knives, and that if you buy that knife you'll be safe from anything. I think the money would be better spent on a case of freeze dried food and water purifiers, then depend on your SAK for any knife needs you may have.
Buying a special knife to keep you alive in SHTF type situations in my opinion is a waste of money- and in no way is aimed directly at Les Stroud, Bear Grylls, Ray Mears, Rambo or anyone else. Buying a good knife to have and use on a daily basis that you'll also have handy in case of a SHTF type situation makes a heck of a lot more sense.
That was my point. Although I will say this, the day the dump truck full of cash rolls up to my door, I guarantee you'll be seeing a Defender line of survival tools too. My integrity is important to me, but so are gold plated supermodels lounging by the pool. >:D
Def
-
I did the whole rambo knife thing back in the 80's , it has stuck in my mind even to this day and still love tactical agressive looking sawback knives, but back then it was more free and easy and i think its all been done, for me i prefer a more solid type of knife or more uk pratical , these are my set ups,
does what i need,



-
I did the whole rambo knife thing back in the 80's

Pictures or it did not happen!!!:D
no pics mate , it was a secret group ;) amazing though that we ran around local woods with these knives, i had a huge bowie once i carried, oh to be young agian, and back to the 80's :Dthis was one of my rambo knife of choice back in the 80's

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



