Why any other knife?
-
In order of primary blade use, I carry a Select Fire, Charge TTi and a Vic Climber. I've never cut anything with the SAK, and nearly everything with the Select Fire. The Charge blade is good for more delicate cutting (cables, tape, etc) but the Kershaw is much better at bigger tasks like cutting apart boxes, large zip ties, hoses etc.
While I'm sure the SAK blade is capable, the Kershaw is more capable :)
Plus I'm a nail biter, and most of the time getting SAK blades or tools open is a massive PITA. OHO all the way for me :)
-
"Why any other knife?"
For the same reason that I carry several different tools in my tool box. Different tasks require different tools. I can't drive a nail with a screwdriver and I wouldn't drive a screw with a hammer. Different tools for different jobs. Simple.
Applying that analogy to the knives I carry is basically the same concept. For most urban tasks an SAK will be sufficient -- granted. However, should I need to deploy a knife for self defense I would most certainly want a tactical folder -- such as my constant companion, the Spyderco Paramilitary 2. I may not be driving a nail but I will definitely be driving a point. If you get my drift!
And then, of course, there is the "two is one and one is none" philosophy. Which I wholeheartedly subscribe to!
-
The same answer to "why more than one knife?".
-
Because I'm a knife knut not only a sak knut.
Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
I say to each thier own..I was for quite awhile a dedicated SAK only carrier unless I felt a Fixed Blade would be needed..One day about a year back I looked at all the knives I had and realized I had too many,so my two boys became the lucky recipients of a majority of my users..including many SAK's that I did not carry..One of the knives that made the cut was a GEC..I love SAK's and I love Tacticals,and I love the Traditional...If all there was in the world of cutlery was SAK's no matter how hard Vic/Wenger try it would get to be a pretty boring place
-
I love the Swisstool blade design better than any blade on any of my multitools. If only it was one-hand opening.
-
I carry a different knife every day. Why? Variety; just as I eat something different every day, I don't want the same knife in my pocket.
Another reason is that the spear point is probably my least favorite blade shape.
I have a decent sized collection of knives from Case, Buck, and GEC. I would say Vic puts out the most consistent, well finished knives, for their price. That said, I've never had to send any of the non-SAKs back for any problems.
-
It has already been mentioned, like a knife-junkie a have to love all knives

But vinox are my precious. -
I have a few Spyderco and Benchmade folders but none seem to cut as well as a 91mm Vic blade due to geometry. So I basically never carry them. If the blade on my SAK isn't strong enough for the task I then make the leap to a fixed blade knife. For camping I'll always bring a fixed blade, if only just a Mora.
-
A SAK meets 99% of my EDC needs. I also agree that they're the most consistent and high quality pocket-knife/multi-tool for the money. I've found the quality of their blades in particular to be very high quality, especially compared to the blades on even mid-range plier based MT's such as Gerber and Leatherman. I also find a SAK to be more pocket friendly, and to have tool-sets most appropriate to my needs.
I do still carry a folder most of the time, either in my EDC bag or in my pocket, as there are just some jobs that I don't like using a SAK for, even one with a large blade like my Outrider or Work Champ. I don't carry a fixed blade at all unless I'm camping or backpacking, and even then, I don't use it all that often. SAK's rock; they're the closest thing to a perfect knife/MT for me.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
- Mr. Whippy