Fixed blade advice needed...
-
If you want a beat on and take it all you can give it kind of knife for a good price I think the Ka-Bar Becker BK2 Campanion is good. Its a big slab of metal you can beat on.

Lots of higher end stuff, but if you arent sure you want to get into the fancy ones its a good start point IMO.
ESEE's are also good, but if you start going higher end than I prefer Fallkniven over ESEE, but ESEE are still damn fine blades. The only fixed blade I own still is a Fallkniven A1. I dont prefer the ESEE coated blades, too grippy for my tastes when cutting and they rust. Fallkniven is VG10 not coated and amazing...
-
I looked @ ESEE just for the skeletonized looks on Izula... I think that's a nice way to pack it in small pouch or something and forget about it untill you need it...
Mora's are great tools, and on my list. But not as Mora then as Bahco... Bahco 2444 that is... That one is exactly Mora, and sandvik steel (for what I know Mora produce them for Bahco)...
Well I presume there will not be much of battoning, if any at all... I presume I'll only try do that, just for fun of it and nothing else...
-
This Bahco is a rebranded Mora clipper.
Sold here for 6 to 8 Euro.
SS -
If I remember corectly price here is 650,00 din so it's tad less then 6eur...
IMHO great knife for that money!!!
-
All the nice things are cheaper in there.. Alcohol, cigarettes and now Knives too!! :D
-
@dks said:
All the nice things are cheaper in there.. Alcohol, cigarettes and now Knives too!! :DYea, but our wages are a lot lower to. :(
I'd advise the Mora combo too, but a Mora + folding saw combo. Great and light setup for the woods. I did play with the Bahco at a local hardware store, The blades are great, but I prefer the handles of a Mora Clipper. But still great knife for the money.
-
EDCgear,
I would go for the Moras great value knives
For some reason I have the idea that you have big hands :-\

If so you should try them out before buying and then have a look at the Hultafors that Zed has been using

-
I'm going to buck the trend here ...
Moras are great woodcraft/camping/outdoors knives, but if you're just looking for a fixed blade work knife, I'm not sure I would always go for a puukko style (even though that's what I have at the boat as an all purpose knife).
My options include Moras (plural), Cold Steel's Canadian Belt Knife, Bushman and Finn Bear for the cheapo options. A couple of slightly nicer puukkos by Iissaki Jaavenpaa and Brusletto, and a Muella stag handled Bowie and a Sheffield made MOD Survival Knife take up the middle ground, then a small 4"(ish) blade I made on a knife making course, a Raker skinning knife, and on order that's ready and waiting collection from a local maker make up the "upper" end of my options. There's a few smaller options too such as a Buck Hartsook and CRKT Folts minimalist for use as neck knives.
I'd trust any of those knives in use, but not necessarily all for the same tasks. The cheap Cold Steel knives (even the puukko clones) tend to be slightly hollow ground with a secondary bevel, which I think is preferable over a puukko style scandi grind for general heavy work rather than woodcraft. Plus they're cheap so it doesn't matter if I over do it and cause them damage. The hollow grind does make it a little easier to resharpen, but doesn't give it the strongest edge though
What do you expect having to use the knife for?
-
LOL good Q 50ft....
Nothing much TBH... More or less backup!
I think on EDCing slipjoint knives, they are just right for most daily jobs I use knife for... So I sale/traded all OHO/blade locking/tactical/heavy duty folders...
Fixed blade should be there for ocasional cutting tasks, as a "car" knife... Maybe right word would be BOB knife, but it's not that I'm building BOB... Occasional trip to the nature, BBQ, garden and backyard tasks...
That's why I mentioned ESEE Izula, they are slim and skeletonized, so you can put it in... Maxpedition Jumbo rear pocket and... Leave it there!!
Also I stumbled upon Becker BK 14 EsKaBar - looks nice, and tad cheaper than ESEE...
At the end I'll maybe ask my friend knife maker to make me one skeletonized knife....
-
Whilst they look nice a skeletonised knife wouldn't be my choice for a back up knife for the car.
They are that way to save weight, but comfort (and maybe even strength) can be compromised. Personally I'd look for a full tang knife with wooden handles and a secondary bevel ... but I'm a sucker for the traditional :P I wouldn't spend a lot of money for a knife in that role either ... I'd rather save it for something I'm going to have more fun with :)
Here are the kind of things I'd be looking at ... depending on the potential tasks, and conditions. Be prepared to have to refine the handles a little to suit your own grip on some of them. You might find these aren't what you have in mind, they're just examples of what I might rummage through for that role

http://www.heinnie.com/Condor-Sapiens/p-0-92-6460/
http://www.heinnie.com/Puma-IP-Denia/p-0-92-6458/
http://www.heinnie.com/Knives/John-Nowill-Knives/John-Nowill-Rigging-Knife/p-92-153-1153/
http://www.heinnie.com/Knives/John-Nowill-Knives/John-Nowill-Survival-Knife/p-92-153-1159/
http://www.heinnie.com/Ka-Bar-Knives/Fixed-Blade-Knives/Ka-Bar-Marine-Hunter/p-155-998-4135/
http://www.heinnie.com/Gerber-Knives/Fixed-Blade-Knives/Gerber-Big-Rock-Camp-Knife/p-144-996-4279/
http://www.heinnie.com/Gerber-Knives/Fixed-Blade-Knives/Gerber-Gator-Machete-/p-144-996-4285/
http://www.heinnie.com/Cold-Steel-Knives/Fixed-Blade-Knives/Cold-Steel-Kukri-Machete/p-127-973-4024/
http://www.heinnie.com/Cold-Steel-Knives/Fixed-Blade-Knives/Cold-Steel-Outdoorsman-Light/p-127-973-6639/Just a random assortment

-
Nice....
Out of all I like John Nowill most!!
-
Nice collection there Al
I also like the John Nowill
I've been thinking about this a bit more, I would go for something like a Stainless Mora,
As its not going to see much use there's no point in tying up a lot of money is something you are only going to play with now an then
There's going to be a lot of condensation in the car depending on the season so I would want stainless
So I would probably end up with a machete :-[ >:D
-
Out of all I like John Nowill most!!
You'll definitely need to refine the handles a little then

(they sell them "unfinished" so you can sand them to suit you - common practice with many fixed blades round this neck of the woods)
@sparky415 said:
Nice collection there Al
I also like the John Nowill
I've been thinking about this a bit more, I would go for something like a Stainless Mora,
As its not going to see much use there's no point in tying up a lot of money is something you are only going to play with now an then
There's going to be a lot of condensation in the car depending on the season so I would want stainless
**So I would probably end up with a machete ** :-[ >:D
:D :D :D
-
@sparky415 said:
Nice collection there Al
I also like the John Nowill
I'll bring my MOD knife to the meet Tony so you can have a play

-
@50ft-trad said:
Nice collection there Al
I also like the John Nowill
I'll bring my MOD knife to the meet Tony so you can have a play

Thanks

I will bring some sandpaper :D
-
I did try using Farmman's belt sander briefly, but it kind of got a bit of a stammer
so it does need tidying up
I've just not got round to sorting it :-[ -
I can wait :D Main thing I'm waiting for is to collect my "other" order :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
Esee or Mora 223
Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
@50ft-trad said:
http://www.heinnie.com/Cold-Steel-Knives/Fixed-Blade-Knives/Cold-Steel-Kukri-Machete/p-127-973-4024/Heh, funny how the item that most guys bought after this:

was this:

:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login