Grip strength
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
If any of you out there have a bathroom scale (the old spring kind at least), any feedback on grip strength? Also, if you could check a second number. If you hold the scale between your palms and squeeze it with both palms toward the middle, what's the reading? This would be like using both hands on the handles of a MT.Anyone care to give me some data here?
If the handles touch it is not really a problem, provided the pliers work ok and the handles go back to their original shape after you release them (spring back).
For example, the pliers handles of my Schrade, US made, tough tool will touch if squeezed hard, but they spring back when released. The New ones, as found out by J-sews at the shot show, will touch and then stay bent.
Grip strength is not allways proportional to size, since it depends on actual leverage and training of the involved muscles. Some people naturally have a strong grip.
Or, you could just be Super-strong. :D
I assume someone will give you feedback on the bathroom scales method soon.

-
If they sprang back normally, and it was from flexing through the frame, I wouldn't have a problem. They're flexing at a point where the plier heads attach to the tool's frame, because the connecting screw is bowing under the force. I can't imagine them lasting long with that kind of movement.
My point in this is how much is 'normal' grip strength, and what should tools be able to handle within normal limits.
Okay... I admit it... I'm She-hulk. :D
-
This is a very good post because it touches a lack of faith I've always had about MTs: I just can't seem to trust any brand when it comes to the strength of the handles and pivot points attaching the plier heads. Maybe a Leatherman, Vic or SOG could take the lugnut off a Mack truck, but I just wonder...
-
This points out the limitations of pliers based MT's (not all, but most), as Biru points out.
The pivot point for folding MT's is a weak point and will always be in comparison to a dedicated pliers forged in tool steel, where the handle and pliers jaws are one single forged piece, with a central pivot.
The other thing I find is that the jaws distort more easily on a MT when twisting around the long axis. Again, I think it's a function of the size and construction of the jaws pivot, more than the actual materials in the jaws deforming.
Re: Grip strength. If you want to see REAL grip strength, go to a climbing gym or crag. Some of those guys can pinch a rock with one hand and do pull ups. That's gotta be at least 150 lbs grip strength and probably much more.
-
A well known tool designer once suggested to me that folding pliers weren't weaker than fixed pliers. He didn't go into details but he seems to be pretty well versed in materials and relative strengths so I would tend to give him some credit, even though I am skeptical.
When it comes to the cheaper brands there tends to be less engineering involved and thinner/cheaper materials meaning higher loads on.lesser sections. Your Husky brand tool is likely a lot less robust than most name brand tools because of the lack of engineering going into it. There's more to designing a multitool than sticking two Swiss Army Knives into some folded sheet metal and bolting them to a plier head, despite what some folks think.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Re: Grip strength. If you want to see REAL grip strength, go to a climbing gym or crag. Some of those guys can pinch a rock with one hand and do pull ups. That's gotta be at least 150 lbs grip strength and probably much more.Yup for sure. I remember the gym I used to frequent when I was an avid climber, had a regular there that could do a pull up with one arm, and only one finger of that arm in a hole. I was impressed. The best I could do at that time was two armed pull up with 1 finger of each hand in a hold.
-
Grant, exactly.
If >I< can look at a tool and in about 3 minutes figure out a major design flaw, the folks that assemble these things (the cheapos) didn't put much thought into them... OR DID, and made decisions based on cost to produce (which is probably much more likely).
Anyway... discussing rock climbers doesn't get me data. Go get me data! :D
-
There's actually a huge story on cheap tools, why they are the way they are and what the folks in China think of them, but since I'm at work now I really can't go into it. Suffice it to say, its not as simple as you think.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
If they sprang back normally, and it was from flexing through the frame, I wouldn't have a problem. They're flexing at a point where the plier heads attach to the tool's frame, because the connecting screw is bowing under the force. I can't imagine them lasting long with that kind of movement.My point in this is how much is 'normal' grip strength, and what should tools be able to handle within normal limits.
Okay... I admit it... I'm She-hulk. :D
An all-green, scantily dressed, furious female?

-
Okay, I admit it... I'm the She-Abomination. That better?
NO ONE wants a picture of me, least of all me.
-
I think this ballpark method isn't going to give you the info you need as different muscles are used to grip different shaped objects but just for the record mine was 93lb.
-
Dunno I'm doing it right since it's very awkward to squeeze a bathroom scale, but I got 120 lb, but the other two hand method is actually less, only 100 or so.
I'm always conservative when it comes to tools, if I feel it flex I go get a bigger one.
-
The two hand method is testing pectoral's and bicep's strength.
So, start benching!
-
Yes, this is awkward, no it's not super-scientific, but I think it's the best I can do on 0 budget.
I suspect it will favor people with larger hands, but I have to start somewhere, and unless someone wants to spend 200 bucks for a hand Dynamometer and put it on the pass-around list... well, this is what I've got to work with.
Also, my 2-handed squeeze was 137lbs. Interesting.
-
Should I ask when you DO wear spandex Jie?
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
-
Lol, I was going to say I don't, but then I realized I actually do. Only as base layer for skiing though, never on the outside. :D
-
Saving it for the locker room huh. I understand wink wink nudge nudge!
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
-
I just tried it with my digital bathroom scale and it displayed "ERR". Perhaps I'm too strong for it :D or maybe too weak :ahhh
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login