Survival Knives
-
@50ft-trad said:
I made a handle for a stick chopper which was smooth like the bushman
I found that your hand gets tired after a while as you have to grip it tighter to stop it twisting in your hand :(
So I think that its really a spear that you can use as a knife...... or maybe it needs a good wrap around the handle?
i have the bowie and standard version of the bushman and you need to use a light ring grip on it like with a khukhri. Nice light knife, but first task in a survival situation (or where extensive woodcraft is required) would be to fashion a wooden extension for the handl to move the weight forward. I dug holes with it for tarp stakes at the last meet, and a quick flick with a steel and it was good to go again. A nice light back up blade for when you don't expect to need a big blade but want to be prepared anyway or feel you need a spare. Used within it's limits and with knowledge of how to get the most out of it, you'll struggle to find a stronger and more capable knife for the weight penalty
Al,
I'm not bashing it just because its Cold Steel I actually like quite a lot of their stuff IE their Kukri
Its just that as I get older I want my tools to fit in my hand better, I just feel like its lacking something
totally agree mate, it is lacking something ... A wooden handle extension :-D
i wouldn't call them a primary knife for any situation, but as a backup I think it's a good choice. I reckon the standard blade would make the better spear
-
Blackbird SK-5 as a spear. :)

A more information How to Choose the Perfect Survival Knife: http://artofmanliness.com/2011/11/29/how-to-choose-the-perfect-survival-knife/
-
@Vadim said:
Blackbird SK-5 as a spear. :)
A more information How to Choose the Perfect Survival Knife: http://artofmanliness.com/2011/11/29/how-to-choose-the-perfect-survival-knife/
In general attaching a knife on the end of a stick as a spear is not really a good idea.
Because if you stick into an animal and said animal runs off into the wilderness with your spear, you have no knife. It also possible that you macho thrusting movements hit rock and other hard option... no good for edges or tips. much better to simply sharpen the stick so its nice and pointy, harden it in afire, use bone or scrap metal as an alternative. If it breaks after killing the animal so be it... make another oneTimes when attaching a knife to a stick is a good idea
- cut folage and vines out of reach
- To harvest fruit/nuts/etc out of reach
- To steal honeycombs (saw david canterbury do that
- To finish off a 'trapped' critter, you may have successfully snared a pig/weasel/kangaroo/large-lizard but adding a bit of reach to your mercy kill is a good idea... even small animal wounds can turn septic and get infected (argubly a sharp stick would work here too...)
Having a dedicated knife only for spear work like the CS bushman is a different matter. That more of a dedicated spear head than a knife (Although for now i am going to be
stronga and save up for an actual CS boar spear)Today i went round neard the nature strip and fashioned a gaff/harpoon spear from bamboo with nothing but a CS shovel

-
I find the Condor bushcraft knives very appealing. While more expensive than a Mora, I like that they have thicker blades and come with a very nice leather sheath, and are available in several different sizes. The Rodan and Varan are the two I like best.
-
I feel there are many great options out there for "Survival Knives" but I really like what Charles Karwan always said on the subgect myself..
I admit to having a Buckmaster..My Youngest decided after aquiring it during my "Paring Down of the Blades"he liked his Gerber BMF better..I have used it out and about and have found it to be rather sturdy..Would it be my first choice? I doubt it,but I beleive there are a few good Hollow Handled Knives available..
I believe and look at the hollow handle as holding a last ditch "OMG I have lost everything Except the Clothes on my Back and my Buckmaster Kit"...
Just my two cents
-
I wonder if Condor is like Tramotina. I don't own any tramotina simply because i found you can buy them cheaper internationally than locally in brazil. (At least in rio de janeiro, if you made a special trip into the city you may find it cheaper)
-
There are just so many variables , seasons , areas . Leaving electronics out of it for the moment ( not being a total fool I would use if available ) , something like a Spirit or a Farmer plus my GB hatchet would be my choice , if possible I would try to stash a redundant or two in my pack .
In an Urban scenario , a stout folder, and a SAK or multi would be my choice .
Just too many variables to make any hard and fast rules .
Chris
-
Of all the "survival" knives(fived blade) I've ecountered. The best, for its price, is the Cold Steel Bushman series!!

Those things are CRAZY SHARPE!!!!!
-
I know a lot of folks don't like Cold Steel, and I know the Bushman is really not a premium model, but dollar for dollar I think you would be very hard pressed to come up with a better knife than the Bushman.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I know a lot of folks don't like Cold Steel, and I know the Bushman is really not a premium model, but dollar for dollar I think you would be very hard pressed to come up with a better knife than the Bushman.Def
It's worth every penny!!

-
The bushman is tempered very soft so it wouldn't break when used as spear, CS does have a couple other models around the same price, though I don't know if they are any harder.
-
The bushman is tempered very soft so it wouldn't break when used as spear, CS does have a couple other models around the same price, though I don't know if they are any harder.
Why would you need it harder? what task requires it to be so ridgid??? ???
Softer steels dull faster.
-
The bushman is tempered very soft so it wouldn't break when used as spear, CS does have a couple other models around the same price, though I don't know if they are any harder.
Why would you need it harder? what task requires it to be so ridgid??? ???
Softer steels dull faster.
But easier to resharpen!!
-
A friend of mine who is heavily involved in Scouting purchased a few a ways back as utility knifes for Camp outs and Such..He has nothing but praise for them starting with cost!
Myself, I also look at my Estwing Hunter's Hatchet as a "Survival Knife"..I keep it hair shaving sharp and have found out with a bit of patience and care it will substitute nicely especially if paired with a decent SAK or Folder for the really detailed work..Just last week I peeled a bunch of Potatoes with the Estwing...It was not pretty but it got done
and I guess that is all that really matters if things have suddenly gone southDtrain
Dtrain
-

I guess thats why i'm in the machete camp in the axe-vs-machete armchair wars. Knife tasks are little more 'plausible'
i did had a rabbit trap setters hatchet when i was young that i found in the old shed of house we bought. Loved it. Sleek little blade profile, light and had a hammer/pry on the reverse. Wouldn't mind pimping one out if i found one for penuts.
Truth is though i much prefer my twelve inch 'Facão' (downsized from eighteen, sounds dirty doesn't it) The reality though is if i'm stuck somewhere i will more likely have my CS Shovel. Been quite happy with its capabilities -
I guess thats why i'm in the machete camp in the axe-vs-machete armchair wars. Knife tasks are little more 'plausible'
i did had a rabbit trap setters hatchet when i was young that i found in the old shed of house we bought. Loved it. Sleek little blade profile, light and had a hammer/pry on the reverse. Wouldn't mind pimping one out if i found one for penuts.
Truth is though i much prefer my twelve inch 'Facão' (downsized from eighteen, sounds dirty doesn't it) The reality though is if i'm stuck somewhere i will more likely have my CS Shovel. Been quite happy with its capabilitiesI've been having a similar debate with myself for a while, and took a few different options to the UK meet to play with. The Cold Steel Shovel does throw well and stick in logs quite deep, but you need to carry round a Scottish forum moderator to throw it for you. As regards other functions I didn't like using it as an axe as whilst it bit deep it also announced its work quite loudly and stuck in the wood on every swing.
I have been an axe fan for a while now and could use a Gransfors Bruks Wildlife Hatchet for many knife tasks. I also took a Vaughan Mini Hatchet which provoked great swathes of laughter and earned itself the nickname of "Baby's First Axe". As a knife it's an ulu on a stick, and reasonably capable for light tasks. It'll handle making tent pegs quite comfortably, but you'd certainly want something heavier duty to process an evenings firewood ideally. With knowledge, care and attention it is capable of heavier tasks though, and googling "old jimbo" will eventually lead you to a HUGE trunk of knotty hemlock he split with one ... just for the sake of it I think. I've had the Wildlife Hatchet and Vaughan Mini for a while now and like them both
The Chris Caine Survival Tool was VERY impressive, and worked BETTER than the Wildlife Hatchet for splitting and chopping. It was very good for cross cut battoning too, which makes splitting easier afterwards. The downside is that your hands and forearms do feel it after a bit of use, and I gave it quite a bit of hammer. Extended use with an axe would be less draining on the hand and arm ... but might take longer too. For carving etc it was large but reasonably well balanced, though it could do with the edge refining a little (or maybe just more practice) and the potential was certainly there for using as a drawknife and even a skinning knife, even though I was only debarking wood to get that appreciation. The back edge would do great if you needed a blunt instrument for smashing something (though I refrained on the ostrich egg as it would have gotten VERY messy). Would I carry it as a primary survival tool? Not unless I was expecting to NEED a super dooper fandango parang type knife. It's a GREAT tool, and it will get lots of work wood processing, but for firewood at the boat or when heavy brutal "gardening" tasks are needed. It's a tool for being static with rather than mobile, unless you're traversing a jungle or such like in my opinion.
The Anton De Plessis Warthog, also by Scorpion Knives was (to me) a far better knife for when mobile. Very ergonomic and durable, and a very good "compromise" between weight size and functionality. There's been a lot of thought gone into that item and it was very well made (as was the CC Survival Tool in my opinion)
A traditional Leuku was less impressive. Saami knives have been used for centuries in Scandinavia, and are proven tools for doing ... well, whatever needs doing really. It didn't fail at anything, and I found it very comfortable (but others didn't share my thoughts on that) however it didn't perform as well as the two Sheffield made knives - at least on the tasks I was attempting. It is actually a "piggyback" combo set with a smaller Puukko, but I felt that the Warthog was a perfect alternative to that pairing ... plus smaller and at not much more cost
I also decided it was time to get my Muela stag handled Jabali 17A dirty which I've had for a number of years. It's been sat nicely in it's sheath, inside the box, glittering when the urge to ogle arises ... but it was time to get vicious with it. With all the adverse comments you get about 400 series stainlesses from today's premium steel fans, I wasn't expecting too much from it, but what a bloody great knife! It chopped (though not heavily due to the modest blade length) and I crosscut battonned it through some pretty chunky and hard material, and the blade was still perfectly sharp enough for tent peg tasks after. When you remember that today's 400 series steels (depending on the steel mill and subsequent treatments) are WAY superior to the steels our ancestors were using, we really didn't ought to whine about them at all. If for any reason they do fail, I'd say 9/10 times it's the operator that failed to use the knife in line with sensible expectations rather than a failure of the tool.
Cold Steel Bushman ... took two but didn't use them as I've used them plenty before. Good backup tools - not for primary knife selection though. They'll do everything the others will but slower and with compromised comfort. If you're going to only take one big knife into whatever arena you're considering, the Bushman is probably not the one to take unless weight is a major restriction. If you're thinking of taking a second knife as back up, then I'd suggest that one of the Bushman (standard or Bowie) will do very nicely if you know how to glean the rewards from using it and work through the compromises. Great secondary tool.
None of these tools could be replaced by a SAK or multitool, but would be very well complimented by one. I'd still want my Bahco Laplander on me too if I was expecting to do any form of wood processing. Any of the knives and axes I've mentioned here would be excellent survival tools in the right hands, accompanied by the right knowledge. They'd only fill that role if you had them when you needed them though.
If I expected to be mobile and need wood processing I'd probably go for the Anton De Plessis Warthog or Wildlife Hatchet combined with a Laplander saw and multitool. If I was on a long hike and didn't expect to be doing processing unless the SHTF, I might take the Cold Steel Shovel. The Chris Caine Tool is a superb yard, wood stove, heavy landscaping, jungle tool ... but if I was at the boat and things went wrong, or even at home and things went wrong I might be very happy to have that with me. The Muela is still a bit too pretty to be primary but would work perfectly well (surprisingly well truth be told), and I'd also be happy with a Bushman in reserve. The biggest disappointment for me was the Leuku, which has been a mainstay primary tool for tribesmen and nomadic families for many many years. It wasn't that the Leuku was bad in any way whatsoever, but the others outperformed it on the day with the tasks undertaken
All the premium steel fanboys can keep their overpriced tripe. Give me a decent simple easy to sharpen blade any day. The ingredients, compositions and structure of the blade are far less important that the ingredients, composition and structure of the mind of the user anyway. I'll probably redo this write up with piccies on a separate thread at some point, but hopefully there's some useful info for folks in there as it is for now.
-
Remember, the Leuku isn't designed for chopping trees. In the core area of the Leuku, a big tree is still lower than yourself. :)
A Leuku is for the reindeer guys, people living in or near the Taiga and similar forests use a Puukko or a tollekniv combined with an axe instead.
Oh, and I just have to add my standard rant: Premium steel today usually means “highly abrasion resistant, and brittle as hell”, which really isn't what I'm personally looking for in a survival-ish knife. The hard use knives I own which I trust are made in A8-mod.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

:D



